Constitutional identity as the basis for resolution of convention-constitutional conflicts
( Pp. 60-65)

More about authors
Belosludtsev Oleg Stanislavovich Cand.Sci.(Law), Sеnior lecturer of International and European Law Department, FAculty of Law
National Research Ogarev Mordovia State University
Saransk, Russian Federation
Abstract:
The article is devoted to the study of the concept of constitutional identity. The author, exploring the issue of the genesis and evolution of the concept of “constitutional identity”, concludes that the contradictions between the two levels of jurisdiction, international and national, have naturally affected domestic legal practices. The national constitutional courts have come to a pronounced need for creation of a special area of legal regulation (constitutional identity), that would have the “immunity” for the decisions of international judicial bodies. This concept acts as a means of legal argumentation resorted to by the bodies of constitutional judicial control when justifying decisions in the case if it is necessary to uphold the basic fundamental values of the constitutional legal order. Particular attention is paid to the topic of correlation of the idea of constitutional identity with the doctrine of counter-limits. The author also considers the relationship between constitutional identity and the doctrine of the “margin of appreciation”, since the legal effect of the decisions of international judicial bodies depends on their recognition and respect for the national constitutional identity.
How to Cite:
Belosludtsev O.S., (2020), CONSTITUTIONAL IDENTITY AS THE BASIS FOR RESOLUTION OF CONVENTION-CONSTITUTIONAL CONFLICTS. Sociopolitical Sciences, 2 => 60-65.
Reference list:
Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti polozheniy stat i 1 Federal nogo zakona O ratifikatsii Konventsii o zashchite prav cheloveka i osnovnykh svobod i Protokolov k ney , punktov 1 i 2 stat i 32 Federal nogo zakona O mezhdunarodnykh dogovorakh RF , chastey pervoy i chetvertoy stat i 11, punkta 4 chasti chetvertoy stat i 392 Grazhdanskogo protsessual nogo kodeksa RF, chastey 1 i 4 stat i 13, punkta 4 chasti 3 stat i 311 Arbitrazhnogo protsessual nogo kodeksa RF, chastey 1 i 4 stat i 15, punkta 4 chasti 1 stat i 350 Kodeksa administrativnogo sudoproizvodstva RF i punkta 2 chasti chetvertoy stat i 413 Ugolovno-protsessual nogo kodeksa RF v svyazi s zaprosom gruppy deputatov Gosudarstvennoy Dumy: Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Ros. Federatsii ot 14 iyulya 2015 g. № 21-P Elektronnyy resurs . Dostup iz sprav.-pravovoy sistemy Konsul tant plyus .
Po delu o razreshenii voprosa o vozmozhnosti ispolneniya v sootvetstvii s Konstitutsiey Rossiyskoy Federatsii postanovleniya Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka ot 4 iyulya 2013 goda po delu Anchugov i Gladkov protiv Rossii v svyazi s zaprosom Ministerstva yustitsii Rossiyskoy Federatsii: Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Ros. Federatsii ot 19 aprelya 2016 g. № 12-P Elektronnyy resurs . Dostup iz sprav.-pravovoy sistemy Konsul tant plyus .
Po delu o razreshenii voprosa o vozmozhnosti ispolneniya v sootvetstvii s Konstitutsiey Rossiyskoy Federatsii postanovleniya Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka ot 31 iyulya 2014 goda po delu OAO Neftyanaya kompaniya YUKOS protiv Rossii v svyazi s zaprosom Ministerstva yustitsii Rossiyskoy Federatsii: Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Ros. Federatsii ot 19 yanv. 2017 g. № 1-P Elektronnyy resurs . Dostup iz sprav.-pravovoy sistemy Konsul tant plyus .
Postanovlenie ESPCH ot 25 aprelya 1978 g. Delo: Tayrer (Tyrer) protiv Soedinennogo Korolevstva (zhaloba № 5856/72). Elektronnyy resurs . URL: http:// europeancourt.ru/uploads/ECHR Tyrer v the United Kingdom 25 04 1978.pdf (data obrashcheniya: 12.03.2020).
Postanovlenie ESPCH ot 13 iyunya 1979 g. Delo: Marks protiv Bel gii (Marckx v. Belgium) (zhaloba № 6833/74).
Reshenie Federal nogo konstitutsionnogo suda Germanii ot 25 maya 1974 g. BverfGE 37, 271 2 BvL 52/71 Solange I - Beschlub. Elektronnyy resurs . URL: https://law.utexas. edu/transnational/foreign-law translations/german/case. php id 588 (data obrashcheniya: 29.02.2020).
Reshenie Konstitutsionnogo suda Italii ot 27 dekabrya 1973 goda № 183/73. Elektronnyy resurs . URL: http:// www.giurcost.org/decisioni/1973/0183s-73.html (data obrashcheniya: 29.02.2020).
Reshenie Federal nogo Konstitutsionnogo suda Germanii ot 12 oktyabrya 1993 goda. BVerfGE 89/155. Elektronnyy resurs . URL: https://www.bundesverfassungsgericht.de/DE/ Das-Gericht/Zeitstrahl/zeitstrahl node.html (data obrashcheniya: 29.02.2020).
Reshenieot14oktyabrya2004g.(№2BvR1481/04). Elektronnyy resurs . URL: https://dpp.mpil.de/04 2015/04 2015 81 105. pdf (data obrashcheniya: 25.02.2020).
Reshenie Federal nogo Konstitutsionnogo suda Germanii ot 30 iyunya 2009 goda. BVerfGE 123/267 Elektronnyy resurs . URL: https://www.bundesverfassungsgericht.de/DE/ DasGericht/Zeitstrahl/zeitstrahl node.html (data obrashcheniya: 29.02.2020).
Reshenie Konstitutsionnogo suda Italii ot 22 oktyabrya 2014 goda № 238. Elektronnyy resurs . URL: http://www. qil-qdi.org/prova-3/ ftnref1 (data obrashcheniya: 29.02.2020).
Zaklyuchenie № 832/2015 Evropeyskoy komissii za demokratiyu cherez pravo (Venetsianskoy komissii) Okonchatel noe zaklyuchenie po popravkam v Federal nyy konstitutsionnyy zakon O Konstitutsionnom Sude Rossiyskoy Federatsii (CDL-AD(2016)016) Elektronnyy resurs . Dostup iz sprav.-pravovoy sistemy Konsul tant plyus .
Barile P. Ancora su diritto comunitario e diritto interno. Studi per il ventesimo anniversario dell Assemblea costituente. Vol. 6: Autonomie et garanzie costituzionali. Firenze: Vallecchi, 1969. R. 49.
Gadzhiev G.A. Konstitutsionnaya identichnost i prava cheloveka v Rossii // Pravo i gosudarstvo: kul turologicheskoe izmerenie: Mezhdunar. nauch.-prakt. konf., 1 dekabrya 2017 g. SPb.: SPbGUP, 2017. S. 19-28.
Gracheva S.A. Razvitie kontsepta konstitutsionnoy identichnosti v svyazi s poiskom podkhodov k razresheniyu konventsionno-konstitutsionnykh kolliziy i konfliktov // ZHurnal rossiyskogo prava. 2018. № 9. S. 52-64.
Zor kin V.D. Konstitutsionnaya identichnost Rossii: doktrina i praktika // ZHurnal konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya. 2017. № 4. S. 4-27.
Vittstum V.G., Bote M., Dol tser R. i dr. Mezhdunarodnoe pravo / per. s nem. N. Spitsa; sost. V. Bergmann. 2-e izd. M.: Infotropik Media, 2015. 1071 s.
Nussberger A. Evropeyskaya Konventsiya o zashchite prav cheloveka i osnovnykh svobod - Konstitutsiya dlya Evropy // Mezhdunarodnoe pravosudie. 2019. № 2 (30). S. 3-20
Stone S.A. On the constitutionalisation of the convention: The European court of human rights as a constitutional court (March 12, 2010). Revue Trimestrielle des Droits de l Homme. 2009. Vol. 80. Pp. 923-944. Available at SSRN. Elektronnyy resurs URL:https://ssrn.com/abstract 1569359 (data obrashcheniya: 12.03.2020).
Keywords:
constitutional identity, constitutional core, convention-constitutional conflicts, court on the model of society, principled resistance, constitutional control, the right to make a final statement, the doctrine of counter-limits, the doctrine of the margin of appreciation, the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation, the German Constitutional Court, the Italian Constitutional Court, the European Court of Human Rights.


