Constitutional Risks of Russia's recognition of the priority of an International Treaty before a National Law and ways of overcoming them in the Doctrine of the Constitutional Identity of the State
( Pp. 127-131)
More about authors
Popova Iuliia Yurievna
kand. yurid. nauk. Dolzhnost: docent. Mesto raboty: Dalnevostochnyy federalnyy universitet. Podrazdelenie: kafedra konstitucionnogo i administrativnogo prava.
Far Eastern Federal University
Far Eastern Federal University
Abstract:
The article is devoted to Constitutional Risks associated with fixing in the Constitution of Russia priority of the international treaty before the Law of the Russian Federation. Author cites as an example of the adverse consequences of such recognition the individual decisions of the European Court of Human Rights handed down against Russia. The Doctrine of Constitutional Identity applied by the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation is being analyzed to overcome the constitutional risks arising in connection with Russia's obligation to implement the ECHR decisions.
How to Cite:
Popova I.Y., (2018), CONSTITUTIONAL RISKS OF RUSSIA'S RECOGNITION OF THE PRIORITY OF AN INTERNATIONAL TREATY BEFORE A NATIONAL LAW AND WAYS OF OVERCOMING THEM IN THE DOCTRINE OF THE CONSTITUTIONAL IDENTITY OF THE STATE. Gaps in Russian Legislation, 4 => 127-131.
Reference list:
Alekhina L.N. O definitsii riska / L.N. Alekhina, T.O. Dyukina, YU.V. SHilenko // Nauka i mir. 2014. №8. S.89-90.
Aranovskiy K.V. Usloviya soglasovaniya praktiki mezhdunarodnogo i konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya // ZHurnal konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya. 2013. №3(33). S.1-10.
Blankenagel A. Proshchay, Sovet Evropy ili Sovet Evropy, davay pogovorim Kommentariy k Postanovleniyu Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossii ot 19 aprelya 2016 goda ob ispolnimosti Postanovleniya ESPCH po delu Anchugova i Gladkova ot 4 iyulya 2013 goda // Sravnitel noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie. 2016. №6. S. 135-150.
Blankenagel A., Levin I.G. V printsipe nel zya, no mozhno . Konstitutsionnyy Sud Rossii i delo ob obyazatel nosti resheniy Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka // Sravnitel noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie. 2015. №5. S.152-162.
Vasil eva T.A. Printsip uvazheniya natsional noy identichnosti gosudarstv - chlenov ES: problemy interpretatsii // Konstitutsionnoe i munitsipal noe pravo. 2017. №6. S.9-12.
Vitruk N.V. Ispolnenie resheniy Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka o priznanii narusheniya Rossiyskoy Federatsiey Konventsii o zashchite prav cheloveka i osnovnykh svobod // Rossiyskoe pravosudie. 2011. №11. S. 39-48.
Gavrilov V.V. Ponyatie i vzaimodeystvie mezhdunarodnoy i natsional nykh pravovykh sistem. M., 2018. 224 s.
Dolzhikov A. Gordost i predubezhdenie : sorazmernost polnogo konstitutsionnogo zapreta zaklyuchennym golosovat v Rossii. Postanovlenie Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka ot 4 iyulya 2013 goda // Mezhdunarodnoe pravosudie. 2013. №4. S.11-31.
Dudin M.N., Lyasnikov N.V., Ivashchenko N.P., Frolova E.E. Rossiya v sisteme mirovoy ekonomiki i mezhdunarodnykh svyazey v usloviyakh innovatsionnoy transformatsii sotsial no-ekonomicheskikh sistem. Monografiya // M., Rusayns, s. 194
Dudin M.N., Sekerin V.D., Smirnova O.O., Frolova E.E., Sepiashvili E.N. State anti-crisis management of banking sector: looking for optimization ways and contemporary development trends // Journal of advanced research in law and economics, 2014, № 5, vol. 2, p. 74-81
Zenin A.A. Konsul tativnye zaklyucheniya Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka i Protokol №16 k Konventsii (k istorii voprosa) // Rossiyskiy ezhegodnik evropeyskoy konventsii po pravam cheloveka. M., 2015. S. 398-415.
Zor kin V.D. Konstitutsionnaya identichnost Rossii: doktrina i praktika // ZHurnal konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya. 2014. №4(58). S.1-18.
