TO QUESTION ABOUT SCIENTIFIC JUSTIFICATION OF EXPANDING SPHERE OF USING POLYGRAPH («LIE DETECTOR») IN CRIMINAL COURT-PROCEEDING
( Pp. 104-112)

More about authors
Khmelevsky Sergey V. kandidat filosofskih nauk, docent; kapitan 1 ranga zapasa.
Abstract:
In article systematically analysed, as well in fact established to date in Russian Federation situation with using of polygraph in private and public sectors, especially in criminal court-proceeding, as a problematic technical, methodological, ethical, juridical and organizational aspects of such using. Among the key conclusions, formulated by author, − thesis, that extension sphere of using of «lie detector», as well as a broad approbation of «criminalistical polygraphology» in criminal court-proceeding is difficult to recognize proper degree scientifically sound idea.
How to Cite:
Khmelevsky S.V., (2014), TO QUESTION ABOUT SCIENTIFIC JUSTIFICATION OF EXPANDING SPHERE OF USING POLYGRAPH («LIE DETECTOR») IN CRIMINAL COURT-PROCEEDING. Business in Law, 1 => 104-112.
Reference list:
A. Bastrykin: Mne ne do poezdok na prirodu . Glava Sledstvennogo komiteta Rossiyskoy Federatsii ob yasnil situatsiyu so skandalom vokrug zhurnalista Novoy gazety v razgovore s shef-redaktorom Izvestiy A.Potapovym //Web-resurs: http: www.izvestia.ru/news/527375 ixzz1xpD5BvlL
Aver yanova T.V., Belkin R.S., Korukhov YU.G., Rossinskaya E.R. Kriminalistika: Uchebnik dlya vuzov /Pod red. R.S.Belkina. M.: Izdatel stvo Norma , 2002. 990 s.
Aleksandrov O. Serdyukov i ego zhenshchiny //The Moscow Post. 01.11.2012.
Barshchev V. Platnoe GAI soprovozhdeniya //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 06.03.2008.
Batyrkhanov G., Gridasov A. Evgeniya Vasil eva: Ty za chto menya pnul, pust slegka, sapogom //Izvestiya. 25.04.2013.
Borisov T. Dvesti tysyach baksov za minutu razgovora. Sud prigovor byvshego ofitsera FSB k semi godam tyur my //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 17.06.2005.
V Moskve zaderzhany 4 sotrudnika ugrozyska, podbrasyvavshikh narkotiki //Web-resurs: http: news.mail.ru/inregions/moscow/90/incident/16644463/
V stolitse pri poluchenii 600 tysyach rubley zaderzhan sledovatel politsii //Internet-portal Rossiyskoy gazety . 22.03.2013; Web-resurs: http: www.rg.ru/2013/03/22/vzyatka-anons.html
prinyala zakonoproekt o voennoy politsii //Vedomosti. 24.01.2014.
Grigor ev YU. Novye oborotni v pogonakh. Prokurory-moshenniki pokhitili 500 mln rubley //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 06.05.2008.
Gridasov A., Evstifeev D. Po itogam 2013 goda MVD prishlet k politsii Moskvy proverku //Izvestiya. 24.01.2014.
Dobrynina E. Kak po-russki demokratiya Sotsiologi vyyasnili, zachem rossiyanam nuzhny konstitutsionnye prava i grazhdanskoe obshchestvo //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 10.01.2014.
Evgeniya Vasil eva zakonchila oznakomlenie so svoim ugolovnym delom //Internet-portal Rossiyskoy gazety . 19.12.2013; Web-resurs: http: www.rg.ru/printable/2013/12/19/vasilieva1-anons.html
Est problema Est i reshenie //TSentr kompleksnykh ekspertiz pri Nekommercheskom partnerstve Natsional naya Kollegiya Poligrafologov //Web-resurs: http: npnkp.ru/ekspertnyi-tsentr
Iskusstvennyy intellekt predskazhet povedenie tolpy //Vesti.Ru. 03.05.2013; Web-resurs: http: //hitech.vesti.ru/news/view/id/1882
Kozichev E. Kak v Rossii sozdavali voennuyu politsiyu //Kommersant . 10.10.2012.
Kozlova N. Zashchita Lukina. Upolnomochennyy po pravam cheloveka v Rossiyskoy Federatsii predlozhil pomoshch poterpevshim ot prestupleniy //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 04.06.2008.
Kozlova N., SHabrov O., Sashchenko N., Mizulin M. Dlya kogo zakon ne pisan //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 04.04.2006.
Komissarova YA.V. Kontseptual nye osnovy professional noy deyatel nosti eksperta v ugolovnom sudoproizvodstve: Avtoref. dis.. dokt. yurid. nauk. M., 2013. 57 s.
Muratov D.A. Predsedatelyu Sledstvennogo komiteta pri prokurature Rossiyskoy Federatsii general-polkovniku yustitsii A.I.Bastrykinu o nezakonchennykh delakh //Novaya gazeta. 13.06.2012.
