Prospects for the Humanization of Criminal Policy in the Field of Entrepreneurship (Critical Analysis of the New Draft Law of the Ministry of Justice of Russia)
( Pp. 168-175)
More about authors
Asnis Alexander Ya.
Dr. Sci. (Law); Director
Law Firm “Asnis and Partners”
Moscow, Russian Federation
Law Firm “Asnis and Partners”
Moscow, Russian Federation
Abstract:
The reason for writing this article was the Draft federal law prepared by the Ministry of Justice of Russia in pursuance of point 9 of the List of Orders of the President of Russia following the results of the XXV St. Petersburg International Economic Forum of July 20, 2022, aimed at liberalizing and humanizing criminal legislation on liability for economic crimes, including crimes in the field of entrepreneurship and crimes related to the implementation of entrepreneurial activities. The main purpose of the corresponding order of the President of the country to the Government and the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation was to ensure the introduction of such changes into the federal legislation that would allow fully or partially (taking into account the level of real inflation in the country's economy) to decriminalize those crimes in the field of entrepreneurial activity (including acts related to the implementation of entrepreneurial activities without registration, license or accreditation), for the commission of which punishment in the form of imprisonment is not provided or applied. At the same time, the task of ensuring the priority of electing entrepreneurs suspected and accused of committing crimes of an economic nature (including members of the management bodies of commercial organizations) of such preventive measures that would allow them to continue to carry out entrepreneurial activities until their cancellation or sentencing had to be solved. The article presents the results of a critical analysis of the relevant bill, which allowed the author to conclude that this bill does not adequately meet the "letter" and "spirit" of the instructions of the President of Russia and does not allow achieving the above goals. The author proposes specific measures to eliminate the key shortcomings of the bill, including a significant expansion of the list of crimes of an economic nature, to which the provisions of Part 2 of Art. 761 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, the conditions for exemption from criminal liability in connection with compensation for damage. The author also justifies the need to abandon some of the novelties of the Criminal Code proposed by the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation, which may reduce the level of criminal law protection of rights to immovable property.
How to Cite:
Asnis A.Y., (2022), PROSPECTS FOR THE HUMANIZATION OF CRIMINAL POLICY IN THE FIELD OF ENTREPRENEURSHIP (CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE NEW DRAFT LAW OF THE MINISTRY OF JUSTICE OF RUSSIA). Gaps in Russian Legislation, 6 => 168-175.
Reference list:
Volzhenkin B.V. Official crimes. Monograph / Volzhenkin B.V. M.: Jurist, 2000. 368 p.
Gaukhman L.D., Maksimov S.V. Crimes in the sphere of economic activity / Gaukhman L.D., Maksimov S.V. M.: UCC «YurInfoR», 1998. 296 p.
Demidov Yu.N. Problems of combating crime in the social and budgetary sphere. Monograph / Demidov Yu.N. Moscow: Shchit-M, 2004. 438 p.
Crimes in the sphere of economy. Proc. allowance for universities / N. A. Lopashenko, M. I. Tretyak. Rep. ed. A. V. Naumov, A. G. Kibalnik. M.: Yurayt, 2022. 123 p.
Asnis A.Ya. New official crimes: prerequisites for criminalization and qualifications. Monograph / Asnis A.Ya. M.: Prospekt, 2021. 128 p.
Plenary session of the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum // http://www.kremlin.ru/events/president/transcripts/68669 (date of access: 04.11.2022).
Skryabin E.N. Features of criminal prosecution for crimes against the interests of the service / Skryabin E.N. // Journal of Russian law. 2002. No. 12. pp.89-99.
Yani P.S. Entrepreneurial crimes against property // Legality. 2017. No. 1. pp.46-51.
Ershova I.V. The concept of entrepreneurial activity in theory and judicial practice / Ershova I.V. // Lex Russica (Russian Law). 2014.№2. pp.160-167.
Mironyuk I.V. On the issue of criminal liability for malicious evasion of disclosure or provision of information defined by the legislation of the Russian Federation on securities / Mironyuk I.V. // Scientific Vedomosti. Series: Philosophy. Sociology. Law.2012. No. 20. Issue 22. pp.83-93.
Borovkov A.A. Fraud in the field of entrepreneurial activity (parts 5-7 of article 159 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation): problems of criminal law regulation and qualification: author. dis. ... cand. legal Sciences: 12.00.08 / Borovkov A.A.. Krasnoyarsk, 2018. 30 p.
Gaukhman L.D., Maksimov S.V. Crimes in the sphere of economic activity / Gaukhman L.D., Maksimov S.V. M.: UCC «YurInfoR», 1998. 296 p.
