Genesis and Transformation of the Elite of the Moscow State. Review of the Monograph: Benetsianov M. M. the Service Elites of the Moscow State. Formation, Status, Integration. XV-XVI Centuries - Moscow: Tsentrpoligraf, 2021. - 254 p. - (The Latest Research on the History of Russia)
( Pp. 148-152)
More about authors
Shishkin Igor G.
Dr. Sci. (Hist.), Associate Professor, Scientific Secretary
Tyumen Museum and Educational Association
Tyumen, Russian Federation Shishkina Svetlana Y. Cand. Sci. (Hist.), Associate Professor
Tyumen Higher Military Engineering Command School
Tyumen, Russian Federation
Tyumen Museum and Educational Association
Tyumen, Russian Federation Shishkina Svetlana Y. Cand. Sci. (Hist.), Associate Professor
Tyumen Higher Military Engineering Command School
Tyumen, Russian Federation
Abstract:
This publication shows the results of the analysis of Benetsianov's monograph and characterizes the content devoted to the formation of the service class and its elites in Russia in the XV-XVI centuries. It emphasizes that the sources used by Benetsianov signify his competence of the problem under study. The author systematizes the existing approaches to the study of the service class of medieval Russia. He recreates the process of formation of the service elite in general and shows the aspects of that development. This paper highlights the advantages and omissions in the Benetsianov’s study with the reflection of the reviewer’s positions.
How to Cite:
Shishkin I.G., Shishkina S.Y., (2022), GENESIS AND TRANSFORMATION OF THE ELITE OF THE MOSCOW STATE. REVIEW OF THE MONOGRAPH: BENETSIANOV M. M. THE SERVICE ELITES OF THE MOSCOW STATE. FORMATION, STATUS, INTEGRATION. XV-XVI CENTURIES - MOSCOW: TSENTRPOLIGRAF, 2021. - 254 P. - (THE LATEST RESEARCH ON THE HISTORY OF RUSSIA). History and Modern Perspectives, 2 => 148-152.
Reference list:
Alekseev Yu. G. On the question of estates in Russia XV-XVI centuries. some features of the estate policy of Ivan III // State and society in Russia XV- early XX century. St. Petersburg., 2007. Рp. 65-81.
Bakulina M. S. Systemic and complex approaches: similarity and difference // Bulletin of the KSPU named after V. P. Astafyev. 2011. No. 2. (Electronic edition): URL: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/sistemnyy-i-kompleksnyy-podhody-shodstvo-i-razlichie (date of application: 12/14/2021).
Benetsianov M. M. The Sovereign's court and territorial corporations of the serving people of the Russian state in the late XV- mid XVI century. Autoref. dis. on the job. learned. step. K.ist.N. spec. 07.00.02. Yekaterinburg, 2000. 28 p.
Brodkin I. A. The military elite of Russian society: theory and methodology of research // Army and society. 2007. No. 1. Рp. 34-42.
Gnevashev D. E. Vologda military «city» in the XV- early XVI century // Estates, institutions and state power in Russia. The Middle Ages and Modern Times. Collection of articles in memory of academician L. V. Cherepnin. Languages of Slavic cultures. M., 2010. Рp. 672-683.
Zhukov Yu. P., Shishkin I. G. Traditions and innovation in the study of the service class of the era of B. Godunov in Russian historical science (the second half of the XX- 20s of the XXI century) // Historical Bulletin. 2021. Vol. 4. No 1. Р. 83-90. Electronic edition): URL: http://hb-journal.ru) (date of application: 14.12.2021).
Kozlyakov V. N. The serving people of Russia of the XVI-XVII centuries, M., 2019. 544 p.
Korzinin A.L. Suzdal nobility and its role in the management of the Russian state in the second half of the XV- early XVI century. Autoref. dis. on the job. learned. step. K.ist.N. spec. 07.00.02. St. Petersburg, 2003. 25 p.
Kuzmin A.V. On the way to Moscow: essays on the genealogy of the military-serving nobility of Northeastern Russia in the XIII- mid XV century. Vol. 1. M., 2014. 336 p.; Vol. 2. M., 2015. 435 p.
Kuzmin A.V. Titled and untitled nobility of Northeastern Russia of the XIII- first quarter of the XV century: historical and genealogical research. Dissertation for the degree of a scientist. step. Cand. Ist. Sci. Spec. 07.00.02. Moscow, 2013. 647 p.
Mikhailova I. B. The serving people of North-Eastern Russia in the XIV- first half of the XVI century: Essays of soc. history of St. Petersburg, 2003. 639 p.
Popov S. N. Tver nobility in the Moscow sovereign's service at the end of the XV- first half of the XVI century. Autoref. dis. on the job. learned. step. Cand. Ist. Sci. Spec. 07.00.02. St. Petersburg, 2006. 25 p.
