Gaps in the legal regulation of the use of assisted reproductive technologies
( Pp. 441-446)
More about authors
Nadezda V. Kruchinina
Dr.Sci.(Law), Professor, professor of the criminalistics department
Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL)
Moscow, Russia Voronova Natalia Vladimirovna Nauchnyy sotrudnik
АО «First Genetics», Skolkovo Innovation centre
Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL)
Moscow, Russia Voronova Natalia Vladimirovna Nauchnyy sotrudnik
АО «First Genetics», Skolkovo Innovation centre
Abstract:
The situation is analyzed in the article associated with an increase in the number of infertile couples, with the problems of determining reproductive human rights, with their protection and regulation. It is concluded that assisted reproductive technologies (in vitro fertilization, surrogacy, etc.) are effective methods of treating infertility. There are heated debates among scientists, public and religious figures regarding the possibilities of using the achievements of biotechnology in the process of human reproduction. The problems associated with the use of genetic technologies in the process of artificial human reproduction are identified: the imperfection of the legal framework, in particular, the legal status of the human embryo, the legitimacy of its use for scientific research and therapeutic purposes. In Russia, methods of assisted reproductive technologies (ART) have generally been used for a long time, but there is still no law regulating this area, but it is needed. Some countries have adopted such laws. Canada has passed the Assisted Human Reproduction Act. The article provides a detailed analysis of this law. In different countries, ART is treated differently: from the prohibition to state support, seeing in some cases a security threat, and in others - the potential for solving demographic and economic problems. Studying foreign experience, it is seen, that some countries use prohibitions on a number of methods of reproductive technologies. The article presents examples of the occurrence of legal liability for violation of these prohibitions. An analysis of legislation, practice, and scientific research related to surrogate motherhood allows us to conclude that where there is no clear legal regulation, there is the possibility of abuses and wrongs. The most common crimes committed in this area are human trafficking, fraud, extortion, falsification of evidence. Therefore, the process of improving legislation in the field of assisted reproductive technologies should continue.
How to Cite:
Nadezda V.K., Voronova N.V., (2020), GAPS IN THE LEGAL REGULATION OF THE USE OF ASSISTED REPRODUCTIVE TECHNOLOGIES. Gaps in Russian Legislation, 4 => 441-446.
Reference list:
Dokhle G.R., Diemer T. Giversman A. i dr. Rukovodstvo po muzhskomu besplodiyu. London: EAU. 2015. - 42 s.
Inkhorn M.K., Patritsio P. Besplodie vo vsem mire: novoe myshlenie o gendere, reproduktivnykh tekhnologiyakh i global nykh dvizheniyakh v 21 veke // Novoe v reproduktsii cheloveka. 2015. № 21 (4). S. 411-426.
Katting R. Perenos odnogo embriona dlya vsekh // Luchshaya praktika i issledovanie: klinicheskoe akusherstvo i ginekologiya. 2018. № 53. S. 30-37.
Kuliev A., Rechitskiy S. Preimplantatsionnoe geneticheskoe testirovanie: sovremennye problemy i perspektivy // Ekspertnyy obzor molekulyarnoy diagnostiki. 2017. № 17 (12). S. 1071-1088.
Kruchinina N.V., Pyatibratova N.D. Rassledovanie prestupleniy protiv sem i: monografiya / pod obshch. red. E.P. Ishchenko. M.: Prospekt, 2019. - 131 s.
Kruchinina N.V. YUridicheskaya otvetstvennost za zloupotrebleniya i prestupleniya v sfere iskusstvennoy reproduktsii cheloveka // LEX Russica № 6 (151). 2019. S.48-51.
Popov V.P. Kruchinina N.V. Vyyavlenie zloupotrebleniy i prestupleniy, svyazannykh s fal sifikatsiey v sfere vspomogatel nykh reproduktivnykh tekhnologiy // Vestnik Universiteta imeni O.E. Kutafina (MGYUA). 2019. № 3 (55). S. 95-100.
Romanovskiy G.B. Pravovaya okhrana materinstva i reproduktivnogo zdorov ya: monografiya. - Moskva: Prospekt, 2018. - 216 s.
Ubaldi F.M., Kapal bo A., Kolamariya S. Sokrashchenie mnogoplodnykh beremennostey v period pozdnego materinskogo vozrasta posle realizatsii vybornoy politiki perenosa odinochnykh embrionov v sochetanii s rasshirennym vyborom embrionov: issledovanie do i posle vmeshatel stva // Reproduktsiya cheloveka. 2015. № 30 (9). S. 2097-2106.
Inkhorn M.K., Patritsio P. Besplodie vo vsem mire: novoe myshlenie o gendere, reproduktivnykh tekhnologiyakh i global nykh dvizheniyakh v 21 veke // Novoe v reproduktsii cheloveka. 2015. № 21 (4). S. 411-426.
Katting R. Perenos odnogo embriona dlya vsekh // Luchshaya praktika i issledovanie: klinicheskoe akusherstvo i ginekologiya. 2018. № 53. S. 30-37.
