TO THE POINT OF LEGALITY, VALIDITY AND JUSTICE OF «PUSSY RIOT’S» SENTENCE
( Pp. 51-55)
More about authors
Baev Valery G.
zaveduyuschiy kafedroy trudovogo i predprinimatelskogo prava, doktor yuridicheskih nauk, professor
law Institute Tambov state technical University Krisanov Ivan A. aspirant
law Institute Tambov state technical University
law Institute Tambov state technical University Krisanov Ivan A. aspirant
law Institute Tambov state technical University
Abstract:
The article should be considered as an attempt to deliver a legal overview of Pussy Riot’s sentence, leaving behind any sort of ideological approach. The authors impose doubt on its correspondence to the main juridical criteria: legality, validity and justice. The analysis of formal components of a crime has been chosen as a method of the research. The latter has resulted to the conclusion that the sentence to the “Pussy Riot” is considered as legal and valid, though lacking justice
How to Cite:
Baev V.G., Krisanov I.A., (2015), TO THE POINT OF LEGALITY, VALIDITY AND JUSTICE OF «PUSSY RIOT’S» SENTENCE. Sociopolitical Sciences, 1 => 51-55.
Reference list:
Ponomariov A. The Pussy Riot Case in Russia: Orthodox Canon law and the Sentence of the Secular Court // Ab Imperio, 4/2013.
Dmitriev M. Pussy Riot. Analiz sostava prestupleniya . //http://zakon.ru/blogs/pussy riot analiz sostava prestupleniya/3891 (data poslednego poseshcheniya - 17.08.2014 g.).
O Pussy Riot i Putine napisali 86 mirovykh SMI. NewsEffector. http:// http://newseffector.com/news/78868-o-pyssy-riot-i-putine-napisali-86-mirovyh-smi.html .UPqQ4iflAsR (data poslednego poseshcheniya - 09.05.2014.
The FP Top 100 Global Thinkers. Foreign Policy. 2012. November 26 // http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2012/11/26/the fp 100 global thinkers (data poslednego poseshcheniya - 12.05.2014).
Les Femmes de 2012. Le Figar.2012. December 18 // http://madame.lefigaro.fr/societe/femmes-de-2012-181212-330304.
O vnesenii izmeneniy v stat yu 148 Ugolovnogo Kodeksa Rossiyskoy Federatsii i otdel nye zakonodatel nye akty Rossiyskoy Federatsii v tselyakh protivodeystviya oskorbleniyu religioznykh ubezhdeniy i chuvstv grazhdan Tekst : Federal nyy zakon № 136-FZ. Prinyat Gosudarstvennoy Dumoy 29.06.2013 g. // Ofitsial nyy internet-portal pravovoy informatsii www.pravo.gov.ru, 30.06.2013.
Prigovor imenem Rossiyskoy Federatsii po delu № 1-170/12 ot 17.08.2012. // http://snob.ru/selected/entry/51999 (data poslednego poseshcheniya - 13.01.2015).
Kodeks Rossiyskoy Federatsii ob administrativnykh pravonarusheniya (KoAP RF) Tekst : Federal nyy Zakon. Prinyat Gosudarstvennoy Dumoy 30.12.2001 // Rossiyskaya gazeta , № 256, 31.12.2001.
RPTS: KHram KHrista Spasitelya - ne pervyy, gde vystupili Pussy Riot. // http://ria.ru/society/20120317/598430640.html (data poslednego poseshcheniya - 13.01.2015).
Ugolovnyy kodeks Rossiyskoy Federatsii Tekst : Federal nyy Zakon. Prinyat Gosudarstvennoy Dumoy 13.06.1996 g. // Rossiyskaya gazeta, № 113, 18.06.1996, № 114, 19.06.1996, № 115, 20.06.1996, № 118, 25.06.1996.
O svobode sovesti i religioznykh ob edineniyakh Tekst : Federal nyy Zakon № 125-FZ. Prinyat Gosudarstvennoy Dumoy 19.09.1997 // Rossiyskaya gazeta. № 190, 01.10.1997.
TSit po: Uzlaner D. Delo Pussi rayot i osobennosti rossiyskogo postsekulyarizma//http://religion.rane.ru/sites/default/files/ E2 80 9EThe 20Pussy 20Riot 20Case E2 80 9C 20and 20the 20Peculiarities 20of 20Russian 20Postsecularism 202 202013.pdf (data poslednego poseshcheniya - 27.07.2014) (na moment zaprosa pervoistochnik - ZHZH Pussi rayot vnesen v Reestr zapreshchennykh saytov, v rezul tate chego dostup k dannomu materialu byl zapreshchen).
Pank-moleben Bogoroditsa, putina progoni v KHrame KHrista spasitelya// http://pussy-riot.info/blog/2012/2/21/bogoroditsa-putina-progoni (data poslednego poseshcheniya - 19.07.2014).
