The gaps in legislation made in the formulation of rules on hostage taking (article 206) and kidnapping (article 126): problems of law enforcement
( Pp. 109-113)
More about authors
Wang Zan
doktor yuridicheskih nauk, docent
Dalian Maritime University Lebedev Maksim Vladimirovich Dolzhnost: analitik.
Gubkin Russian State University of Oil and Gas (National Research University) Anna V. Serebrennikova Dr.Sci.(Law), Professor, Professor of the Department of Criminal Law and Criminology
Lomonosov Moscow State University
Moscow, Russian Federation
Dalian Maritime University Lebedev Maksim Vladimirovich Dolzhnost: analitik.
Gubkin Russian State University of Oil and Gas (National Research University) Anna V. Serebrennikova Dr.Sci.(Law), Professor, Professor of the Department of Criminal Law and Criminology
Lomonosov Moscow State University
Moscow, Russian Federation
Abstract:
As you know, the current criminal Code of the Russian Federation contains an exhaustive list of rules for which the legislator provides for criminal liability. A certain similarity in the design of the elements of different constituents often leads to conflict and competition of individual articles and their provisions in the doctrine of criminal law and practice of application. Recently, there has been a tendency to expand the norms of the Special part of the criminal code of the Russian Federation, which exacerbate this problem. An increase in the number of rules does not always mean their effectiveness, and there is no gap in the current criminal code of the Russian Federation. The article deals with actual problems contained in the legislative structure of the norms providing for criminal liability for hostage-taking and kidnapping. Purpose of the article: This work aims to study the problem of qualification of crimes on the basis of elements of crime, violation of the principle of justice and insufficient individualization of criminal responsibility hostage-taking and kidnapping. The authors aim to demonstrate and specify the existing gaps in the current legislation. Methodology and methods: the article uses a comparative legal research method, as well as a method of interpretation of legal norms, which allow us to better understand the institutions of criminal law and determine the main directions of their development. Conclusions: the problem of imperfections in the current legislation is relevant to study, as evidenced by the judicial practice in criminal cases, discussions and works of legal scholars. The doctrine also notes the need to observe the principle of justice in order to achieve the goals of the criminal law. Problems in the construction of these norms lead to the problem of misqualification of the investigated crimes, and the problem of differentiation of these norms. Application of the results: this article may be of interest to students of higher educational institutions: bachelors, undergraduates, postgraduates who study this area of criminal law, but also this material may be of interest to teachers of law schools, can be used as a guide for the preparation of practical and seminar classes
How to Cite:
Wang Z.., Lebedev M.V., Anna V.S., (2020), THE GAPS IN LEGISLATION MADE IN THE FORMULATION OF RULES ON HOSTAGE TAKING (ARTICLE 206) AND KIDNAPPING (ARTICLE 126): PROBLEMS OF LAW ENFORCEMENT. Gaps in Russian Legislation, 1 => 109-113.
Reference list:
Brilliantov A.V. Pokhishchenie cheloveka ili zakhvat zalozhnika. - Rossiyskaya YUstitsiya. 1999.- № 9. s.45
Lebedev M.V. Problemy kvalifikatsii prestupleniy po priznaku sub ektivnoy storony (na primere otdel nykh prestupleniy protiv zhizni). v zhurnale Probely v rossiyskom zakonodatel stve, № 7, 2016 s. 175
Petrov P.K. Pokhishchenie cheloveka i zakhvat zalozhnikov- voprosy kvalifikatsii/ Vestnik YUzhno-ural skogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Pravo 2008g. https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/pohischenie-cheloveka-i-zahvat-zalozhnika-voprosy-kvalifikatsii (data obrashcheniya k elektronnomu resursu 01.08.2019g.)
Rarog A.I., Probely v ugolovnom zakonodatel stve Rossii. Tekst nauchnoy stat i po spetsial nosti Pravo , Probely v Rossiyskom zakonodatel stve. YUridicheskiy zhurnal. M., №1, 2008 s.194-197
Serebrennikova A. V., Lebedev M. V. Ugolovnaya otvetstvennost za organizatsiyu nezakonnogo vooruzhennogo formirovaniya i uchastie v nem //Probely v rossiyskom zakonodatel stve. - 2018. - № 3. - S. 285-289.
Apellyatsionnoe opredelenie VS RF №67-APU14-36 ot 08.10.2014g., https://www.zakonrf.info/suddoc/ 898bfad41c59c90891299ab6e4e4134e/ (data obrashcheniya k elektronnomu resursu 10.07.2019g.).
Prigovor Prigorodnogo rayonnogo suda Respubliki Severnaya Osetiya-Alaniya№1-3/18, http://sudact.ru/ regular/doc/TMy8Tie6whNB/ regulartxt D0 B7 D0 B0 D0 BB D0 BE D0 B6 D0 BD D0 B8 D0 BA ular- (data obr. k el. resursu 22.07.19g.).
Prigovor Verkhovnogo suda CHechenskoy respubliki №b/n ot 19.11.2014g., http://sudact.ru/regular/doc/Bng6h-PFkj6g3/ (data obr. k el. resursu 16.07.2019g.).
Prigovor Klintsovskogo rayonnogo suda, Bryanskoy oblasti, №1-7/2015 ot 25.03.2015g., http://sudact.ru/ regular/doc/jA7YtkxLJTQJ/ page 12 regulardoc type (data obrashcheniya k elektronnomu resursu 28.12.2018g).
Reshenie Moskovskogo oblastnogo suda po delu № 2-9/2010 ot 02.08.2010g., https://actysudov.ru/act name reshenie-po-delu-29-2010-265-2009- court (data obrashcheniya k elektronnomu resursu 20.07.2019g.).
