Sociopolitical Sciences Issue №6 — 2020

Doctrine “counter-limits” and doctrine “ultra vires” in the context of protection of national constitutional identity
( Pp. 98-105)

DOI: 10.33693/2223-0092-2020-10-6-98-105

Belosludtsev Oleg Stanislavovich Cand.Sci.(Law), Sеnior lecturer of International and European Law Department, FAculty of Law
National Research Ogarev Mordovia State University
Saransk, Russian Federation

Abstract:

The article is devoted to the study of the connection between the doctrine of constitutional identity with the doctrine of “counter-limits” and the doctrine of “ultra vires”. All these concepts are applied in the practice of European constitutional courts in cases related to the resolution of conventionally constitutional conflicts. Since the doctrine of “constitutional identity” in domestic theory and practice is in its infancy, in the author’s opinion, it is necessary to take into account the foreign experience of protecting national constitutional identity. And also carefully consider all related concepts, such as the doctrine of counter-limits and the doctrine of “ultra vires”, paying special attention to the topic of their relationship. The author, analyzing the doctrine of “counter-limits” and the doctrine of “ultra vires”, comes to the conclusion that these doctrines, along with other instruments for protecting national constitutional identity (the doctrine of the margin of appreciation), can be used in relation to the dispute between the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation and the ECHR on “the right of the last word”.

How to Cite:

Belosludtsev O.S., (2020), DOCTRINE “COUNTER-LIMITS” AND DOCTRINE “ULTRA VIRES” IN THE CONTEXT OF PROTECTION OF NATIONAL CONSTITUTIONAL IDENTITY. Sociopolitical Sciences, 6 => 98-105.

Reference list:

Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Italii № 183/73 ot 27 dekabrya 1973 goda. Elektronnyy resurs . URL: http://www.giurcost.org/decisioni/1973/0183s-73.html (data obrashcheniya: 06.10.2020).
Reshenie Konstitutsionnogo suda Italii ot 22 oktyabrya 2014 goda № 238. Elektronnyy resurs . URL: http://www.qil-qdi.org/prova-3/ ftnref1 (data obrashcheniya: 06.10.2020).
Reshenie Federal nogo konstitutsionnogo suda Germanii ot 25 maya 1974 goda BverfGE 37, 271 2 BvL 52/71 Solange I - Beschlub. Elektronnyy resurs . URL: http:// https://law.utexas.edu/transnational/foreign-law-translations/german/case.php id 588 (data obrashcheniya: 06.10.2020).
Reshenie Federal nogo Konstitutsionnogo suda Germanii ot 30 iyunya 2009 goda. BVerfGE 123/267 Elektronnyy resurs . URL: https://www.bundesverfassungsgericht.de/DE/DasGericht/Zeitstrahl/zeitstrahl node.html (data obrashcheniya: 29.10.2020).
Reshenie Federal nogo Konstitutsionnogo suda Germanii BVerfGE 89, 155 (Maastricht/Maastrikht). Izbrannye resheniya Federal nogo Konstitutsionnogo Suda Germanii / Fond Konrada Adenauera v Rossiyskoy Federatsii; sost. YU. SHvabe, T. Gayssler. M.: Infotropik Media, 2018. S. 867-882.
Reshenie Federal nogo Konstitutsionnogo suda Germanii BVerfGE 123, 267 (Lissabon/Lissabon). Izbrannye resheniya Federal nogo Konstitutsionnogo Suda Germanii / Fond Konrada Adenauera v Rossiyskoy Federatsii; sost. YU. SHvabe, T. Gayssler. M.: Infotropik Media, 2018. S. 905-916.
Reshenie Federal nogo Konstitutsionnogo suda Germanii BVerfGE 126, 286 (Ultra-vires-Kontrolle Mangold / Kontrol aktov, prinyatykh s prevysheniem polnomochiy. Delo Mangol d ). Izbrannye resheniya Federal nogo Konstitutsionnogo Suda Germanii / Fond Konrada Adenauera v Rossiyskoy Federatsii; sost. YU. SHvabe, T. Gayssler. M.: Infotropik Media, 2018. S. 916-921.
Reshenie Federal nogo Konstitutsionnogo suda Germanii 2 BvR 1390/12 i drugie (Ultra vires-Kontrolle OMT / Kontrol aktov, prinyatykh s prevysheniem polnomochiy. Pryamye denezhnye operatsii). Izbrannye resheniya Federal nogo Konstitutsionnogo Suda Germanii / Fond Konrada Adenauera v Rossiyskoy Federatsii; sost. YU. SHvabe, T. Gayssler. M.: Infotropik Media, 2018. S. 935-946.
Postanovlenie Evropeyskogo Suda Spravedlivosti ot 15 iyulya 1964 goda, Costa/Enel, C-6/64 Elektronnyy resurs . URL: https://eulaw.ru/translation/kosta-protiv-enel/ (data obrashcheniya: 06.10.2020).
Postanovlenie ESPCH ot 29.10.2013 po delu Varvara protiv Italii Varvara v. Italy (zhaloba № 17475/09) Elektronnyy resurs . Dostup iz sprav.-pravovoy sistemy Garant .
Blokhin P.D. Sudebnaya doktrina konstitutsionnoy identichnosti: genezis, problemy, perspektivy // Sravnitel noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie. 2018. № 6 (127). S. 67.
Gracheva S.A. Razvitie kontsepta konstitutsionnoy identichnosti v svyazi s poiskom podkhodov k razresheniyu konventsionno-konstitutsionnykh kolliziy i konfliktov // ZHurnal rossiyskogo prava. 2018. № 9. S. 59.
Zor kin V.D. Bukva i dukh Konstitutsii // Rossiyskaya gazeta. 9 oktyabrya 2018. № 226.
Ispolinov A.S. Rossiya i ESPCH: neskol ko slov v zashchitu Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF Elektronnyy resurs . URL.: https://zakon.ru/blog/2015/07/21/rossiya i espch neskolko slov v zashhitu konstitucionnogo suda rf (data obrashcheniya: 10.11.2020).
Ispolinov A.S. Eto est ikh posledniy i reshitel nyy boy Konstitutsionnye sudy Evropy protiv evropeyskikh mezhdunarodnykh sudov Elektronnyy resurs . URL.: https://https://zakon.ru/blog/ 2017/2/20/eto est ih poslednij i reshitelnyj boj konstitucionnye sudy evropy protiv evropejskih mezhdunarodnyh (data obrashcheniya: 10.11.2020).
Filatova M.A. Konflikty konstitutsionnykh i nadnatsional nykh norm: sposoby preodoleniya (na primere Evropeyskogo Soyuza i pravovykh sistem gosudarstv - chlenov ES) // Mezhdunarodnoe pravosudie. 2013. № 4. S. 94-106.
Dickmann R. Corte costituzionale e controlimiti al. diritto internazionale. Ancora sulle relazioni tra ordinamento costituzionale e Cedu // Focus Human Rights. № 3/2013 Elektronnyy resurs . URL: www.federalismi.it (data obrashcheniya: 10.11.2020).
Cannizzaro E., Palchetti P. Ultra vires acts of international organizations. In: Research handbook on the law of international organizations. UK: Northampton; MA: Edward Elgar, 2011. P. 365.
Itzcovich G. Sovereignty, legal pluralism and fundamental rights: Italian jurisprudence and European integration (1964-1973) (July 21, 2011) // European Public Law. 2004. Vol. 10. No. 1. P. 111. Available at SSRN Elektronnyy resurs . URL: https://ssrn.com/abstract 1892337 (data obrashcheniya: 10.11.2020).