Plokhova V.I. Klassicheskoe khuliganstvo, prestupleniya iz khuliganskikh pobuzhdeniy, i ekstremistskoe khuliganstvo // http://izvestia.asu.ru/2012/2-1/jurs/TheNewsOfASU-2012-2-1-jurs-09.pdf (poslednee poseshchenie - 25.08.2014).
Postanovlenie po delu № 44u-217/10 tekst : Postanovlenie. Prinyato Prezidiumom Moskovskogo gorodskogo Suda 30.07. 2010 // Spravochno-informatsionnaya sistema Konsul tant http://base.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi req doc;base MARB;n 174367.
O sudebnoy praktike po ugolovnym delam o khuliganstve i inykh prestupleniyakh, sovershennykh iz khuliganskikh pobuzhdeniy. Tekst : Postanovlenie Plenuma Verkhovnogo Suda. Prinyato Plenumom Verkhovnogo suda Rossiyskoy Federatsii 15.11.2007g. // Rossiyskaya gazeta http://www.rg.ru/2007/11/21/sud-dok.html (data poslednego poseshcheniya - 17.01.2015).
Kobzeva E.V. Otsenochnye priznaki v ugolovnom zakone: Avtoref. dis. kand. yurid. nauk. - Saratov, 2002.
Ugolovno-protsessual nyy kodeks Rossiyskoy Federatsii tekst : Federal nyy zakon № 174-FZ v deystv. redaktsii. Prinyat Gosudarstvennoy Dumoy 22.11.2001 // Rossiyskaya gazeta, № 249, 22.12.2001.
Dmitriev M. Pussy Riot. Analiz sostava prestupleniya . //http://zakon.ru/blogs/pussy riot analiz sostava prestupleniya/3891 (data poslednego poseshcheniya - 17.08.2014 g.).
O Pussy Riot i Putine napisali 86 mirovykh SMI. NewsEffector. http:// http://newseffector.com/news/78868-o-pyssy-riot-i-putine-napisali-86-mirovyh-smi.html .UPqQ4iflAsR (data poslednego poseshcheniya - 09.05.2014.
The FP Top 100 Global Thinkers. Foreign Policy. 2012. November 26 // http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2012/11/26/the fp 100 global thinkers (data poslednego poseshcheniya - 12.05.2014).
Les Femmes de 2012. Le Figar.2012. December 18 // http://madame.lefigaro.fr/societe/femmes-de-2012-181212-330304.
O vnesenii izmeneniy v stat yu 148 Ugolovnogo Kodeksa Rossiyskoy Federatsii i otdel nye zakonodatel nye akty Rossiyskoy Federatsii v tselyakh protivodeystviya oskorbleniyu religioznykh ubezhdeniy i chuvstv grazhdan Tekst : Federal nyy zakon № 136-FZ. Prinyat Gosudarstvennoy Dumoy 29.06.2013 g. // Ofitsial nyy internet-portal pravovoy informatsii www.pravo.gov.ru, 30.06.2013.
Prigovor imenem Rossiyskoy Federatsii po delu № 1-170/12 ot 17.08.2012. // http://snob.ru/selected/entry/51999 (data poslednego poseshcheniya - 13.01.2015).
Kodeks Rossiyskoy Federatsii ob administrativnykh pravonarusheniya (KoAP RF) Tekst : Federal nyy Zakon. Prinyat Gosudarstvennoy Dumoy 30.12.2001 // Rossiyskaya gazeta , № 256, 31.12.2001.
RPTS: KHram KHrista Spasitelya - ne pervyy, gde vystupili Pussy Riot. // http://ria.ru/society/20120317/598430640.html (data poslednego poseshcheniya - 13.01.2015).
Ugolovnyy kodeks Rossiyskoy Federatsii Tekst : Federal nyy Zakon. Prinyat Gosudarstvennoy Dumoy 13.06.1996 g. // Rossiyskaya gazeta, № 113, 18.06.1996, № 114, 19.06.1996, № 115, 20.06.1996, № 118, 25.06.1996.
O svobode sovesti i religioznykh ob edineniyakh Tekst : Federal nyy Zakon № 125-FZ. Prinyat Gosudarstvennoy Dumoy 19.09.1997 // Rossiyskaya gazeta. № 190, 01.10.1997.
TSit po: Uzlaner D. Delo Pussi rayot i osobennosti rossiyskogo postsekulyarizma//http://religion.rane.ru/sites/default/files/ E2 80 9EThe 20Pussy 20Riot 20Case E2 80 9C 20and 20the 20Peculiarities 20of 20Russian 20Postsecularism 202 202013.pdf (data poslednego poseshcheniya - 27.07.2014) (na moment zaprosa pervoistochnik - ZHZH Pussi rayot vnesen v Reestr zapreshchennykh saytov, v rezul tate chego dostup k dannomu materialu byl zapreshchen).
Pank-moleben Bogoroditsa, putina progoni v KHrame KHrista spasitelya// http://pussy-riot.info/blog/2012/2/21/bogoroditsa-putina-progoni (data poslednego poseshcheniya - 19.07.2014).
