Methodology for the Participation of the Prosecutor in the Study of Expert Opinions in the Court of Appeal
( Pp. 250-254)
More about authors
Pavlova Elena Vitalievna
zamestitel nachalnika ugolovno-sudebnogo upravleniya
Prosecutor's Office of the Moscow Region
Moscow, Russian Federation
Prosecutor's Office of the Moscow Region
Moscow, Russian Federation
Abstract:
Purpose of the study: The article discusses the main issues of the participation of the prosecutor in the study of expert opinions in the court of appeal. The effectiveness of this activity depends on its implementation on the correct methodological basis. The author formulates the definition of the concept of the corresponding methodology, considers its components, determines its place in the general methodology for the participation of the prosecutor in the appeal trial. Examples of practice show some typical schemes of actions of a prosecutor participating in a session of the court of appeal, preparing for the examination of expert opinions contested by the defense side, forming his position on this issue and bringing it to the attention of the court. The author formulated the conclusion that this activity of the prosecutor is aimed at assisting the court of appeal in making a lawful and cogent decision regarding the expert's opinion, who, in the opinion of the defense, justified the court's verdict or which was unreasonably excluded from the evidence. An opinion is expressed about the still insufficient use by both the courts of appeal and the prosecutors participating in their sessions of the possibilities for resolving disputed situations by appointing and conducting additional or repeated expert examination. In this regard, a suggestion was made to establish in the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation a norm obliging the court to use this opportunity.
How to Cite:
Pavlova E.V., (2021), METHODOLOGY FOR THE PARTICIPATION OF THE PROSECUTOR IN THE STUDY OF EXPERT OPINIONS IN THE COURT OF APPEAL. Gaps in Russian Legislation, 6 => 250-254.
Reference list:
Razinkina A.N., Reshetova N.Yu., Khaliulin A.G. The participation of the prosecutor in the consideration of criminal cases by the courts of appeal of general jurisdiction: a guide. - M .: University of the Prosecutor's Office of the Russian Federation, 2020, p. 51.
On amendments and additions to certain decisions of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation: Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of June 29, 2021 No. 22 // Ros.gazeta, No. 159, July 16, 2021.
Solovieva N.A., Trishina N.T. Legal-factual verification of the verdict in the appeal proceedings: monograph. - M .: Jurlitinform, 2013. S. 90-91.
On amendments and additions to certain decisions of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation: Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of June 29, 2021 No. 22 // Ros.gazeta, No. 159, July 16, 2021.
Solovieva N.A., Trishina N.T. Legal-factual verification of the verdict in the appeal proceedings: monograph. - M .: Jurlitinform, 2013. S. 90-91.
Keywords:
appeal proceedings, prosecutor, defense side, expert opinion, methodology, violation of the law.
Related Articles
DEBATING ISSUES OF HISTORY Pages: 30-36 DOI: 10.33693/2658-4654-2023-5-3-30-36 Issue №23446
Theoretical Approaches to the Question of Defining the Concept of «Monument of Industrial Heritage» in the USSR
terminology
methodology
industrial heritage
monument
conferences
Show more
11. YOUNG SCIENTISTS IN ACTUAL CRIMIAL LAW PROBLEMS SOLVING Pages: 230-233 Issue №17728
Procedure for implementation of prosecutor's supervision over the activities of bodies of inquiry at the stage of preliminary investigation
Investigator
Prosecutor
process
inquiry
supervision
Show more
REGIONAL AND SECTORAL ECONOMICS Pages: 224-228 Issue №24704
Development of a Methodology for Checking Counterparties to Implement the Principle of Due Diligence
due diligence
methodology
tax control
counterparty
economic security.
Show more
13. MISCELLANIOUS Pages: 178-181 Issue №18017
System of methodological approaches in historical and pedagogical research
pedagogy
history
thinking
science
methodology
Show more
10. Forensics; Forensic expertise; Operational and search activities; Criminal procedure Pages: 143-146 Issue №10386
EVIDENTIARY ACTIVITIES FEATURES BY INQUIRY PRODUCTION IN THE REDUCED FORM
proof
urgent investigative actions
verification of evidence
the principle of the presumption of innocence in pre-trial proceedings
forensic examination
Show more
5. Philosophical sciences, Social science Political science Pages: 115-118 Issue №2418
BASIC CONDITIONS AND FEATURES OF APPLICATION OF POLITICAL CYCLISTICS AND CLASSIFICATION IN THE COURSE OF THE POLITICAL ANALYSIS
the fundamental theory
methodology
political ciclistica
political taxonomy
subsystem
Show more
13. Philosophy of history and modern historical researches Pages: 152-159 Issue №10327
Different points of view in the history of Russia: world outlook
the state
the historical process
historiography
methodology
logic
Show more
9. Human and civil rights and freedoms, guarantees of their provision Pages: 138-141 Issue №7176
ABOUT REMOVAL OF THE OBSERVERS AND OTHER PERSONS BREAKING THE LAW ON ELECTIONS, REFERENDA FROM THE ROOM FOR VOTE IN THE ORDER ESTABLISHED BY THE CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LEGAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION AND THE CODE OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION ABOUT ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENSES
elections
violation of the law
deletion of observers
the bodies of internal Affairs
Show more
REGIONAL AND SECTORAL ECONOMICS Pages: 239-249 Issue №24576
Development of a Procedure for Controlled Withdrawal of Industrial Enterprises from Equilibrium for Transition to a Higher-Level Innovative Development
economic stability
innovation
enterprise
methodology
theory of system limitation
Show more
6. Criminology Pages: 183-186 Issue №3132
Planning and modeling of measures to combat organized crime: features methodologies and perspectives
planning against crime
modeling
methodology
a systematic approach
quantitative and qualitative characteristics
Show more