TO QUESTION ABOUT SCIENTIFIC JUSTIFICATION OF EXPANDING SPHERE OF USING POLYGRAPH («LIE DETECTOR») IN CRIMINAL COURT-PROCEEDING
( Pp. 104-112)

More about authors
Khmelevsky Sergey V. kandidat filosofskih nauk, docent; kapitan 1 ranga zapasa.
For read the full article, please, register or log in
Abstract:
In article systematically analysed, as well in fact established to date in Russian Federation situation with using of polygraph in private and public sectors, especially in criminal court-proceeding, as a problematic technical, methodological, ethical, juridical and organizational aspects of such using. Among the key conclusions, formulated by author, − thesis, that extension sphere of using of «lie detector», as well as a broad approbation of «criminalistical polygraphology» in criminal court-proceeding is difficult to recognize proper degree scientifically sound idea.
How to Cite:
Khmelevsky S.V., (2014), TO QUESTION ABOUT SCIENTIFIC JUSTIFICATION OF EXPANDING SPHERE OF USING POLYGRAPH («LIE DETECTOR») IN CRIMINAL COURT-PROCEEDING. Business in Law, 1: 104-112.
Reference list:
A. Bastrykin: Mne ne do poezdok na prirodu . Glava Sledstvennogo komiteta Rossiyskoy Federatsii ob yasnil situatsiyu so skandalom vokrug zhurnalista Novoy gazety v razgovore s shef-redaktorom Izvestiy A.Potapovym //Web-resurs: http: www.izvestia.ru/news/527375 ixzz1xpD5BvlL
Aver yanova T.V., Belkin R.S., Korukhov YU.G., Rossinskaya E.R. Kriminalistika: Uchebnik dlya vuzov /Pod red. R.S.Belkina. M.: Izdatel stvo Norma , 2002. 990 s.
Aleksandrov O. Serdyukov i ego zhenshchiny //The Moscow Post. 01.11.2012.
Barshchev V. Platnoe GAI soprovozhdeniya //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 06.03.2008.
Batyrkhanov G., Gridasov A. Evgeniya Vasil eva: Ty za chto menya pnul, pust slegka, sapogom //Izvestiya. 25.04.2013.
Borisov T. Dvesti tysyach baksov za minutu razgovora. Sud prigovor byvshego ofitsera FSB k semi godam tyur my //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 17.06.2005.
V Moskve zaderzhany 4 sotrudnika ugrozyska, podbrasyvavshikh narkotiki //Web-resurs: http: news.mail.ru/inregions/moscow/90/incident/16644463/
V stolitse pri poluchenii 600 tysyach rubley zaderzhan sledovatel politsii //Internet-portal Rossiyskoy gazety . 22.03.2013; Web-resurs: http: www.rg.ru/2013/03/22/vzyatka-anons.html
prinyala zakonoproekt o voennoy politsii //Vedomosti. 24.01.2014.
Grigor ev YU. Novye oborotni v pogonakh. Prokurory-moshenniki pokhitili 500 mln rubley //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 06.05.2008.
Gridasov A., Evstifeev D. Po itogam 2013 goda MVD prishlet k politsii Moskvy proverku //Izvestiya. 24.01.2014.
Dobrynina E. Kak po-russki demokratiya Sotsiologi vyyasnili, zachem rossiyanam nuzhny konstitutsionnye prava i grazhdanskoe obshchestvo //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 10.01.2014.
Evgeniya Vasil eva zakonchila oznakomlenie so svoim ugolovnym delom //Internet-portal Rossiyskoy gazety . 19.12.2013; Web-resurs: http: www.rg.ru/printable/2013/12/19/vasilieva1-anons.html
Est problema Est i reshenie //TSentr kompleksnykh ekspertiz pri Nekommercheskom partnerstve Natsional naya Kollegiya Poligrafologov //Web-resurs: http: npnkp.ru/ekspertnyi-tsentr
Iskusstvennyy intellekt predskazhet povedenie tolpy //Vesti.Ru. 03.05.2013; Web-resurs: http: //hitech.vesti.ru/news/view/id/1882
Kozichev E. Kak v Rossii sozdavali voennuyu politsiyu //Kommersant . 10.10.2012.