Zor kin V.D. Predel ustupchivosti // Rossiyskaya gazeta. 29.10.2010. №5325.
Zor kin V.D. Sut prava // ZHurnal konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya. 2014. №5(59). S.1-11.
Ermakov S.L., Frolova E.E. Osnovy vnutribankovskogo antikrizisnogo upravleniya i regulirovaniya bankovskikh riskov // Izvestiya IGEA, 2011, № 6, s. 49-58;
Kireev V.V. Kategoriya riska v rossiyskoy konstitutsionno-pravovoy nauke // Problemy prava. 2013. №2(40). S.30-37.
Knyazev S.D. Stabil nost Konstitutsii i ee znachenie dlya sovremennogo rossiyskogo konstitutsionalizma // Konstitutsionnoe i munitsipal noe pravo. 2015. №1. S.4-12.
Kovler A.I. Sootnoshenie evropeyskogo i natsional nogo prava - obostrenie problemy // Rossiyskiy ezhegodnik evropeyskoy konventsii po pravam cheloveka. M., 2015. S.19-64.
Kokotov A.N. O nekotorykh izmeneniyakh zakonodatel stva o Konstitutsionnom Sude Rossiyskoy Federatsii // ZHurnal konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya. 2014. №5(59). S.15-19.
Marochkin S.YU. Deystvie i realizatsiya norm mezhdunarodnogo prava v pravovoy sisteme Rossiyskoy Federatsii: Monografiya. M., 2011. 288 s.
CHerkashin M.D. Fenomen riska v sovremennom obshchestve i novaya rol nauki // Filosofskie i kul turologicheskie aspekty sovremennogo sotsial no-gumanitarnogo znaniya. 2013. №1-2. S.16-20.
Frolova E.E. Risk-orientirovannyy podkhod v formirovanii organizatsiey politiki upravleniya riskami // Pravozashchitnik, 2016, № 2, s.1
Gadzhiev G.A. Konstitutsionnaya identichnost i prava cheloveka v Rossii : Ofitsial nyy sayt Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiyskoy Federatsii. http://www.ksrf.ru/ru/News/Documents/report D0 93 D0 B0 D0 B4 D0 B6 D0 B8 D0 B5 D0 B2 20 2016.pdf (data obrashcheniya: 24.02.2018).
Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti stat i 14.1 Federal nogo zakona O pogrebenii i pokhoronnom dele i Polozheniya o pogrebenii lits, smert kotorykh nastupila v rezul tate presecheniya sovershennogo imi terroristicheskogo akta, v svyazi s zhaloboy grazhdan K.I. Guzieva i E.KH. Karmovoy : Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo suda ot 28 iyunya 2007 goda № 8 - P // Rossiyskaya gazeta. 04.07.2007. № 4404.
Osoboe mnenie sud i Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiyskoy Federatsii K.V. Aranovskogo po delu o razreshenii voprosa o vozmozhnosti ispolneniya v sootvetstvii s Konstitutsiey Rossiyskoy Federatsii postanovleniya Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka ot 31 iyulya 2014 goda po delu OAO Neftyanaya kompaniya YUKOS protiv Rossii v svyazi s zaprosom Ministerstva yustitsii Rossiyskoy Federatsii : Ofitsial nyy sayt Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF. http://doc.ksrf.ru/decision/KSRFDecision 258613.pdf (data obr.: 24.02.2018).
Ob otkaze v prinyatii k rassmotreniyu zhalob grazhdanina Markina K.A. na narushenie ego konstitutsionnykh prav polozheniyami st.st. 13 i 15 FZ , statey 10 i 11 FZ O statuse voennosluzhashchikh , st. 32 Polozheniya o poryadke prokhozhdeniya voennoy sluzhby i punktov 35 i 44 Polozheniya o naznachenii i vyplate gosudarstvennykh posobiy grazhdanam, imeyushchim detey : Opredelenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF ot 15 yanvarya 2009 g. № 187-O-O34 // Rossiyskaya gazeta. 13.05.2009. №4908.
Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti polozheniy stat i 11 i punktov 3 i 4 chasti chetvertoy stat i 392 Grazhdanskogo protsessual nogo kodeksa Rossiyskoy Federatsii v svyazi s zaprosom prezidiuma Leningradskogo okruzhnogo voennogo suda : Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF ot 06.12.2013 №27-P // Rossiyskaya gazeta. 18.12.2013. №285.
Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti polozheniy...: Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF ot 14.07.2015 N 21-P // Rossiyskaya gazeta. 27.07.2015. № 163.
Po delu o razreshenii voprosa o vozmozhnosti ispolneniya v sootvetstvii s Konstitutsiey Rossiyskoy Federatsii postanovleniya Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka ot 4 iyulya 2013 goda po delu Anchugov i Gladkov protiv Rossii v svyazi s zaprosom Ministerstva yustitsii Rossiyskoy Federatsii: Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF ot 19.04.2016 N 12-P // Rossiyskaya gazeta. 05.05.2016. №95.
Aranovskiy K.V. Usloviya soglasovaniya praktiki mezhdunarodnogo i konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya // ZHurnal konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya. 2013. №3(33). S.1-10.
Blankenagel A. Proshchay, Sovet Evropy ili Sovet Evropy, davay pogovorim Kommentariy k Postanovleniyu Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossii ot 19 aprelya 2016 goda ob ispolnimosti Postanovleniya ESPCH po delu Anchugova i Gladkova ot 4 iyulya 2013 goda // Sravnitel noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie. 2016. №6. S. 135-150.
Blankenagel A., Levin I.G. V printsipe nel zya, no mozhno . Konstitutsionnyy Sud Rossii i delo ob obyazatel nosti resheniy Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka // Sravnitel noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie. 2015. №5. S.152-162.
Vasil eva T.A. Printsip uvazheniya natsional noy identichnosti gosudarstv - chlenov ES: problemy interpretatsii // Konstitutsionnoe i munitsipal noe pravo. 2017. №6. S.9-12.
Vitruk N.V. Ispolnenie resheniy Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka o priznanii narusheniya Rossiyskoy Federatsiey Konventsii o zashchite prav cheloveka i osnovnykh svobod // Rossiyskoe pravosudie. 2011. №11. S. 39-48.
Gavrilov V.V. Ponyatie i vzaimodeystvie mezhdunarodnoy i natsional nykh pravovykh sistem. M., 2018. 224 s.
Dolzhikov A. Gordost i predubezhdenie : sorazmernost polnogo konstitutsionnogo zapreta zaklyuchennym golosovat v Rossii. Postanovlenie Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka ot 4 iyulya 2013 goda // Mezhdunarodnoe pravosudie. 2013. №4. S.11-31.
Dudin M.N., Lyasnikov N.V., Ivashchenko N.P., Frolova E.E. Rossiya v sisteme mirovoy ekonomiki i mezhdunarodnykh svyazey v usloviyakh innovatsionnoy transformatsii sotsial no-ekonomicheskikh sistem. Monografiya // M., Rusayns, s. 194
Dudin M.N., Sekerin V.D., Smirnova O.O., Frolova E.E., Sepiashvili E.N. State anti-crisis management of banking sector: looking for optimization ways and contemporary development trends // Journal of advanced research in law and economics, 2014, № 5, vol. 2, p. 74-81
Zenin A.A. Konsul tativnye zaklyucheniya Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka i Protokol №16 k Konventsii (k istorii voprosa) // Rossiyskiy ezhegodnik evropeyskoy konventsii po pravam cheloveka. M., 2015. S. 398-415.
Zor kin V.D. Konstitutsionnaya identichnost Rossii: doktrina i praktika // ZHurnal konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya. 2014. №4(58). S.1-18.
Zor kin V.D. Predel ustupchivosti // Rossiyskaya gazeta. 29.10.2010. №5325.
Zor kin V.D. Sut prava // ZHurnal konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya. 2014. №5(59). S.1-11.
Ermakov S.L., Frolova E.E. Osnovy vnutribankovskogo antikrizisnogo upravleniya i regulirovaniya bankovskikh riskov // Izvestiya IGEA, 2011, № 6, s. 49-58;
Kireev V.V. Kategoriya riska v rossiyskoy konstitutsionno-pravovoy nauke // Problemy prava. 2013. №2(40). S.30-37.
Knyazev S.D. Stabil nost Konstitutsii i ee znachenie dlya sovremennogo rossiyskogo konstitutsionalizma // Konstitutsionnoe i munitsipal noe pravo. 2015. №1. S.4-12.
