Globalization and Westernization: Horizons of “identification” and “discrimination”
( Pp. 106-114)
More about authors
Maltsev Konstantin G.
Dr. Sci. (Philos.), Professor; Professor, Department of Theory and Methodology of Science
Belgorod State Technological University named after V.G. Shukhov
Belgorod, Russian Federation Maltseva Anna V. Cand. Sci. (Polit.); associate professor, Department of Theory and Methodology of Science; Belgorod State Technological University named after V.G. Shukhov; Belgorod, Russian Federation Lomako Leonid L. senior lecturer at the Department of Theory and Methodology of Science; Belgorod state Technological University named after V.G. Shukhov; Belgorod, Russian Federation. Author ID: 685089; ORCID: 0000-0001-9608-615X; E-mail: parmenid@bk.ru
Belgorod state Technological University named after V.G. Shukhov
Belgorod, Russian Federation
Belgorod State Technological University named after V.G. Shukhov
Belgorod, Russian Federation Maltseva Anna V. Cand. Sci. (Polit.); associate professor, Department of Theory and Methodology of Science; Belgorod State Technological University named after V.G. Shukhov; Belgorod, Russian Federation Lomako Leonid L. senior lecturer at the Department of Theory and Methodology of Science; Belgorod state Technological University named after V.G. Shukhov; Belgorod, Russian Federation. Author ID: 685089; ORCID: 0000-0001-9608-615X; E-mail: parmenid@bk.ru
Belgorod state Technological University named after V.G. Shukhov
Belgorod, Russian Federation
Abstract:
The scientific relevance of distinguishing between “globalization” and “westernization” is due to the political requirement for the implementation of the “world economic order” in the liberal version of the “economic paradigm” (J. Agamben) of the social. Methodologically, one should distinguish between scientific/disciplinary analysis and philosophical interpretation of globalization; “Distinction” (“drawing boundaries”) is the exclusive prerogative of philosophy (M. Heidegger) and presupposes the presence of the concept of globalization (“radical metaphysical concept”) as “the unity of reality and meaning” the condition for the possibility of a «radical concept» is the ordering of perspectives/points of view in the horizon of a certain paradigm of the social; the dominance of the “economic paradigm” in Western European social science determines the formulation of the question regarding the subject of research, the way of its thematization and the area in which the distinction between “globalization” and “Westernization” is important: Westernization is a necessary aspect of globalization as a world order, along with “excluded localities” defined as a result of interpretation as “bipolar”; the distinction between “material” and “cosmological” values (in the terminology of D. Lala) presupposes the homogenization of the world order and the interpretation of “features” in terms of culture; the “remnant” not reduced to culture is interpreted as “absolutely different” and “locked up” in locality as a “prison” (Z. Bauman); sustainability is provided as a “balancing equilibrium” of the Westernized (“universal”) and “other” (“locality”) levels of the world order; the redistribution of power between the main actors/competitors of a single world order does not have a significant impact and is not relevant for distinguishing between “globalization” and “westernization” in terms of philosophical interpretation; “Civilizational paradigm” (S. Huntington) and “planetarism” (existential-historical thinking of M. Heidegger) are marginal for the approach to the study of globalization prevailing in the “positive sciences”, but they are of fundamental importance for its philosophical interpretation.
How to Cite:
Maltsev K.G., Maltseva A.V., Lomako L.L., (2020), GLOBALIZATION AND WESTERNIZATION: HORIZONS OF “IDENTIFICATION” AND “DISCRIMINATION”. Sociopolitical Sciences, 5 => 106-114.
Reference list:
Agamben Dzh. Homo sacer. CHrezvychaynoe polozhenie. M.: Evropa, 2011. 148 s.
Agamben Dzh. TSarstvo i slava. K teologicheskoy genealogii ekonomiki i upravleniya. M.; SPb: Izd-vo In-ta Gaydara; Fakul tet svobodnykh iskusstv i nauk SPbGU, 2018. 552 s.
Ankersmit F.R. Politicheskaya reprezentatsiya. M.: Izd. dom Gos. un-ta Vysshaya shkola ekonomiki , 2012. 288 c.
Arrigi Dzh. Adam Smit v Pekine. CHto poluchil v nasledstvo XXI vek. M.: In-t obshchestvennogo proektirovaniya, 2009. 456 s.
Bauman Z. Globalizatsiya. Posledstviya dlya cheloveka i obshchestva. M.: Ves Mir, 2004. 188 s.