Keywords:

constitutional identity, conventionally constitutional conflicts, constitutional review, the right to the last word, the doctrine of counter-limits, the doctrine of the margin of appreciation, the doctrine of “ultra vires”, the German Constitutional Court, the Italian Constitutional Court, the European Court of Human Rights.

1. Political Science Pages: 6-10 Issue №6215

CURRENT TRENDS IN UNIVERSAL HUMAN RIGHTS SYSTEM: MODERNISATION OR DEGRADATION?

Abashidze Aslan Husejnovich

human rights values The United Nations Treaty bodies on human rights The Committee on human rights

3. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 127-131 Issue №12435

Constitutional Risks of Russia's recognition of the priority of an International Treaty before a National Law and ways of overcoming them in the Doctrine of the Constitutional Identity of the State

Popova Iuliia Yurievna

constitutional risk constitutional identity universally recognized principles and norms of international law international Treaty constitutional control

10. International law; European Law; Corporate law; Energy law Pages: 260-262 Issue №4982

Nature and organizational framework of the European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice of Council of Europe

Gurbanov Ramin Afad ogly

The Council Of Europe The Commission competence The European court of human rights Convention

15. MISCELLANEOUS Pages: 306-312 Issue №18933

On the Role of the Constitutional Court in Criminal Proceedings in the Light of Amendments to the Constitution of the Russian Federation

Panfilov Pavel O.

the Constitutional Court the European Court of Human Rights the new circumstances the Constitutionality of the amendments to the Constitution

8. Judicial, prosecutorial, human rights and law enforcement activities Pages: 236-239 Issue №4539

To the question about the concept and the essence of the legal status of the Russian Prosecutor's Office

Gogolevskiy Alexander Vladimirovich

Legal status legal status the legality The Constitution Of The Russian Federation principles

9. Forensics; Forensic expertise; Operational and search activities Pages: 178-182 Issue №9342

IS IT ALWAYS A PANACEA OPERATIONAL EXPERIMENT TO EXPOSE CORRUPT?

Potapov Ilya Nikolaevich

Derevyanko Elena Olegovna

operational experiment bribe commercial bribery operatively-search activity The European Court of human rights

8. Criminal procedure Pages: 190-193 Issue №8046

The principle of the presumption of innocence in the jurisprudence of the European Court human rights

Khmelnitskaya Oksana Yurievna

the presumption of innocence Convention for the protection of human rights and fundamental freedoms international legal standards of criminal procedure The European Court of human rights the principle of justice

5. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 123-125 Issue №11287

TO THE QUESTION OF JUSTICE APPLICATIONCRIMINAL PROTECTION MEASURES

Rudich Valery V.

measure the accused a fair hearing The European Court of human rights criminal proceedings

9. CIVIL LAW; ENTREPRENEURIAL LAW; FAMILY LAW; INTERNATIONAL PRIVATE LAW Pages: 133-135 Issue №11740

THE CASE-LAW OF THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS: FORMATION OF A SECURITY STANDARD FOR THE ACTIVITIES OF BODIES INTERNAL AFFAIRS FOR THE PROTECTION OF PUBLIC ORDER AND SECURITY

Gadaborshev Ruslan T.

The European court of human rights public safety public order security the bodies of internal Affairs

1. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 25-29 Issue №13916

ROLE OF UKRAINE'S CONSTITUTIONAL COURT IN PROTECTING HUMAN RIGHTS TO HEALTH

Shvets Yuri Yu.

Constitutional Court constitutional review constitutional jurisdiction right to health protection protection of law

Doctrine “counter-limits” and doctrine “ultra vires” in the context of protection of national constitutional identity
( Pp. 98-105)

Related Articles

Journal Indexing

Doctrine “counter-limits” and doctrine “ultra vires” in the context of protection of national constitutional identity ( Pp. 98-105)

Related Articles

Journal Indexing

Doctrine “counter-limits” and doctrine “ultra vires” in the context of protection of national constitutional identity
( Pp. 98-105)