Demidov Yu.N. Problems of combating crime in the social and budgetary sphere. Monograph / Demidov Yu.N. Moscow: Shchit-M, 2004. 438 p.
Crimes in the sphere of economy. Proc. allowance for universities / N. A. Lopashenko, M. I. Tretyak. Rep. ed. A. V. Naumov, A. G. Kibalnik. M.: Yurayt, 2022. 123 p.
Asnis A.Ya. New official crimes: prerequisites for criminalization and qualifications. Monograph / Asnis A.Ya. M.: Prospekt, 2021. 128 p.
Plenary session of the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum // http://www.kremlin.ru/events/president/transcripts/68669 (date of access: 04.11.2022).
Skryabin E.N. Features of criminal prosecution for crimes against the interests of the service / Skryabin E.N. // Journal of Russian law. 2002. No. 12. pp.89-99.
Yani P.S. Entrepreneurial crimes against property // Legality. 2017. No. 1. pp.46-51.
Ershova I.V. The concept of entrepreneurial activity in theory and judicial practice / Ershova I.V. // Lex Russica (Russian Law). 2014.№2. pp.160-167.
Mironyuk I.V. On the issue of criminal liability for malicious evasion of disclosure or provision of information defined by the legislation of the Russian Federation on securities / Mironyuk I.V. // Scientific Vedomosti. Series: Philosophy. Sociology. Law.2012. No. 20. Issue 22. pp.83-93.
Borovkov A.A. Fraud in the field of entrepreneurial activity (parts 5-7 of article 159 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation): problems of criminal law regulation and qualification: author. dis. ... cand. legal Sciences: 12.00.08 / Borovkov A.A.. Krasnoyarsk, 2018. 30 p.
Keywords:
criminal law, criminal procedure law, economic crimes, entrepreneurship, business entities, decriminalization, humanization.
Related Articles
Pages: 10-14 DOI: 10.33693/2782-7372-2023-2-1-10-14 Issue №22977
Features of Russia’s Criminal Policy in the Context of Digitalization of Modern Society
criminal law
criminal offenses
scientific and technological progress
cybercrime
Show more
7. Criminal; Criminal enforcement law Pages: 141-145 Issue №9149
OPPORTUNITIES AND IMPERATIVES OF OSVOBORZHDENIJA FROM CRIMINAL LIABILITY
exemption from criminal liability
active repentance
a judicial fine
parole
economic crimes
Show more
Criminal law Pages: 218-222 Issue №23832
History of the Development of Domestic Criminal Legislation on Pornography
pornography
legislation on pornography
criminal law
pornographic materials and objects
criminal legislation on pornography.
Show more
4. CRIMINAL LAW (5.1.4.) Pages: 232-237 Issue №22137
Attracting to Community Services as Type of Criminal Punishmentin the Republic of Kazakhstan
criminal law
criminal responsibility
Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan arrest
correctional tasks
community services
Show more
3. GENERAL THEORETICAL, CRIMINAL-LEGAL AND OTHER PROBLEMS OF COUNTERING EXTREMISM AND TERRORISM. PROBLEMS OF PREVENTING EXTREMISM AND TERRORISM Pages: 187-192 Issue №21338
On Topical Issues of Counterterrorism in the Russian Federation: Criminal Legal Aspect
counteraction
fight
terrorism
terrorist activity
criminal law
Show more
5. Criminal; Criminal enforcement law Pages: 172-177 Issue №8598
The formation of subjective criminal liability preconditions («contemporaneity is growing out of the past»)
criminal law
criminal liability
the subject of the crime
individualization of responsibility
criminal economic law
Show more
7. Criminal law, Criminal enforcement law, Criminology Pages: 163-165 Issue №8046
Some issues of the retroactive force of criminal law in view of changing of General part of Criminal Code of Russian Federation
retroactivity
change
categories of crimes
criminal law
the sentence
Show more
6. Criminology Pages: 146-150 Issue №6543
Criminological Characteristics of Criminality in Prison
deviant behavior
disruptive action
a social phenomenon
prison crime
criminal law
Show more
14. ECONOMICS AND NATIONAL ECONOMY MANAGEMENT, ENTREPRENEURSHIP, MARKETING, MANAGEMENT Pages: 150-153 Issue №4029
SEVEN STEPS ON THE WAY OF SMALL BUSINESS TO SUCCESS
entrepreneurship
the business environment
property support
procurement
lending
Show more
ECONOMICS AND NATIONAL ECONOMY MANAGEMENT, MARKETING, MANAGEMENT Pages: 141-144 Issue №2286
Character conversion’s processes and their influence on competitiveness of business
competitiveness
entrepreneurship
the transformation process
efficiency
regulation
Show more