Bek U. Kosmopoliticheskoe mirovozzrenie. M.: TSentr issledovaniy postindustrial nogo obshchestva, 2008. 336 s.
Bek U. CHto takoe globalizatsiya M.: Progress-Traditsiya, 2001. 304 s.
Veber M. Osnovnye sotsiologicheskie ponyatiya // Veber M. Izbrannye proizvedeniya. M.: Progress, 1990. S. 602-643.
Veber M. Sotsiologiya // Veber M. KHozyaystvo i obshchestvo: ocherki ponimayushchey sotsiologii. V 4-kh tt. T. I. M.: Izd. dom Gos. un-ta Vysshaya shkola ekonomiki , 2016. 445 s.
Gegel G.V.F. Lektsii po filosofii istorii. SPb.: Nauka, 2000. 480 s.
Gegel G.V.F. Filosofiya prava. M.: Mysl , 1990. 524 s.
ZHizhek S. O nasilii. M.: Evropa, 2010. 184 s.
Lal D. Pokhvala imperii: Globalizatsiya i poryadok. M.: Novoe izdatel stvo, 2010. 364 s.
Lindsi B. Globalizatsiya: povtorenie proydennogo. Neopredelennoe budushchee global nogo kapitalizma. M.: IRISEN, 2006. 415 s.
Mal tsev K.G., Mal tseva A.V., Lomako L.L. Ponyatie politicheskogo i mirovoy besporyadok : perspektivy soglasiya, voyny i global nogo imperskogo poryadka. Belgorod: Izd-vo BGTU im. V.G. SHukhova, 2020. 914 s.
Mann M. Stanovlenie klassov i natsiy-gosudarstv, 1760-1914 gody // Mann M. Istochniki sotsial noy vlasti. V 4-kh tt. T. 2. CH. 1, 2. M.: Delo, 2018. 503 s. 507 s.
Mann M. Globalizatsii, 1945-2011 gody // Mann M. Istochniki sotsial noy vlasti. V 4-kh tt. T. 4. M.: Delo, 2019. 664 s.
Polan i K. Velikaya transformatsiya. Politicheskie i ekonomicheskie istoki nashego vremeni. SPb.: Aleteyya, 2002. 320 s.
Rozanov V.V. Listva. Uedinennoe. Opavshie list ya. Ukazateli // Rozanov V.V. Sobr. soch. T. 30. M.: Respublika; SPb.: Rostok, 2010. 591 s.
Smit A. Issledovanie o prirode i prichinakh bogatstva narodov. M.: Sotsekgiz, 1962. 684 s.
Fukuyama F. Konets istorii i posledniy chelovek. M: ACT: ACT Moskva: Poligrafizdat, 2010. 588 s.
KHaydegger M. Nitsshe. T. 1. SPb.: Vladimir Dal , 2006. 608 s.
KHaydegger M. Razmyshleniya II-VI (CHernye tetradi 1931-1938). M.: Izd-vo In-ta Gaydara, 2016. 584 s.
KHaydegger M. Razmyshleniya VII-XI (CHernye tetradi 1938-1939). M.: Izd-vo In-ta Gaydara, 2018. 528 s.
KHantington S. Stolknovenie tsivilizatsiy. M.: OOO Izdatel stvo ACT , 2003. 603 s.
KHardt M., Negri A. Imperiya. M.: Praksis, 2004. 440 s.
SHmitt K. Dukhovno-istoricheskoe sostoyanie sovremennogo parlamentarizma // SHmitt K. Politicheskaya teologiya. M.: Kanon-Press-TS, 2000a. C. 155-258
SHmitt K. Nomos Zemli v prave narodov Jus publicum Europaeum. SPb.: Vladimir Dal , 2008. 669 s.
SHmitt K. Politicheskaya teologiya // SHmitt K. Politicheskaya teologiya. M.: Kanon-Press-TS, 2000b. C. 7-98.
SHmitt K. Ponyatie politicheskogo // SHmitt K. Ponyatie politicheskogo. SPb.: Nauka, 2016. C. 280-408.
SHpengler O. Geshtal t i deystvitel nost // SHpengler O. Zakat Evropy. T. 1. M.: Mysl , 1998. 663 s.
El ster YU. Kislyy vinograd: Issledovanie provalov ratsional nosti. M.: Izd-vo In-ta Gaydara, 2018. 296 s.