Kozlova N. Zashchita Lukina. Upolnomochennyy po pravam cheloveka v Rossiyskoy Federatsii predlozhil pomoshch poterpevshim ot prestupleniy //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 04.06.2008.
Kozlova N., SHabrov O., Sashchenko N., Mizulin M. Dlya kogo zakon ne pisan //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 04.04.2006.
Komissarova YA.V. Kontseptual nye osnovy professional noy deyatel nosti eksperta v ugolovnom sudoproizvodstve: Avtoref. dis.. dokt. yurid. nauk. M., 2013. 57 s.
Muratov D.A. Predsedatelyu Sledstvennogo komiteta pri prokurature Rossiyskoy Federatsii general-polkovniku yustitsii A.I.Bastrykinu o nezakonchennykh delakh //Novaya gazeta. 13.06.2012.
Netraditsionnye metody v raskrytii prestupleniy. Tezisy nauchno-prakticheskogo seminara /Pod red. E.G.Samovicheva. M.: Izdatel stvo VNII MVD Rossii, 1994. -158 s.
Nikitinskiy L. Kogo obmanyvaet militsiya //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 11.05.2006.
Ofitsial noe zayavlenie prokuratury Sakhalinskoy oblasti o faktakh telefonnogo moshennichestva. 21.01.2014 //Web-resurs: http: procrf.ru/news/178870-ofitsialnoe-zayavlenie-prokuraturyi-oblasti.html
Podpisan zakon, obespechivayushchiy deyatel nost voennoy politsii VS RF //RAPSI (Rossiyskoe agentstvo pravovoy i sudebnoy informatsii). 04.02.2014; Web-resurs: http: //rapsinews.ru/legislation news/20140204/270629717.html
Postanovlenie Pravitel stva Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 20.01.2014 №39 O Mezhvedomstvennoy komissii po voprosam, svyazannym s vnedreniem i razvitiem sistem apparatno-programmnogo kompleksa tekhnicheskikh sredstv quot;Bezopasnyy gorod quot; //Web-resurs: http: premier.gov.ru/dep news/9992
Prikaz Ministerstva vnutrennikh del Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 12.09.1995 №353 Ob obespechenii vnedreniya poligrafa v deyatel nost organov vnutrennikh del (po sostoyaniyu na iyul 2011 goda) //Web-resurs: http: www.bestpravo.ru/rossijskoje/vr-postanovlenija/q2o.htm
Primenenie spetsial nykh znaniy (poligraf) v ugolovnom sudoproizvodstve. 21.10.2012 //Web-resurs: http: www.polygraphclub.ru/f/showthread.php 486
Prichinoy otstavki sledovatelya Morozova stali skandaly //Kommersant . 21.01.2014.
Rekomendatsiya YUNESKO O statuse nauchno-issledovatel skikh rabotnikov (prinyata v g. Parizhe 20.11.1974 na 18-y sessii General noy konferentsii YUNESKO) //Mezhdunarodnye normativnye akty YUNESKO. M.: Izdatel stvo Logos , 1993. S.199-213; Konsul tant Plyus. 01.02.2014.
Serdyukov provel etu noch u Vasil evoy //RBK daily. 13.12.2012.
Sledstvennyy les. Poiski istiny v lesu ne luchshaya reklama dlya Sledstvennogo komiteta Rossiyskoy Federatsii //Gazeta.Ru. 13.06.2012.
Ugolovnyy kodeks Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 13.06.1996 №63-FZ (UK RF) (deystvuyushchaya redaktsiya) //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 18-20, 25.06.1996; Konsul tant Plyus. 01.02.2014.
