TORTURE: PROBLEMS OF INTERPRETATION AND WAYS OF IMPROVING CRIMINAL LAW
( Pp. 85-94)

More about authors
Asnis Alexander Yakovlevich
Law Office “Asnis and Partners”
Moscow, Russia
Abstract:
The concept of "torture" and its features in the context of international obligations of Russia, national criminal legislation and judicial practice in criminal cases are investigated. The differences between the national and conventional definitions of this concept are considered. The discrepancy between the definition of torture under the criminal code of the Russian Federation and the conventional definition in terms of unjustified expansion of the range of subjects of torture was revealed. The author proposes a new version of the definition of torture (note to article 117 of the Russian Criminal Сode (RCC), which would correspond to the definition enshrined in Art.1 of the UN Convention against torture ratified by Russia, justifies the need to place this definition as notes to Art. 286 RCC. At the same time, it is proposed to fix in the notes to Art. 286 RCC the definition of the dependent person and the rules of delimitation of torture from causing suffering, not separated from the reasonably applied punishment or other legal restriction of the rights and freedoms of a person. The expediency of the exclusion of part 2 of Art. 117 "Torture" RCC, paragraph "d" (the Commission of torture the use of torture and amendments of article 286 RCC the new part providing for increased liability for excess of powers of office with application of torture. A similar provision is proposed to supplement Art. 288 RCC ("Assignment of powers of an official"). The necessity of criminalization under Art.302 RCC of coercion to give evidence (including torture) of persons brought to administrative responsibility, as well as the inclusion of judges in the range of subjects of the crime under this article is proposed and justified. The necessity of criminalization as a crime against military service the action in excess of the head office against a subordinate serviceman or persons performing military duties, as well as the adoption of a special resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation on court practice in cases on crimes related to torture to dependent persons.
How to Cite:
Asnis A.Y., (2019), TORTURE: PROBLEMS OF INTERPRETATION AND WAYS OF IMPROVING CRIMINAL LAW. Gaps in Russian Legislation, 6 => 85-94.
Reference list:
Barenboym P.D, Karakhanyan S.G., Kravchenko D.V. Psikhologicheskaya pytka v Rossii i za rubezhom. M.: Izd. LUM , 2016. 212 s.
Borkov V.N. Aktual nye problemy kvalifikatsii prevysheniya dolzhnostnykh polnomochiy // Ugolovnoe pravo. 2016. № 4.S. 4-8.
Veklenko V., Galyukova M. Istyazanie i pytka: ugolovno-pravovoy analiz // Ugolovnoe pravo. 2007. № 4. S. 15-18.
Dodonov V.N., Kapinus O.S., SHCHerba S.P. Sravnitel noe ugolovnoe pravo. Osobennaya chast : Monografiya. Pod red. S.P. SHCHerby. M.: YUrlitinform, 2010. S. 85-96.
Konarev M.YU. Ugolovnaya otvetstvennost sotrudnikov ugolovno-ispolnitel noy sistemy za primenenie pytki: vchera, segodnya, zavtra // Prikladnaya yuridicheskaya psikhologiya. 2012. № 1. S. 182-185.
Krivoshein P. Pytka: ponyatie, priznaki // Ugolovnoe pravo. 2005. №5. S. 40-43.
Nakazaniya za pytki v mezhdunarodnom prave // https://ljusifer.livejournal.com/536172.html (data obrashcheniya: 20.02.2019).
Rashkovskaya SH.S. Prinuzhdenie k dache pokazaniy // Kurs sovetskogo ugolovnogo prava v shesti tomakh. Red.koll.: Piontkovskiy A.A., Romashkin P.S., CHkhikvadze V.M. Tom VI. M.: Nauka, 1971. S. 130-136.
Tokubaev Z.S. Ugolovnaya otvetstvennost za pytki: mezhdunarodnyy i otechestvennyy opyt // Vestnik Vostochno-Sibirskogo instituta MVD Rossii. 2017. №4. S.121-129.
Ugolovnoe pravo. Osobennaya chast . Uchebnik. Pod red. L.D. Gaukhmana i S.V. Maksimova. M.: Eksmo, 2005. S. 63-65.
Scott, George R. The history of torture throughout the ages / 2nd ed. London: Luxor Press, Published, 1959. 328 pp.
Keywords:
torture, criminal law, interests of justice, criminal procedure, administrative procedure, dependent person, public persons.


Related Articles

Pages: 10-14 DOI: 10.33693/2782-7372-2023-2-1-10-14 Issue №22977
Features of Russia’s Criminal Policy in the Context of Digitalization of Modern Society
criminal law criminal offenses scientific and technological progress cybercrime
Show more
5. Philosophical sciences, Social science Political science Pages: 134-139 Issue №2418
«SLANDER»: PROBLEMS OF LAW-ENFORCEMENT PRACTICE
dignity false information slander punishment law enforcement practice
Show more
6. Criminology Pages: 146-150 Issue №6543
Criminological Characteristics of Criminality in Prison
deviant behavior disruptive action a social phenomenon prison crime criminal law
Show more
13. CRIMINAL PROCEDURE 12.00.09 Pages: 220-227 DOI: 10.33693/2541-8025-2021-17-5-220-227 Issue №19821
On the Possibilities of Integrating Artificial Intelligence into Criminal Proceedings
artificial intelligence machine-readable law ontology of law criminal procedure digitalization
Show more
11. CRIMINAL LAW AND CRIMINOLOGY; CRIMINAL ENFORCEMENT LAW 12.00.08 Pages: 219-225 Issue №17214
Constitutionalization of criminal law as a process
Constitution criminal law constitutionalization of criminal law mechanism of constitutionalization of criminal law object of branch constitutionalization
Show more
7. Criminal law and criminology; Criminal enforcement law Pages: 150-152 Issue №12615
Determinants of corruption crimes and need of improvement of the criminal precepts of law providing responsibility for their commission
corruption the criminalization of acts corruption the fight against corruption bribery
Show more
7. Criminal law, Criminal enforcement law, Criminology Pages: 171-175 Issue №8046
Problems of qualification of crimes on the basis of the subjective side (crimes against life)
Russia criminal law the subjective side of the crime wine crimes against life
Show more
5. Criminal; Criminal enforcement law Pages: 154-161 Issue №4982
Correction method regulations governing the quality of feed for farm animals used for human food
animal feed food human health the criminalization of acts criminal law
Show more
7. Criminal law, Criminal enforcement law, Criminology Pages: 155-158 Issue №4088
Differentiation of criminal liability for dissolute actions and pornography trade related crimes
criminal law qualification of crimes crimes in the sphere of circulation of pornographic materials and objects indecent assault crimes against sexual inviolability
Show more
5. Criminal; Criminal enforcement law Pages: 157-159 Issue №3370
Consistency and certainty of criminal law as a basic prerequisite for effective application of the rules governing its action in time and in space
the action in time the action in space the norm certainty consistency
Show more