Skobelkin O. V. Serving «Germans» in the Russian army of the second half of the XVI century. // The Russian army in the era of Ivan the Terrible. St. Petersburg, 2015. Рp.69-103.
Tkachuk V. A. Formation of the political elite of the united Russian state: XVI- 80s of the XVI century. Autoref. dis. on the job. learned. step. K.ist.N. spec. 07.00.02. Barnaul, 2007. 25 p.
Chernikova T. V. Foreigners in Russian life of the XV-XVI century. // Bulletin of MGIMO. 2011. No. 6. Рp. 146-152.
Chechenkov P. V. Formation of land ownership and family composition of the Nizhny Novgorod service corporation of the first half- middle of the XVI century. // Ancient Rus. Questions of medieval studies. 2015. Issue 1. (59). Рp.60-75.
Shishkin I. G. Domestic historiography of the history of governance in the Russian state of the late XV-XVI centuries. (1917- early XXI centuries.) Tyumen, 2009. 596 p.
Bakulina M. S. Systemic and complex approaches: similarity and difference // Bulletin of the KSPU named after V. P. Astafyev. 2011. No. 2. (Electronic edition): URL: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/sistemnyy-i-kompleksnyy-podhody-shodstvo-i-razlichie (date of application: 12/14/2021).
Benetsianov M. M. The Sovereign's court and territorial corporations of the serving people of the Russian state in the late XV- mid XVI century. Autoref. dis. on the job. learned. step. K.ist.N. spec. 07.00.02. Yekaterinburg, 2000. 28 p.
Brodkin I. A. The military elite of Russian society: theory and methodology of research // Army and society. 2007. No. 1. Рp. 34-42.
Gnevashev D. E. Vologda military «city» in the XV- early XVI century // Estates, institutions and state power in Russia. The Middle Ages and Modern Times. Collection of articles in memory of academician L. V. Cherepnin. Languages of Slavic cultures. M., 2010. Рp. 672-683.
Zhukov Yu. P., Shishkin I. G. Traditions and innovation in the study of the service class of the era of B. Godunov in Russian historical science (the second half of the XX- 20s of the XXI century) // Historical Bulletin. 2021. Vol. 4. No 1. Р. 83-90. Electronic edition): URL: http://hb-journal.ru) (date of application: 14.12.2021).
Kozlyakov V. N. The serving people of Russia of the XVI-XVII centuries, M., 2019. 544 p.
Korzinin A.L. Suzdal nobility and its role in the management of the Russian state in the second half of the XV- early XVI century. Autoref. dis. on the job. learned. step. K.ist.N. spec. 07.00.02. St. Petersburg, 2003. 25 p.
Kuzmin A.V. On the way to Moscow: essays on the genealogy of the military-serving nobility of Northeastern Russia in the XIII- mid XV century. Vol. 1. M., 2014. 336 p.; Vol. 2. M., 2015. 435 p.
Kuzmin A.V. Titled and untitled nobility of Northeastern Russia of the XIII- first quarter of the XV century: historical and genealogical research. Dissertation for the degree of a scientist. step. Cand. Ist. Sci. Spec. 07.00.02. Moscow, 2013. 647 p.
Mikhailova I. B. The serving people of North-Eastern Russia in the XIV- first half of the XVI century: Essays of soc. history of St. Petersburg, 2003. 639 p.
Popov S. N. Tver nobility in the Moscow sovereign's service at the end of the XV- first half of the XVI century. Autoref. dis. on the job. learned. step. Cand. Ist. Sci. Spec. 07.00.02. St. Petersburg, 2006. 25 p.
Skobelkin O. V. Serving «Germans» in the Russian army of the second half of the XVI century. // The Russian army in the era of Ivan the Terrible. St. Petersburg, 2015. Рp.69-103.
Tkachuk V. A. Formation of the political elite of the united Russian state: XVI- 80s of the XVI century. Autoref. dis. on the job. learned. step. K.ist.N. spec. 07.00.02. Barnaul, 2007. 25 p.
Chernikova T. V. Foreigners in Russian life of the XV-XVI century. // Bulletin of MGIMO. 2011. No. 6. Рp. 146-152.
Chechenkov P. V. Formation of land ownership and family composition of the Nizhny Novgorod service corporation of the first half- middle of the XVI century. // Ancient Rus. Questions of medieval studies. 2015. Issue 1. (59). Рp.60-75.
Shishkin I. G. Domestic historiography of the history of governance in the Russian state of the late XV-XVI centuries. (1917- early XXI centuries.) Tyumen, 2009. 596 p.
Keywords:
serving corporations, serving elites, the Moscow state, the specific system.
Related Articles