Ugolovno-protsessual nyy kodeks Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 18.12.2001 №174-FZ (UPK RF) (deystvuyushchaya redaktsiya) //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 22.12.2001; Konsul tant Plyus. 01.02.2014.
Ukaz dlya Komiteta //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 03.08.2007.
Falaleev M. Dopros chinovnika pod tokom . MVD Rossii i FSB Rossii predlagayut zakonoproekt ob ispol zovanii detektora lzhi pri vysokikh naznacheniyakh //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 04.03.2008.
Falaleev M. Kto ostanovit militsionera na Leksuse //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 07.12.2007.
Falaleev M. Otvechayte korotko da ili net . Detektor lzhi razreshili primenyat do vozbuzhdeniya dela. Rezul taty ekspertizy, poluchennye s pomoshch yu detektora lzhi , stanut vesomym argumentom v sude, gde reshaetsya vinoven li chelovek v prestuplenii //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 17.09.2013.
Federal nyy zakon Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 31.05.2001 №73-FZ O gosudarstvennoy sudebno-ekspertnoy deyatel nosti v Rossiyskoy Federatsii (deystvuyushchaya redaktsiya) //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 05.06.2001; Konsul tant Plyus. 01.02.2014.
Federal nyy zakon Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 17.01.1992 №2202-1 O prokurature Rossiyskoy Federatsii (deystvuyushchaya redaktsiya) //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 18.02.1992; Konsul tant Plyus. 01.02.2014.
Federal nyy zakon Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 17.07.2009 №172-FZ Ob antikorruptsionnoy ekspertize normativnykh pravovykh aktov i proektov normativnykh pravovykh aktov (deystvuyushchaya redaktsiya) //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 22.07.2009; Konsul tant Plyus. 01.02.2014.
Federal nyy zakon Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 31.05.1996 №61-FZ Ob oborone (deystvuyushchaya redaktsiya) //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 06.06.1996; Konsul tant Plyus. 01.02.2014.
Federal nyy zakon Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 12.08. 1995 №144-FZ Ob operativno-rozysknoy deyatel nosti (deystvuyushchaya redaktsiya) //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 18.08.1995; Konsul tant Plyus. 01.02.2014.
KHolodnyy YU.I. Primenenie detektora lzhi v Rossii //Sudebnyy ekspert. Sudebnaya ekspertiza na detektore lzhi u nezavisimogo eksperta //Nezavisimyy Ekspertnyy TSentr Triumf . 18.12.2013 //Web-resurs: http: www.test-detector.ru/interest/ ELEMENT ID 69
SHleynov R., Nikol skiy A. Lyudi Serdyukova. S tekh por kak ministr oborony otpravlen v otstavku, vokrug nego ne utikhaet skandal, v kotorom to i delo poyavlyayutsya novye imena Vasil eva, El kin, Puzikov //Vedomosti. 03.12.2012.
Emotsii upravlyayut dushevnym i fizicheskim sostoyaniyami //Razum i Mozg. 02.01.2014; Web-resurs: http: mindbrain.ru/2014/01/02/1043.html
KHmelevskiy S.V. Mezhdunarodno-pravovaya zashchita detey s drevnosti do nachala vtoroy mirovoy voyny // Probely v rossiyskom zakonodatel stve №1, 2012, s. 295-298
KHmelevskiy S.V. Moral i pravo: nekotorye bazovye aspekty vzaimosvyazi i vzaimovliyaniya // Biznes v zakone №2, 2012, s. 191-198
KHmelevskiy S.V. K voprosu o vliyanii grazhdanskogo obshchestva na politicheskuyu bezopasnost // Sotsial no-politicheskie nauki №1, 2012, s. 139-145
Keywords:
military police, forensics, unorthodox methods in solving crimes, operatively-search activity, the bodies of internal Affairs, the polygraph ("lie detector"), the Prosecutor's office, psychophysiological method, the investigator, it is judicial-expert activity, criminal proceedings, expert, examination.