Related Articles

PUBLIC LAW (STATE LAW) Pages: 14-19 Issue №22019
The Principle of the Social State in the Russian Federation: The Evolution of the Content and Application in the Decisions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation
the social state social rights and freedoms principles-requirements of the social state the Constitution of the Russian Federation the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation
Show more
5. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 76-78 Issue №6215
ROTECTING (NEGATIVE) FUNCTION OF BASIC RIGHTS IN DEFINITIONS AND DECISIONS OF THE CONSTITUTIONAL AND AUTHORIZED COURTS OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION SUBJECTS
the fundamental rights and freedoms the rights of man and citizen constitutional control the protective function of constitutional rights the competence of the constitutional and statutory courts of the Russian Federation
Show more
10. International law; European Law; Corporate law; Energy law Pages: 260-262 Issue №4982
Nature and organizational framework of the European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice of Council of Europe
The Council Of Europe The Commission competence The European court of human rights Convention
Show more
10. Judicial, prosecutorial, human rights and law enforcement activities Pages: 234-236 Issue №12615
ON THE UPDATE OF SOME PROVISIONS OF THE LEGISLATION OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION ABOUT SHIPBUILDING
the appointment of judges The Supreme Court Of The Russian Federation The Constitutional Court Of The Russian Federation
Show more
15. MISCELLANEOUS Pages: 306-312 Issue №18933
On the Role of the Constitutional Court in Criminal Proceedings in the Light of Amendments to the Constitution of the Russian Federation
the Constitutional Court the European Court of Human Rights the new circumstances the Constitutionality of the amendments to the Constitution
Show more
9. Forensics; Forensic expertise; Operational and search activities Pages: 178-182 Issue №9342
IS IT ALWAYS A PANACEA OPERATIONAL EXPERIMENT TO EXPOSE CORRUPT?
operational experiment bribe commercial bribery operatively-search activity The European Court of human rights
Show more
8. Criminal procedure Pages: 190-193 Issue №8046
The principle of the presumption of innocence in the jurisprudence of the European Court human rights
the presumption of innocence Convention for the protection of human rights and fundamental freedoms international legal standards of criminal procedure The European Court of human rights the principle of justice
Show more
3. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 132-135 Issue №12435
Application of the constitutional principles of local selfgovernment by the Russian courts
local government the application of the constitutional principles of local self-government conflict The Constitutional Court Of The Russian Federation courts of General jurisdiction
Show more
5. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 123-125 Issue №11287
TO THE QUESTION OF JUSTICE APPLICATIONCRIMINAL PROTECTION MEASURES
measure the accused a fair hearing The European Court of human rights criminal proceedings
Show more
3. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 127-131 Issue №12435
Constitutional Risks of Russia's recognition of the priority of an International Treaty before a National Law and ways of overcoming them in the Doctrine of the Constitutional Identity of the State
constitutional risk constitutional identity universally recognized principles and norms of international law international Treaty constitutional control
Show more