The Subject Composition of Judicial Control in Russia
( Pp. 39-45)
More about authors
Markheim Marina V.
Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor; Head, Department of Constitutional and International Law, Law Institute
Belgorod State National Research University
Belgorod, Russian Federation. Peterburgskiy Andrey Pavlovich postgraduate student, Constitutional and International law department
Belgorod state national research university
Belgorod, Russia
Belgorod State National Research University
Belgorod, Russian Federation. Peterburgskiy Andrey Pavlovich postgraduate student, Constitutional and International law department
Belgorod state national research university
Belgorod, Russia
Abstract:
The article substantiates the author's approach to the designation and categorization of subjects of judicial control. The relevance of addressing this topic is justified by the variety of legislative provisions, as well as the results of scientific research, which are rather fragmented than an orderly system. Within the framework of the institutionalization of judicial control that we are developing, the question of its subjects is of great scientific and practical importance. As a result of the author's analysis of legal and doctrinal sources devoted to subjects of judicial control, this category is defined as a mandatory element of the institution of judicial control, which has a complex structured character. At the same time, it is proposed to use the term "subject composition" as an integrating concept, within which two groups of subjects are identified and characterized - basic and optional. The approach described in the article can be adopted for legislative regulation in order to streamline and unify judicial control procedures in terms of building an optimal model of the legal content of the relevant legal relations.
How to Cite:
Markheim M.V., Peterburgskiy A.P., (2023), THE SUBJECT COMPOSITION OF JUDICIAL CONTROL IN RUSSIA. Gaps in Russian Legislation, 1 => 39-45.
Reference list:
Alpatov Yu.M., (2016), Issues of procedural law and judicial control. Scientific Proceedings of the Russian Academy of Advocacy and Notary, 3 (42): 92-95.
Balashova I.N., (2019), Clarification of a court ruling as a form of manifestation of judicial power in enforcement proceedings. Court Administrator, 3: 6-10.
Balayan E.Yu., Sychev S.S., (2020), Enforcement of decisions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation on complaints of violations of constitutional rights and freedoms of citizens. Russian Justice, 10: 31-33.
Bondar N.S., Dzhagaryan A.A., (2018), Justice: orientation to the Constitution: monograph. M.: NORM, INFRA-M, 224 p.
Burmagin S.V., (2020), Metamorphoses of the adversarial nature of criminal proceedings in cases of judicial control. Lex russica, 2: 44-62.
Endoltseva A.A., (2022), Judicial control procedure for making a decision on pre-trial production of investigative and other procedural actions as an effective mechanism for protecting the rights of participants in criminal proceedings. Russian judge, 4: 42-46.
Kolokolov N.A., (2014), Operational judicial control in criminal proceedings. Moscow: Lawyer, 2008. 416 p.
Justice in the modern world: monograph, (2012) / edited by V.M. Lebedev, T.Ya. Khabrieva. M.: Norm, Infra-M, 704 p.
Tatarinov S.A., (2014), On the question of the principles of the implementation of constitutional legal proceedings in the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation. Constitutional and Municipal Law, 3: 57-61.
Umarova M.A., (2018), The mechanism of judicial control: a general theoretical study: diss. ... cand. jurid. sciences'. Kursk, 204 p.
Fialkovskaya I.D., Tonenkova O.A., (2008), Judicial control in the sphere of executive power: concept, signs, place in the system of administrative law. Bulletin of the Nizhny Novgorod University named after N.I. Lobachevsky, 3: 208-212.
Tsvetkov Yu.A., (2014), Investigator on appeal. Criminal Proceedings, 4: 27-32.
Chaptykov A.V., (2007), The concept and classification of subjects of the right to appeal to the bodies of constitutional justice. State Power and Local Self-government, 4: 7-11.
Shekshueva O.N., (2022), Judicial control activities and evidence in pre-trial proceedings. Russian Judge, 7: 9-14.
Balashova I.N., (2019), Clarification of a court ruling as a form of manifestation of judicial power in enforcement proceedings. Court Administrator, 3: 6-10.
Balayan E.Yu., Sychev S.S., (2020), Enforcement of decisions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation on complaints of violations of constitutional rights and freedoms of citizens. Russian Justice, 10: 31-33.
Bondar N.S., Dzhagaryan A.A., (2018), Justice: orientation to the Constitution: monograph. M.: NORM, INFRA-M, 224 p.
Burmagin S.V., (2020), Metamorphoses of the adversarial nature of criminal proceedings in cases of judicial control. Lex russica, 2: 44-62.
Endoltseva A.A., (2022), Judicial control procedure for making a decision on pre-trial production of investigative and other procedural actions as an effective mechanism for protecting the rights of participants in criminal proceedings. Russian judge, 4: 42-46.