Kuliev A., Rechitskiy S. Preimplantatsionnoe geneticheskoe testirovanie: sovremennye problemy i perspektivy // Ekspertnyy obzor molekulyarnoy diagnostiki. 2017. № 17 (12). S. 1071-1088.
Kruchinina N.V., Pyatibratova N.D. Rassledovanie prestupleniy protiv sem i: monografiya / pod obshch. red. E.P. Ishchenko. M.: Prospekt, 2019. - 131 s.
Kruchinina N.V. YUridicheskaya otvetstvennost za zloupotrebleniya i prestupleniya v sfere iskusstvennoy reproduktsii cheloveka // LEX Russica № 6 (151). 2019. S.48-51.
Popov V.P. Kruchinina N.V. Vyyavlenie zloupotrebleniy i prestupleniy, svyazannykh s fal sifikatsiey v sfere vspomogatel nykh reproduktivnykh tekhnologiy // Vestnik Universiteta imeni O.E. Kutafina (MGYUA). 2019. № 3 (55). S. 95-100.
Romanovskiy G.B. Pravovaya okhrana materinstva i reproduktivnogo zdorov ya: monografiya. - Moskva: Prospekt, 2018. - 216 s.
Ubaldi F.M., Kapal bo A., Kolamariya S. Sokrashchenie mnogoplodnykh beremennostey v period pozdnego materinskogo vozrasta posle realizatsii vybornoy politiki perenosa odinochnykh embrionov v sochetanii s rasshirennym vyborom embrionov: issledovanie do i posle vmeshatel stva // Reproduktsiya cheloveka. 2015. № 30 (9). S. 2097-2106.
Keywords:
human reproductive rights, reproductive health, assisted reproductive technologies, surrogate maternity, legal regulation.
Related Articles
THEORETICAL AND HISTORICAL LEGAL SCIENCES Pages: 14-19 Issue №21610
Discretional Legal Technique and Technology of the Practice of Legal Regulation
legal regulation
legal technology
legal technique
discretionary legal technique
discretion
Show more
10. CIVIL LAW, HOUSING LAW, FAMILY LAW, INTERNATIONAL PRIVATE LAW Pages: 142-145 Issue №9731
THE PHENOMENON OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE LEGAL RISK CATEGORY
legal regulation
insurance
insurance law
business risks
Show more
7. Criminal law and criminology; Criminal enforcement law Pages: 135-138 Issue №15895
PROBLEMS OF LEGAL REGULATION OF THE MECHANISM OF PREVENTION OF JUVENILE DELINQUENCY
juvenile delinquency
prevention
prevention
legal regulation
commissions on juvenile Affairs and protection of their rights
Show more
PRIVATE LAW (CIVIL) Pages: 184-193 Issue №24449
Application of Artificial Methods of Reproduction in Russia and Ukraine: Comparative and Legal Analysis of Legislative Regulation
medical law
comparative legal studies
artificial reproduction
assisted reproductive technologies
ART in Russia
Show more
10. CIVIL LAW, HOUSING LAW, FAMILY LAW, INTERNATIONAL PRIVATE LAW Pages: 137-141 Issue №9731
THE PROBLEMS OF PROTECTING THE INSTITUTION OF FAMILY, MOTHERHOOD AND CHILDHOOD IN RUSSIA AND WAYS OF THEIR SOLUTION
legal regulation
the institution of the family
motherhood and childhood
family policy
Show more
9. ECONOMICS AND NATIONAL ECONOMY MANAGEMENT, ENTREPRENEURSHIP, MARKETING, MANAGEMENT Pages: 111-113 Issue №2928
Improvement of national legislation in the field of innovation as a factor of sustainable economic development
Innovation
legal regulation
improvement of legislation
innovative development
Show more
5. INTERNATIONAL LAW (5.1.5.) Pages: 219-226 Issue №22584
Problems of Legal Regulation of Labor Protection and Health of Coal Industry Workers: International and National Level
labor protection
coal industry
legal regulation
occupational injuries
International Labor Organization
Show more
11. Administrative law; Administrative process Pages: 152-154 Issue №15378
LEGAL REGULATION OF DISCIPLINARY RESPONSIBILITY OF CIVIL SERVANTS
civil service
civil servant
disciplinary liability
legal regulation
Show more
4. CRIMINAL - LEGAL, CRIMINOLOGICAL, ADMINISTRATIVE AND OTHER MEASURES FOR COUNTERING CRIME IN CONTEMPORARY CONDITIONS Pages: 151-154 Issue №19269
Problems of Implementation of the Principles of Criminal Legislation
principles of law
criminal legislation
legal regulation
state
jurisdiction
Show more
6. CIVIL LAW, BUSINESS LAW, FAMILY LAW; PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW 12.00.03 Pages: 166-174 Issue №18348
Legislative regulation of the removal of children by foreigners through the surrogacy procedure: overview of the working group meeting in the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation
medical law
demography
national security
child rights
reproductive technologies
Show more