Collecting Reliable and Admissible Evidence in Tax Process by Engaging Specialist
( Pp. 310-316)
More about authors
Orlova Natalia A.
Advisor to the State Civil Service of the Russian Federation, Grade 2, Deputy Head, Postgraduate Student of the Department of International and Public Law of the Faculty of Law, Financial University under the Government of the Russian Federation (Financial university), Russia, Moscow. Hirsch Index - 1
Interdistrict Inspectorate of the Federal Tax Service of the Russian Federation No. 17 for the Moscow Region
Lyubertsy, Russia
Interdistrict Inspectorate of the Federal Tax Service of the Russian Federation No. 17 for the Moscow Region
Lyubertsy, Russia
Abstract:
Abstract: The purpose of the study. The research paper examines the problems associated with the involvement of a specialist to assist in carrying out tax control measures and obtaining acceptable and reliable evidence. A specialist who is not interested in the outcome of the case has the necessary knowledge and skills, as well as practical experience, the use of which contributes to the identification and consolidation of appropriate evidence. Despite the high evidentiary capacity, the sources of information obtained with the participation of a specialist are excluded from the list of acceptable and reliable, which leads to the cancellation of the decision of the tax authority. Conclusions. As a result of the conducted research, objective reasons were identified for recognizing the evidence obtained during the involvement of a specialist as improper, violating the rights and interests of taxpayers. The proposed qualification requirements to be presented to a specialist, as well as the developed and justified limits of his involvement, contribute to increasing the legitimacy of the evidence obtained and prevents the unjustified use of a specialist for conducting an examination.
How to Cite:
Orlova N.A. Collecting Reliable and Admissible Evidence in Tax Process by Engaging Specialist // Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2023. Vol. 16. №5. Pp. 310-316. (in Russ.). EDN: VTUPRS
Reference list:
Arsenyev V.D., Zabolotsky V.G. The use of special knowledge in establishing the actual circumstances of a criminal case / V.D. Arsenyev, V.G. Zabolotsky. – Krasnoyarsk: Publishing house of the Krasnoyarsk University, 1986. 152 p.
Glazunova I.V. Specificity of evidence in the tax process // Law enforcement. 2019. Vol. 3, No. 4. pp. 63-74.
Kozyrin A.N., Semencha O.Yu. Conducting expertise and attracting a specialist on the Tax Code of the Russian Federation // Arbitration justice in Russia. 2007. No.8.
Nakhov E.A. Evidentiary law in civil and arbitration proceedings: general part / E.A. Nakhova. - St. Petersburg: VVM. 2012.
Orlov Yu.K. Expert opinion and its assessment in criminal cases / Yu.K. Orlov. – M.: Lawyer, 1995. 64 p.
Savost yanova S.A. Nekotorye problemy zashchity prav i zakonnykh interesov nalogoplatel shchikov pri osushchestvlenii nalogovogo kontrolya // Problemy ekonomiki i yuridicheskoy praktiki. 2020 T. 16. № 3. S. 182-186.
Savostyanova S.A. Some problems of protecting the rights and legitimate interests of taxpayers in the implementation of tax control // Problems of economics and legal practice. 2020 t . 16. No. 3. pp. 182-186.
Glazunova I.V. Specificity of evidence in the tax process // Law enforcement. 2019. Vol. 3, No. 4. pp. 63-74.
Kozyrin A.N., Semencha O.Yu. Conducting expertise and attracting a specialist on the Tax Code of the Russian Federation // Arbitration justice in Russia. 2007. No.8.
Nakhov E.A. Evidentiary law in civil and arbitration proceedings: general part / E.A. Nakhova. - St. Petersburg: VVM. 2012.
Orlov Yu.K. Expert opinion and its assessment in criminal cases / Yu.K. Orlov. – M.: Lawyer, 1995. 64 p.
Savost yanova S.A. Nekotorye problemy zashchity prav i zakonnykh interesov nalogoplatel shchikov pri osushchestvlenii nalogovogo kontrolya // Problemy ekonomiki i yuridicheskoy praktiki. 2020 T. 16. № 3. S. 182-186.
Savostyanova S.A. Some problems of protecting the rights and legitimate interests of taxpayers in the implementation of tax control // Problems of economics and legal practice. 2020 t . 16. No. 3. pp. 182-186.
Keywords:
specialist, conclusion, means of proof, tax process, evidence..
Related Articles
PUBLIC LAW (STATE LAW) Pages: 14-19 Issue №72283
Expanding Powers of Higher Tax Authorities in Tax Process at the Stage of Resolving the Issue of Acceptance of Complaint for Consideration
tax process
stage
tax authorities
taxpayer
court
Show more
15. Criminal procedure Pages: 239-246 Issue №12273
THE RIGHT OF THE ADVOCATE-DEFENDER TO RECEPTION OPINION OF A SPECIALIST AND ITS PRESENTATION TO SUBJOIN TO THE MATERIALS OF THE CRIMINAL CASE: GUARANTEE AND PROBLEMS OF IMPLEMENTATION
criminal proceedings
defense attorney
specialist
expert opinion
expert
Show more
SPECIALTY 12.00.04 Pages: 182-186 Issue №14694
LEGAL PRINCIPLES OF TAX PROCESS
principle
tax process
democracy
justice
legal process
Show more
7. Criminal procedure Pages: 191-195 Issue №3132
PROBLEMS OF PROFESSIONAL SPECIALIST IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS
specialist
Federal law "On the expert's activities in the Russian Federation"
a competent person
special knowledge
the criminal process
Show more
8. CRIMINAL LAW (5.1.4.) Pages: 249-255 Issue №20974
Criminalistic Teaching About the Implementation of Special Knowledge Outside of Forensic Examination: The Results of the Study
criminology
criminalistic teaching
interdisciplinary research
specialist
special knowledge
Show more
6. CRIMINAL PROCEDURE Pages: 235-237 Issue №16680
Features of the use of special psychological knowledge in criminal proceedings
psychologist
psychological knowledge
criminal process
examination
suspect
Show more
5. PUBLIC LAW (STATE LAW) (5.1.2.) Pages: 260-266 Issue №21729
Expertise as a Form of Evidence in the Tax Process
expertise
evidence
tax process
means of proof
decision
Show more
13. FORENSICS; FORENSIC EXPERTISE; OPERATIONAL AND SEARCH ACTIVITIES (12.00.12) Pages: 270-276 DOI: 10.33693/2072-3164-2021-14-3-270-276 Issue №18933
Conceptual Foundations of the Private Theory of Forensic Economic Expertise
specialist participation
specialized knowledge
forensic activity
preliminary research
specialist consultation
Show more
7. Forensics; Forensic expertise; Operational and search activities Pages: 222-225 Issue №4539
ON THE FORMATION SPETSIOLOGII AS A NEW DIRECTION IN JURISPRUDENCE
speleologia
specialist
special knowledge
special knowledge
ekspertika
Show more
7. Criminal procedure Pages: 162-165 Issue №4285
On the concept of criminal procedure evidence in the context of electronic information
proof
the fact
means of proof
source of evidence
Show more