Kolokolov N.A., (2014), Operational judicial control in criminal proceedings. Moscow: Lawyer, 2008. 416 p.
Justice in the modern world: monograph, (2012) / edited by V.M. Lebedev, T.Ya. Khabrieva. M.: Norm, Infra-M, 704 p.
Tatarinov S.A., (2014), On the question of the principles of the implementation of constitutional legal proceedings in the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation. Constitutional and Municipal Law, 3: 57-61.
Umarova M.A., (2018), The mechanism of judicial control: a general theoretical study: diss. ... cand. jurid. sciences'. Kursk, 204 p.
Fialkovskaya I.D., Tonenkova O.A., (2008), Judicial control in the sphere of executive power: concept, signs, place in the system of administrative law. Bulletin of the Nizhny Novgorod University named after N.I. Lobachevsky, 3: 208-212.
Tsvetkov Yu.A., (2014), Investigator on appeal. Criminal Proceedings, 4: 27-32.
Chaptykov A.V., (2007), The concept and classification of subjects of the right to appeal to the bodies of constitutional justice. State Power and Local Self-government, 4: 7-11.
Shekshueva O.N., (2022), Judicial control activities and evidence in pre-trial proceedings. Russian Judge, 7: 9-14.
Keywords:
subject, court, judge, constitutional control, judicial control, courts of general jurisdiction, arbitration courts, secretariat, initiator.
Related Articles
PUBLIC LAW (STATE LAW) Pages: 14-19 Issue №72283
Expanding Powers of Higher Tax Authorities in Tax Process at the Stage of Resolving the Issue of Acceptance of Complaint for Consideration
tax process
stage
tax authorities
taxpayer
court
Show more
7. Criminal procedure Pages: 183-188 Issue №13807
PROCEDURAL STATUS OF A JUDGE AT THE STAGE AFTER THE REFUSAL OF EXCITATION CRIMINAL CASE OR ITS TERMINATION BY THE DECISION OF THE INVESTIGATOR OR INQUIRER
criminal proceedings
stage
proceedings
judge
status
Show more
7. CRIMINAL PROCESS (12.00.09) Pages: 155-161 DOI: 10.33693/2072-3164-2021-14-1-155-161 Issue №18132
Limiting the constitutional rights of the suspect and the accused in the election of a measure of restraint - banning certain actions
criminal proceedings
court
judge
interrogator
investigator
Show more
5. CIVIL LAW; ENTREPRENEURIAL LAW; FAMILY LAW; INTERNATIONAL PRIVATE LAW; Civil procedure arbitration procedure Pages: 99-102 Issue №6998
Commercial disputes: pre-judicial settlement
claim
pre-trial procedure for dispute settlement
arbitration courts
procedural law
third parties with independent claims
Show more
10. TAX AND CUSTOMS PROBLEMS, FINANCIAL LAW, BUDGET LAW Pages: 105-109 Issue №4641
Judicial control over the legality in the operation of customs authorities
judicial control
illegal decisions of customs authorities
the rule of law
the complaint
action (inaction)
Show more
7. Criminal procedure Pages: 126-128 Issue №13916
CONTENT OF THE ACTIVITY OF THE COURT, WHEN APPLYING THE SPECIAL ORDER REVISED BY CHAPTER 40 OF THE CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION: PROOF OR QUASI-PROOF?
court
court hearing
evidence
quasi-proof
sentence
Show more
10. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 119-125 Issue №11076
IMPORTANT ISSUES OF NORMATIVE CONTROL IN THE REPUBLIC OF SERBIA
The Constitution of the Republic of Serbia 2006
The law on the constitutional court
Constitutional control
The place of the constitutional court in the system of separation of powers
The competence of the constitutional court
Show more
9. Theory and history of law and state; History of law and State teachings Pages: 116-120 Issue №3758
PUBLIC ENTITIES PROCEDURAL RESTRICTIVE LEGAL RELATIONS
entity
the subject of the relationship
the division of state power
the unity of state power
the legislature
Show more
7. Criminal procedure Pages: 138-145 Issue №13916
COMPETENCE OF THE COURT, JUDGE IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS: THEORETICAL DEFINITION AND REGULATORY BASIS
court
judge
competence
procedural status
functions
Show more
3. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 127-131 Issue №12435
Constitutional Risks of Russia's recognition of the priority of an International Treaty before a National Law and ways of overcoming them in the Doctrine of the Constitutional Identity of the State
constitutional risk
constitutional identity
universally recognized principles and norms of international law
international Treaty
constitutional control
Show more