Plokhova V.I. Klassicheskoe khuliganstvo, prestupleniya iz khuliganskikh pobuzhdeniy, i ekstremistskoe khuliganstvo // http://izvestia.asu.ru/2012/2-1/jurs/TheNewsOfASU-2012-2-1-jurs-09.pdf (poslednee poseshchenie - 25.08.2014).
Postanovlenie po delu № 44u-217/10 tekst : Postanovlenie. Prinyato Prezidiumom Moskovskogo gorodskogo Suda 30.07. 2010 // Spravochno-informatsionnaya sistema Konsul tant http://base.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi req doc;base MARB;n 174367.
O sudebnoy praktike po ugolovnym delam o khuliganstve i inykh prestupleniyakh, sovershennykh iz khuliganskikh pobuzhdeniy. Tekst : Postanovlenie Plenuma Verkhovnogo Suda. Prinyato Plenumom Verkhovnogo suda Rossiyskoy Federatsii 15.11.2007g. // Rossiyskaya gazeta http://www.rg.ru/2007/11/21/sud-dok.html (data poslednego poseshcheniya - 17.01.2015).
Kobzeva E.V. Otsenochnye priznaki v ugolovnom zakone: Avtoref. dis. kand. yurid. nauk. - Saratov, 2002.
Ugolovno-protsessual nyy kodeks Rossiyskoy Federatsii tekst : Federal nyy zakon № 174-FZ v deystv. redaktsii. Prinyat Gosudarstvennoy Dumoy 22.11.2001 // Rossiyskaya gazeta, № 249, 22.12.2001.
Keywords:
"Pussy Riot", The Cathedral Of Christ The Savior, prayer, punk band, the sentence, the court, legal studies.
Related Articles
2. ECONOMICS AND MANAGEMENT OF ENTERPRISES, INDUSTRIES, COMPLEXES; ENTREPRENEURSHIP Pages: 11-17 Issue №9731
CONCEPTUAL FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES AND POSSIBILITIES FOR HIGH-QUALITY TAX RISK MANAGEMENT AS AN EFFECTIVE MECHANISM TO HEDGE THE RISK OF BUSINESS PROSECUTION IN RUSSIA (ON THE EXAMPLE OF PJSC (PAO) SEVERSTAL)
Russia (Russian Federation)
prosecution
business
the business climate
evasion
Show more
15. Administrative law; Administrative process, Information Law Pages: 219-221 Issue №11076
PROCEDURAL PROBLEMS OF ADMINISTRATIVE DISPUTES
administrative dispute
the Executive authorities and officials
the court
the Protocol on administrative offense
review of decisions of the
Show more
4. CIVIL LAW, INTERNATIONAL PRIVATE LAW, HOUSING LAW, FAMILY LAW, CIVIL PROCEDURE, ARBITRATION PROCESS Pages: 179-182 Issue №10864
Consideration of disputes by the courts on the rights of the child
the court
the rights of the child
the debate about the place of residence of the child
the child's relationship with grandparents
the divorce of the spouses
Show more
8. Criminal procedure Pages: 194-196 Issue №8046
To the question of overcoming prejudice in criminal proceedings of the Russian Federation
criminal proceedings
validity
the sentence
proof
prejudice
Show more
19. Judicial, prosecutorial, human rights and law enforcement activities Pages: 179-181 Issue №11394
TO THE QUESTION OF PROPERTY CONSEQUENCES OF THE RECOGNITION OF ILLEGAL ACTIONS AND DECISIONS OF LAW-ENFORCEMENT BODIES AND THEIR BRANCHES
the bodies of internal Affairs
property damage
legal position of the constitutional Court of the Russian Federation
the court
the court decision
Show more
LEGAL MECHANISMS OF INTERACTION OF THE STATE AND CIVIL SOCIETY Pages: 130-132 Issue №10195
The verdict of the court as the basis for ensuring the rule of law
the court
the legality
justice
the criminal process
the sentence
Show more
11. Judicial, prosecutorial, human rights and law enforcement activities Pages: 170-172 Issue №5143
The credentials of a lawyer in civil proceedings
lawyer
civil process
the power of attorney
the court
powers
Show more
LEGAL MECHANISMS OF INTERACTION OF THE STATE AND CIVIL SOCIETY Pages: 133-135 Issue №10195
The realization of justice in the leading models of judicial systems nowadays
the judiciary
the judicial system
justice
model judicial systems
right
Show more
13. Judicial, prosecutorial, human rights and law enforcement activities Pages: 203-206 Issue №3758
On the intersectoral regulation of circumstances to be proved at the stage of sentence execution
the sentence
proof
cross-sectoral regulation
the circumstances to be proven
Show more
9. Judicial, prosecutorial, human rights and law enforcement activities Pages: 229-232 Issue №3132
Problems of coordination and interaction of courts and legal enforcement authorities
coordination
interaction
law enforcement
law enforcement Agency
the bodies of internal Affairs
Show more