Kennedy P. The rise and fall of the great powers. London. Fontana Press, 1989.
Rowls J. Political liberalism. New York: Columbia University Press, 1996. 525 r.
Agamben Dzh. TSarstvo i slava. K teologicheskoy genealogii ekonomiki i upravleniya. M.; SPb: Izd-vo In-ta Gaydara; Fakul tet svobodnykh iskusstv i nauk SPbGU, 2018. 552 s.
Ankersmit F.R. Politicheskaya reprezentatsiya. M.: Izd. dom Gos. un-ta Vysshaya shkola ekonomiki , 2012. 288 c.
Arrigi Dzh. Adam Smit v Pekine. CHto poluchil v nasledstvo XXI vek. M.: In-t obshchestvennogo proektirovaniya, 2009. 456 s.
Bauman Z. Globalizatsiya. Posledstviya dlya cheloveka i obshchestva. M.: Ves Mir, 2004. 188 s.
Bek U. Kosmopoliticheskoe mirovozzrenie. M.: TSentr issledovaniy postindustrial nogo obshchestva, 2008. 336 s.
Bek U. CHto takoe globalizatsiya M.: Progress-Traditsiya, 2001. 304 s.
Veber M. Osnovnye sotsiologicheskie ponyatiya // Veber M. Izbrannye proizvedeniya. M.: Progress, 1990. S. 602-643.
Veber M. Sotsiologiya // Veber M. KHozyaystvo i obshchestvo: ocherki ponimayushchey sotsiologii. V 4-kh tt. T. I. M.: Izd. dom Gos. un-ta Vysshaya shkola ekonomiki , 2016. 445 s.
Gegel G.V.F. Lektsii po filosofii istorii. SPb.: Nauka, 2000. 480 s.
Gegel G.V.F. Filosofiya prava. M.: Mysl , 1990. 524 s.
ZHizhek S. O nasilii. M.: Evropa, 2010. 184 s.
Lal D. Pokhvala imperii: Globalizatsiya i poryadok. M.: Novoe izdatel stvo, 2010. 364 s.
Lindsi B. Globalizatsiya: povtorenie proydennogo. Neopredelennoe budushchee global nogo kapitalizma. M.: IRISEN, 2006. 415 s.
Mal tsev K.G., Mal tseva A.V., Lomako L.L. Ponyatie politicheskogo i mirovoy besporyadok : perspektivy soglasiya, voyny i global nogo imperskogo poryadka. Belgorod: Izd-vo BGTU im. V.G. SHukhova, 2020. 914 s.
Mann M. Stanovlenie klassov i natsiy-gosudarstv, 1760-1914 gody // Mann M. Istochniki sotsial noy vlasti. V 4-kh tt. T. 2. CH. 1, 2. M.: Delo, 2018. 503 s. 507 s.
Mann M. Globalizatsii, 1945-2011 gody // Mann M. Istochniki sotsial noy vlasti. V 4-kh tt. T. 4. M.: Delo, 2019. 664 s.
Polan i K. Velikaya transformatsiya. Politicheskie i ekonomicheskie istoki nashego vremeni. SPb.: Aleteyya, 2002. 320 s.
Rozanov V.V. Listva. Uedinennoe. Opavshie list ya. Ukazateli // Rozanov V.V. Sobr. soch. T. 30. M.: Respublika; SPb.: Rostok, 2010. 591 s.
Smit A. Issledovanie o prirode i prichinakh bogatstva narodov. M.: Sotsekgiz, 1962. 684 s.
Fukuyama F. Konets istorii i posledniy chelovek. M: ACT: ACT Moskva: Poligrafizdat, 2010. 588 s.
KHaydegger M. Nitsshe. T. 1. SPb.: Vladimir Dal , 2006. 608 s.
KHaydegger M. Razmyshleniya II-VI (CHernye tetradi 1931-1938). M.: Izd-vo In-ta Gaydara, 2016. 584 s.
KHaydegger M. Razmyshleniya VII-XI (CHernye tetradi 1938-1939). M.: Izd-vo In-ta Gaydara, 2018. 528 s.
KHantington S. Stolknovenie tsivilizatsiy. M.: OOO Izdatel stvo ACT , 2003. 603 s.
KHardt M., Negri A. Imperiya. M.: Praksis, 2004. 440 s.