Netraditsionnye metody v raskrytii prestupleniy. Tezisy nauchno-prakticheskogo seminara /Pod red. E.G.Samovicheva. M.: Izdatel stvo VNII MVD Rossii, 1994. -158 s.
Nikitinskiy L. Kogo obmanyvaet militsiya //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 11.05.2006.
Ofitsial noe zayavlenie prokuratury Sakhalinskoy oblasti o faktakh telefonnogo moshennichestva. 21.01.2014 //Web-resurs: http: procrf.ru/news/178870-ofitsialnoe-zayavlenie-prokuraturyi-oblasti.html
Podpisan zakon, obespechivayushchiy deyatel nost voennoy politsii VS RF //RAPSI (Rossiyskoe agentstvo pravovoy i sudebnoy informatsii). 04.02.2014; Web-resurs: http: //rapsinews.ru/legislation news/20140204/270629717.html
Postanovlenie Pravitel stva Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 20.01.2014 №39 O Mezhvedomstvennoy komissii po voprosam, svyazannym s vnedreniem i razvitiem sistem apparatno-programmnogo kompleksa tekhnicheskikh sredstv quot;Bezopasnyy gorod quot; //Web-resurs: http: premier.gov.ru/dep news/9992
Prikaz Ministerstva vnutrennikh del Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 12.09.1995 №353 Ob obespechenii vnedreniya poligrafa v deyatel nost organov vnutrennikh del (po sostoyaniyu na iyul 2011 goda) //Web-resurs: http: www.bestpravo.ru/rossijskoje/vr-postanovlenija/q2o.htm
Primenenie spetsial nykh znaniy (poligraf) v ugolovnom sudoproizvodstve. 21.10.2012 //Web-resurs: http: www.polygraphclub.ru/f/showthread.php 486
Prichinoy otstavki sledovatelya Morozova stali skandaly //Kommersant . 21.01.2014.
Rekomendatsiya YUNESKO O statuse nauchno-issledovatel skikh rabotnikov (prinyata v g. Parizhe 20.11.1974 na 18-y sessii General noy konferentsii YUNESKO) //Mezhdunarodnye normativnye akty YUNESKO. M.: Izdatel stvo Logos , 1993. S.199-213; Konsul tant Plyus. 01.02.2014.
Serdyukov provel etu noch u Vasil evoy //RBK daily. 13.12.2012.
Sledstvennyy les. Poiski istiny v lesu ne luchshaya reklama dlya Sledstvennogo komiteta Rossiyskoy Federatsii //Gazeta.Ru. 13.06.2012.
Ugolovnyy kodeks Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 13.06.1996 №63-FZ (UK RF) (deystvuyushchaya redaktsiya) //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 18-20, 25.06.1996; Konsul tant Plyus. 01.02.2014.
Ugolovno-protsessual nyy kodeks Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 18.12.2001 №174-FZ (UPK RF) (deystvuyushchaya redaktsiya) //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 22.12.2001; Konsul tant Plyus. 01.02.2014.
Ukaz dlya Komiteta //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 03.08.2007.
Falaleev M. Dopros chinovnika pod tokom . MVD Rossii i FSB Rossii predlagayut zakonoproekt ob ispol zovanii detektora lzhi pri vysokikh naznacheniyakh //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 04.03.2008.
Falaleev M. Kto ostanovit militsionera na Leksuse //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 07.12.2007.
Falaleev M. Otvechayte korotko da ili net . Detektor lzhi razreshili primenyat do vozbuzhdeniya dela. Rezul taty ekspertizy, poluchennye s pomoshch yu detektora lzhi , stanut vesomym argumentom v sude, gde reshaetsya vinoven li chelovek v prestuplenii //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 17.09.2013.
Federal nyy zakon Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 31.05.2001 №73-FZ O gosudarstvennoy sudebno-ekspertnoy deyatel nosti v Rossiyskoy Federatsii (deystvuyushchaya redaktsiya) //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 05.06.2001; Konsul tant Plyus. 01.02.2014.
Federal nyy zakon Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 17.01.1992 №2202-1 O prokurature Rossiyskoy Federatsii (deystvuyushchaya redaktsiya) //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 18.02.1992; Konsul tant Plyus. 01.02.2014.
Federal nyy zakon Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 17.07.2009 №172-FZ Ob antikorruptsionnoy ekspertize normativnykh pravovykh aktov i proektov normativnykh pravovykh aktov (deystvuyushchaya redaktsiya) //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 22.07.2009; Konsul tant Plyus. 01.02.2014.
Federal nyy zakon Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 31.05.1996 №61-FZ Ob oborone (deystvuyushchaya redaktsiya) //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 06.06.1996; Konsul tant Plyus. 01.02.2014.
Federal nyy zakon Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 12.08. 1995 №144-FZ Ob operativno-rozysknoy deyatel nosti (deystvuyushchaya redaktsiya) //Rossiyskaya gazeta (federal nyy vypusk). 18.08.1995; Konsul tant Plyus. 01.02.2014.