Kovler A.I. Sootnoshenie evropeyskogo i natsional nogo prava - obostrenie problemy // Rossiyskiy ezhegodnik evropeyskoy konventsii po pravam cheloveka. M., 2015. S.19-64.
Kokotov A.N. O nekotorykh izmeneniyakh zakonodatel stva o Konstitutsionnom Sude Rossiyskoy Federatsii // ZHurnal konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya. 2014. №5(59). S.15-19.
Marochkin S.YU. Deystvie i realizatsiya norm mezhdunarodnogo prava v pravovoy sisteme Rossiyskoy Federatsii: Monografiya. M., 2011. 288 s.
CHerkashin M.D. Fenomen riska v sovremennom obshchestve i novaya rol nauki // Filosofskie i kul turologicheskie aspekty sovremennogo sotsial no-gumanitarnogo znaniya. 2013. №1-2. S.16-20.
Frolova E.E. Risk-orientirovannyy podkhod v formirovanii organizatsiey politiki upravleniya riskami // Pravozashchitnik, 2016, № 2, s.1
Gadzhiev G.A. Konstitutsionnaya identichnost i prava cheloveka v Rossii : Ofitsial nyy sayt Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiyskoy Federatsii. http://www.ksrf.ru/ru/News/Documents/report D0 93 D0 B0 D0 B4 D0 B6 D0 B8 D0 B5 D0 B2 20 2016.pdf (data obrashcheniya: 24.02.2018).
Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti stat i 14.1 Federal nogo zakona O pogrebenii i pokhoronnom dele i Polozheniya o pogrebenii lits, smert kotorykh nastupila v rezul tate presecheniya sovershennogo imi terroristicheskogo akta, v svyazi s zhaloboy grazhdan K.I. Guzieva i E.KH. Karmovoy : Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo suda ot 28 iyunya 2007 goda № 8 - P // Rossiyskaya gazeta. 04.07.2007. № 4404.
Osoboe mnenie sud i Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiyskoy Federatsii K.V. Aranovskogo po delu o razreshenii voprosa o vozmozhnosti ispolneniya v sootvetstvii s Konstitutsiey Rossiyskoy Federatsii postanovleniya Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka ot 31 iyulya 2014 goda po delu OAO Neftyanaya kompaniya YUKOS protiv Rossii v svyazi s zaprosom Ministerstva yustitsii Rossiyskoy Federatsii : Ofitsial nyy sayt Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF. http://doc.ksrf.ru/decision/KSRFDecision 258613.pdf (data obr.: 24.02.2018).
Ob otkaze v prinyatii k rassmotreniyu zhalob grazhdanina Markina K.A. na narushenie ego konstitutsionnykh prav polozheniyami st.st. 13 i 15 FZ , statey 10 i 11 FZ O statuse voennosluzhashchikh , st. 32 Polozheniya o poryadke prokhozhdeniya voennoy sluzhby i punktov 35 i 44 Polozheniya o naznachenii i vyplate gosudarstvennykh posobiy grazhdanam, imeyushchim detey : Opredelenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF ot 15 yanvarya 2009 g. № 187-O-O34 // Rossiyskaya gazeta. 13.05.2009. №4908.
Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti polozheniy stat i 11 i punktov 3 i 4 chasti chetvertoy stat i 392 Grazhdanskogo protsessual nogo kodeksa Rossiyskoy Federatsii v svyazi s zaprosom prezidiuma Leningradskogo okruzhnogo voennogo suda : Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF ot 06.12.2013 №27-P // Rossiyskaya gazeta. 18.12.2013. №285.
Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti polozheniy...: Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF ot 14.07.2015 N 21-P // Rossiyskaya gazeta. 27.07.2015. № 163.
Po delu o razreshenii voprosa o vozmozhnosti ispolneniya v sootvetstvii s Konstitutsiey Rossiyskoy Federatsii postanovleniya Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka ot 4 iyulya 2013 goda po delu Anchugov i Gladkov protiv Rossii v svyazi s zaprosom Ministerstva yustitsii Rossiyskoy Federatsii: Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF ot 19.04.2016 N 12-P // Rossiyskaya gazeta. 05.05.2016. №95.
Keywords:
constitutional risk, constitutional identity, universally recognized principles and norms of international law, international Treaty, constitutional control, The Constitutional Court Of The Russian Federation, The European Court of human rights.