SHmitt K. Dukhovno-istoricheskoe sostoyanie sovremennogo parlamentarizma // SHmitt K. Politicheskaya teologiya. M.: Kanon-Press-TS, 2000a. C. 155-258
SHmitt K. Nomos Zemli v prave narodov Jus publicum Europaeum. SPb.: Vladimir Dal , 2008. 669 s.
SHmitt K. Politicheskaya teologiya // SHmitt K. Politicheskaya teologiya. M.: Kanon-Press-TS, 2000b. C. 7-98.
SHmitt K. Ponyatie politicheskogo // SHmitt K. Ponyatie politicheskogo. SPb.: Nauka, 2016. C. 280-408.
SHpengler O. Geshtal t i deystvitel nost // SHpengler O. Zakat Evropy. T. 1. M.: Mysl , 1998. 663 s.
El ster YU. Kislyy vinograd: Issledovanie provalov ratsional nosti. M.: Izd-vo In-ta Gaydara, 2018. 296 s.
Kennedy P. The rise and fall of the great powers. London. Fontana Press, 1989.
Rowls J. Political liberalism. New York: Columbia University Press, 1996. 525 r.
Keywords:
globalization, westernization, value assignment and evaluation, economic paradigm, world economic order, liberal metaphysics, “cultural identity”, global political order.
Related Articles
Theoretical and Historical Legal Sciences Pages: 11-16 DOI: 10.33693/2782-7372-2024-3-2-11-16 Issue №108322
Legal Problems of Ensuring Food Security in Modern Russia in the Context of Globalization and Mutual Restrictive Measures
globalization
regulation
security
monitoring
restrictive measures
Show more
ТЕОРЕТИКО-ИСТОРИЧЕСКИЕ ПРАВОВЫЕ НАУКИ (СПЕЦИАЛЬНОСТЬ 5.1.1.) Pages: 15-18 Issue №24364
The Problem of the Impact of Globalization on State Sovereignty
globalization
state sovereignty
conflict interaction
international relations
denazification
Show more
1. THEORY AND HISTORY OF STATE AND LAW, HISTORICAL STUDIES OF LAW AND STATE (12.00.01) Pages: 15-20 Issue №17728
Humanization of national law in the direction of globalization
humanization
humanization of law
humanization of legislation
globalization
legal globalization
Show more
WORLD POLITICS AND NATIONAL INTERESTS Pages: 15-22 DOI: 10.33693/2223-0092-2020-10-2-15-22 Issue №16644
Driving forces in global education policy scenarios
globalization
education
global educational policy
driving forces of development
scenarios
Show more
1. PHILOSOPHY AND VALUES OF MODERN SOCIETY Pages: 6-15 Issue №3724
THREATS AND CHALLENGES TO MODERN RUSSIA THROUGH THE PRISM OF PROPHECY OF «CLAB OF ROME»
geopolitics
globalization
"Golden billion"
corruption
international relations
Show more
History and Theory of Politics Pages: 24-32 DOI: 10.33693/2223-0092-2024-14-2-24-32 Issue №100812
The Concept of “Just War”: Horizon, Structure, Criticism
the concept of just war
anti-terrorist war
illegal enemy
economic paradigm of the political
global political order
Show more
1. NATIONAL ECONOMY AND MANAGEMENT 08.00.05 Pages: 35-39 Issue №19457
Specific Threats to the Financial Security and Sustainability of the Russian Federation in the Context of the Global Market
globalization
economic security
transnational corporations
financial sovereignty
international financial market
Show more
1. International scientific and practical conference «EFFECTIVE COUNTERING TO CRIME IN THE CONDITIONS OF GLOBALIZATION: PROBLEMS AND PERSPECTIVES» Pages: 20-21 Issue №11986
KEY FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO THE DEVELOPMENT OF EFFECTIVE MECHANISMS TO COUNTER INTERNATIONAL TERRORISM
terrorism
international terrorism
globalization
threats
systemic crisis
Show more
1. CURRENT ISSUES OF SOCIO-ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT OF RUSSIA. Pages: 17-21 Issue №10025
NATIONAL ECONOMIC SECURITY AND GLOBALIZATION: THREATS AND CHALLENGE
national security
a threat to national security
national security
the system of ensuring national security
the composition of the national security
Show more
2. POLITICAL RESEARCH Pages: 15-20 Issue №9525
THE EFFICIENCY OF POLITICAL FORECASTS AN ERA OF GLOBALIZATION
globalization
policy
political forecasting
uncertainty
focus system
Show more