Lebedev M.V. Problemy kvalifikatsii prestupleniy po priznaku sub ektivnoy storony (na primere otdel nykh prestupleniy protiv zhizni). v zhurnale Probely v rossiyskom zakonodatel stve, № 7, 2016 s. 175
Petrov P.K. Pokhishchenie cheloveka i zakhvat zalozhnikov- voprosy kvalifikatsii/ Vestnik YUzhno-ural skogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Pravo 2008g. https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/pohischenie-cheloveka-i-zahvat-zalozhnika-voprosy-kvalifikatsii (data obrashcheniya k elektronnomu resursu 01.08.2019g.)
Rarog A.I., Probely v ugolovnom zakonodatel stve Rossii. Tekst nauchnoy stat i po spetsial nosti Pravo , Probely v Rossiyskom zakonodatel stve. YUridicheskiy zhurnal. M., №1, 2008 s.194-197
Serebrennikova A. V., Lebedev M. V. Ugolovnaya otvetstvennost za organizatsiyu nezakonnogo vooruzhennogo formirovaniya i uchastie v nem //Probely v rossiyskom zakonodatel stve. - 2018. - № 3. - S. 285-289.
Apellyatsionnoe opredelenie VS RF №67-APU14-36 ot 08.10.2014g., https://www.zakonrf.info/suddoc/ 898bfad41c59c90891299ab6e4e4134e/ (data obrashcheniya k elektronnomu resursu 10.07.2019g.).
Prigovor Prigorodnogo rayonnogo suda Respubliki Severnaya Osetiya-Alaniya№1-3/18, http://sudact.ru/ regular/doc/TMy8Tie6whNB/ regulartxt D0 B7 D0 B0 D0 BB D0 BE D0 B6 D0 BD D0 B8 D0 BA ular- (data obr. k el. resursu 22.07.19g.).
Prigovor Verkhovnogo suda CHechenskoy respubliki №b/n ot 19.11.2014g., http://sudact.ru/regular/doc/Bng6h-PFkj6g3/ (data obr. k el. resursu 16.07.2019g.).
Prigovor Klintsovskogo rayonnogo suda, Bryanskoy oblasti, №1-7/2015 ot 25.03.2015g., http://sudact.ru/ regular/doc/jA7YtkxLJTQJ/ page 12 regulardoc type (data obrashcheniya k elektronnomu resursu 28.12.2018g).
Reshenie Moskovskogo oblastnogo suda po delu № 2-9/2010 ot 02.08.2010g., https://actysudov.ru/act name reshenie-po-delu-29-2010-265-2009- court (data obrashcheniya k elektronnomu resursu 20.07.2019g.).
Keywords:
hostage - taking, kidnapping, gaps in legislation, qualification of crimes, problems of qualification, judicial practice.
Related Articles
1. THEORY AND HISTORY OF LAW AND STATE; HISTORY OF LAW AND STATE TEACHINGS Pages: 22-27 Issue №16680
The importance of judicial practice in the Russian legal system
judicial practice
Supreme Court of the Russian Federation
ruling
state power
judicial power
Show more
7. Criminal law, Criminal enforcement law, Criminology Pages: 166-170 Issue №8046
Category "competition" and "alternative" in the criminal law
competition
alternative
comparative law
qualification of crimes
the honors categories of competition from alternatives
Show more
REGIONAL AND SECTORAL ECONOMICS Pages: 201-209 Issue №24067
Judicial Novelties and Conflicts in Tariff Legislation
judicial practice
tariffs
disputed articles
regulated organizations
regulatory body
Show more
9. Criminal law and criminology; Criminal enforcement law Pages: 142-145 Issue №7765
ILLEGAL CASHING FUNDS AS AN ELEMENT OF ACTUS REUS
illegal cashing of funds
the objective side of the crime
qualification of crimes
Show more
3. PRIVATE LAW (CIVIL) DISCIPLINES Pages: 190-198 Issue №19964
Summary Proceedings of Resolving Claims in Civil Proceedings
summary proceedings
civil proceedings
stages of legal proceedings
gaps in legislation
reform
Show more
7. Criminal law, Criminal enforcement law, Criminology Pages: 128-130 Issue №9342
ON THE ISSUE OF FRAUD QUALIFICATION IN THE SPHERE OF COMPUTER INFORMATION
fraud in the sphere of computer information
qualification of crimes
the distinction between crimes
related and competing formulations
Show more
6. Criminal law and criminology; Criminal enforcement law Pages: 137-139 Issue №16219
Qualification Issues for Juvenile Abuse: A Theoretical Aspect
juvenile
ill-treatment
latency
victim
torture
Show more
4. Employment Law; Right to social security; Land law; Natural resource law; Environmental law; Pages: 148-150 Issue №4539
Retroactive effect of the criminal law: some aspects of the implementation of the criminal proceedings
criminal law
the effect of the criminal law in time
qualification of crimes
criminal procedure legislation
improvement of legislation
Show more
8. FINANCIAL LAW; TAX LAW; BUDGETARY LAW 12.00.04 Pages: 182-186 Issue №16787
Some problems of protecting the rights and legitimate interests of taxpayers in the implementation of tax control
principles of taxation
abuse of law
tax control
protection of the rights of taxpayers
balance of public and private interests
Show more
6. Criminal; Criminal enforcement law Pages: 127-133 Issue №11188
On the singularity of criminal legal counteraction to organized forms of extremism in Russia and the Republic of Kazakhstan
extremist community
criminal community
terrorist community
extremism
terrorism
Show more