KHolodnyy YU.I. Primenenie detektora lzhi v Rossii //Sudebnyy ekspert. Sudebnaya ekspertiza na detektore lzhi u nezavisimogo eksperta //Nezavisimyy Ekspertnyy TSentr Triumf . 18.12.2013 //Web-resurs: http: www.test-detector.ru/interest/ ELEMENT ID 69
SHleynov R., Nikol skiy A. Lyudi Serdyukova. S tekh por kak ministr oborony otpravlen v otstavku, vokrug nego ne utikhaet skandal, v kotorom to i delo poyavlyayutsya novye imena Vasil eva, El kin, Puzikov //Vedomosti. 03.12.2012.
Emotsii upravlyayut dushevnym i fizicheskim sostoyaniyami //Razum i Mozg. 02.01.2014; Web-resurs: http: mindbrain.ru/2014/01/02/1043.html
KHmelevskiy S.V. Mezhdunarodno-pravovaya zashchita detey s drevnosti do nachala vtoroy mirovoy voyny // Probely v rossiyskom zakonodatel stve №1, 2012, s. 295-298
KHmelevskiy S.V. Moral i pravo: nekotorye bazovye aspekty vzaimosvyazi i vzaimovliyaniya // Biznes v zakone №2, 2012, s. 191-198
KHmelevskiy S.V. K voprosu o vliyanii grazhdanskogo obshchestva na politicheskuyu bezopasnost // Sotsial no-politicheskie nauki №1, 2012, s. 139-145
Keywords:
military police, forensics, unorthodox methods in solving crimes, operatively-search activity, the bodies of internal Affairs, the polygraph ("lie detector"), the Prosecutor's office, psychophysiological method, the investigator, it is judicial-expert activity, criminal proceedings, expert, examination.


Related Articles

1. SCIENTIFIC SCHOOL OF DOCTOR OF SCIENCE, PROFESSOR SHCHERBA SERGEJ PETROVICH Pages: 10-14 Issue №9149
SCIENTIFIC SCHOOL of PROFESSOR SERGEI PETROVICH SZCZERBA FEATURES OF CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS FOR PEOPLE SUFFERING PHYSICAL OR MENTAL DISABILITIES
scientific school of Professor Sergei Petrovich Scherba criminal proceedings persons with physical or mental disabilities
Show more
3. CRIMINALISTIC, PROCEDURAL AND OPERATIVE-SEARCH MEASURES TO COUNTER CRIME IN THE GLOBALIZATION CONDITIONS Pages: 212-215 Issue №16988
Once again to the question of the classification of forensics
criminalistics expertise methods system classification
Show more
14. Judicial, prosecutorial, human rights and law enforcement activities Pages: 194-197 Issue №5306
PUBLIC PROSECUTORS AND ADVOCACY IN THE POST-SOVIET COUNTRIES: THE COMPARATIVE LEGAL ANALYSIS
the Prosecutor's office advocacy efficiency analysis rating
Show more
7. Criminal procedure Pages: 201-204 Issue №4982
SOME QUESTIONS OF INQUIRY PRODUCTION IN THE REDUCED FORM (CUSTOMS ASPECT)
manufacture of inquiry in abbreviated form criminal proceedings the customs authorities criminal case the inquirer
Show more
7. Criminal procedure Pages: 209-212 Issue №4748
To a question on legal regulation of operatively-search action «inspection of buildings, constructions, sites of district and vehicles» spent by operating-technical divisions
operatively-search activity operational-search activities the rights and freedoms of man and citizen
Show more
9. Judicial, prosecutorial, human rights and law enforcement activities Pages: 194-196 Issue №4285
Some imperfect legislation identified in the implementation of prosecutorial supervision of execution of laws in the field of protection of forests
supervision the Prosecutor's office the organization of Prosecutor's supervision the laws on the protection of forests deficiencies in the organization and implementation of supervision
Show more
13. Judicial, prosecutorial, human rights and law enforcement activities Pages: 207-209 Issue №3758
Activities defense lawyer in criminal cases of illegal crossing of the State Border of the Russian Federation
the criminal process the defender "on purpose" defender "by agreement" criminal proceedings border authorities
Show more
8. Judicial, prosecutorial, human rights and law enforcement activities Pages: 217-224 Issue №3636
New legislation on termination of service in the internal affairs
the bodies of internal Affairs service in bodies of internal Affairs employee of internal Affairs bodies The law "On service in bodies of internal Affairs" The law "On police"
Show more
9. Judicial, prosecutorial, human rights and law enforcement activities Pages: 229-232 Issue №3132
Problems of coordination and interaction of courts and legal enforcement authorities
coordination interaction law enforcement law enforcement Agency the bodies of internal Affairs
Show more
11. Forensics; Forensic expertise; Operational and search activities Pages: 226-230 Issue №15895
Content and type of unified expert opinion
author's opinion unification text documents examination
Show more