Methodology and objects of assessment of the expert’s opinion by the state prosecutor
( Pp. 164-169)

More about authors
Pavlova Elena Vitalievna zamestitel nachalnika ugolovno-sudebnogo upravleniya
Prosecutor's Office of the Moscow Region
Moscow, Russian Federation
Abstract:
Purpose of the study. Consideration of the problems existing in the practice of analysis, assessment and use of expert opinions by public prosecutors, and their causes. The study of the methodology for the implementation of this activity as a combination of:a) theoretical principles and practical methods, research methods that the prosecutor applies to assess the relevance, admissibility, reliability of the expert’s opinion; b) a system of principles and methods for studying the laws in accordance with which the process of this assessment proceeds. The author briefly considers the principles of: a) legality; b) science; c) systemic; d) objectivity included in the set of principles on which the assessment of the expert’s opinion is based. The author proposes the sequence of the prosecutor’s decision to analyze and evaluate the expert’s opinion, considered as the most rational way of this activity. The set of questions clarified in this case is considered both as a task and as a set of objects of assessment. These objects are divided into two groups, depending on the nature of the main issues to be solved; 1) concerning the assessment of the possibility of using one or another expert opinion as evidence of a charge in court; 2) relating to the definition of tactics of their submission to the court and participation in their research. The article provides examples of the use of individual research methods and assessment of expert opinions: comparative legal, analogy, analysis and synthesis. The results of the study . The analysis and assessment of the expert’s opinion is a complex cognitive process that requires legal and special knowledge, practical experience, knowledge of the methodology of this work from prosecutors. Its use in compliance with the principles that it is based on is one of the ways to increase the professional level of public prosecutors.
How to Cite:
Pavlova E.V., (2020), METHODOLOGY AND OBJECTS OF ASSESSMENT OF THE EXPERT’S OPINION BY THE STATE PROSECUTOR. Sociopolitical Sciences, 3 => 164-169.
Reference list:
Alekseev P.V., Panin A.V. Filosofiya: uchebnik. 4-e izd., pererab. i dop. M.: Prospekt, 2017.
Belkin R.S., Vinberg A.I. Kriminalistika i dokazyvanie (metodologicheskie problemy). M.: YUrid. lit-ra, 1969.
Bozrov V.M., Kostovskaya N.V. Nekotorye problemnye voprosy otsenki dokazatel stv sudom // Mirovoy sud ya. 2012. № 11. (SPS Konsul tantPlyus) (data obrashcheniya: 01.06.2020).
Isaenko V.N. Sodeystvie sudu v ustanovlenii istiny - zadacha podderzhaniya gosudarstvennogo obvineniya // Vestnik Universiteta prokuratury Ros. Federatsii. 2020. № 1 (75).
Isaenko V.N. Ekspertnaya otsenka pokazaniy v ugolovnom sudoproizvodstve // Zakonnost . 2020. № 2.
Kirillov V.I., Starchenko A.A. Logika: uchebnik dlya yuridicheskikh vuzov. Izd. 5-e, pererab. i dop. M.: YUrist , 2004.
Marchenko M.N. Problemy teorii gosudarstva i prava: uchebnik. M.: Prospekt, 2016.
Orlov O.K. Sovremennye problemy dokazyvaniya i ispol zovaniya spetsial nykh znaniy v ugolovnom sudoproizvodstve: nauch.-ucheb. posobie. M.: Prospekt, 2017.
Petrukhin I.L. Ekspertiza kak sredstvo dokazyvaniya v sovetskom ugolovnom protsesse. M.: YUrid. lit-ra, 1964.
Rakhunov R.D. Teoriya i praktika ekspertizy v sovetskom ugolovnom protsesse. Izd. 2-3, pererab. i dop. M.: Gosyurizdat, 1953.
Teoriya dokazatel stv v sovetskom ugolovnom protsesse: monografiya / otv. red. N.V. ZHogin; izd. 2-e, ispr. i dop. M.: YUrid. lit-ra, 1973.
Ekspertiza v ugolovnom sudoproizvodstve: uchebnik / pod red. E.R. Rossinskoy. M.: Prospekt, 2019.
Keywords:
state prosecution, expert opinion, assessment of evidence, analysis of evidence, assessment methodology, principles, assessment methods.


Related Articles

1. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 12-15 Issue №5746
The principles of public administration by electoral process in the Russian Federation
principles public administration the electoral process Russian Federation
Show more
17. Judicial, prosecutorial, human rights and law enforcement activities Pages: 215-218 Issue №11740
DOCTRINAL MODEL AND SYSTEM OF POWERS OF THE PROSECUTOR IN RUSSIAN FEDERATION
the Prosecutor doctrine model theory practice
Show more
9. CRIMINAL LAW AND CRIMINOLOGY; CRIMINAL ENFORCEMENT LAW 12.00.08 Pages: 201-204 Issue №19457
Topical Issues of Using the Results of Computer-Technical Expertise
computer-technical expertise expert activity expert opinion evidence criminal process
Show more
10. Forensics; Forensic expertise; Operational and search activities; Criminal procedure Pages: 143-146 Issue №10386
EVIDENTIARY ACTIVITIES FEATURES BY INQUIRY PRODUCTION IN THE REDUCED FORM
proof urgent investigative actions verification of evidence the principle of the presumption of innocence in pre-trial proceedings forensic examination
Show more
11. LEGAL SUPPORT OF ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITIES Pages: 154-159 Issue №10386
THE BURDEN OF PROOF IN CASES OF INSOLVENCY (BANKRUPTCY)
the burden of proof the burden of proof insolvency (bankruptcy) bankruptcy law principles
Show more
5.2.3. REGIONAL AND SECTORAL ECONOMICS Pages: 229-238 Issue №22298
The Basic Basis for Ensuring the Social Security of the Region
social security threats diagnostics pension system assessment methods
Show more
9. CIVIL LAW; ENTREPRENEURIAL LAW; FAMILY LAW; INTERNATIONAL PRIVATE LAW Pages: 178-183 Issue №12273
PRINCIPLES OF LEGAL REGULATION OF MEDICAL SERVICES WITH THE USE OF ASSISTED REPRODUCTIVE TECHNOLOGIES
civil Pravovoe regulation principles medical technology assisted reproductive technologies (art) in vitro fertilization (IVF)
Show more
5. CIVIL LAW; ENTREPRENEURIAL LAW; FAMILY LAW; INTERNATIONAL PRIVATE LAW; Civil procedure arbitration procedure Pages: 145-148 Issue №6840
The principles of judicial activity in the Russian Federation
judicial activities the judiciary the judicial system the court principles
Show more
MANAGEMENT Pages: 256-263 DOI: 10.33693/2541-8025-2024-20-1-256-263 Issue №72283
Correlation of Risk Management Methods and Procedures with Risk Management and Economic Security Systems
risk management economic security management risk management principles
Show more
4. CRIMINAL LAW DISCIPLINES Pages: 250-254 Issue №19964
Methodology for the Participation of the Prosecutor in the Study of Expert Opinions in the Court of Appeal
appeal proceedings prosecutor defense side expert opinion methodology
Show more