In Regards to Improvement of Payment Procedure for Forensic Expertise in Civil and Arbitration Procedures
( Pp. 123-129)
More about authors
Svetlana A. Smirnova
Dr.Sci.(Law), Professor, Honored Scientist of the Russian Federation, Honored Lawyer of the Russian Federation, Head of the Department of Judicial Activity of the Law Institute
Peoples' Friendship University of Russia named after Patrice Lumumba (RUDN)
; Moscow, Russian Federation Maxim V. Mozgov Cand.Sci.(History), Managing Director, Division for Judicial Recovery of Troubled Debts of Corporate Clients, Legal Department; Joint-Stock Company Gazprombank
Peoples' Friendship University of Russia named after Patrice Lumumba (RUDN)
; Moscow, Russian Federation
Peoples' Friendship University of Russia named after Patrice Lumumba (RUDN)
; Moscow, Russian Federation Maxim V. Mozgov Cand.Sci.(History), Managing Director, Division for Judicial Recovery of Troubled Debts of Corporate Clients, Legal Department; Joint-Stock Company Gazprombank
Peoples' Friendship University of Russia named after Patrice Lumumba (RUDN)
; Moscow, Russian Federation
Abstract:
Abstract: The purpose of the research. The article deals with the actual problem of payment for expertise in civil and arbitration proceedings. Legal norms in terms of payment for expertise, their transformation, and influence on the legal position of a forensic expert are analysed. The purpose of the study is to identify the existing gaps of legal regulation affecting the mechanism of payment for expertise, as well as the author's proposals for their settlement by making appropriate changes in the legislation. This is necessary to improve the mechanism of payment for expertise in civil and arbitration proceedings. Results. As a result of the conducted research, the author concludes that recent changes in the civil procedural legislation, in terms of assigning a forensic examination only after depositing money to the court deposit, if there are no grounds to assign it at the expense of the budget, have significantly improved the position of the expert, but still a number of issues remain unresolved. Expert organizations often face the problem of receiving money from the court deposit without a reason and sufficient grounds for such delay. The author concludes that the problem of payment for expert examinations in civil and arbitration proceedings should be approached in a differentiated manner, supplementing the legislation with special mechanisms dedicated to the payment of remuneration to the expert.
How to Cite:
Smirnova S.A., Mozgov M.V. In Regards to Improvement of Payment Procedure for Forensic Expertise in Civil and Arbitration Procedures // Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2024. Vol. 17. №6. Pp. 123-129. (in Russ.). DOI: 10.33693/2072-3164-2024-17-6-123-129. EDN: ERBEUC
Reference list:
Zamaraeva N.A. Forensic examinations: why experts are not paid and how to fix it? // Legal Academy. Legal talks webinars. Rubric “Author's View”. Link: https://legalacademy.ru/sphere/post/sudebnye-ekspertizy-pochemu-ekspertam-ne-platyat-i-kak-eto-ispravit.
Zatonova D.Y. Property claim of a forensic expert on payment for the work performed by him. Commentary to the Decree of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation of July 20, 2023 N 43-P // Herald of Civil Procedure. 2023. N 6. P. 183 - 200.
Epstein V.A. Actual problems of recovery of funds for forensic expertise in civil proceedings // Gaps in Russian legislation. 2023. Т. 16. №8. P. 167- 171.
Epshteyn V.A. Aktual nye problemy vzyskaniya sredstv za provedennye sudebnye ekspertizy v grazhdanskom protsesse // Probely v rossiyskom zakonodatel stve. 2023. T. 16. №8. S. 167- 171.
Zatonova D.Y. Property claim of a forensic expert on payment for the work performed by him. Commentary to the Decree of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation of July 20, 2023 N 43-P // Herald of Civil Procedure. 2023. N 6. P. 183 - 200.
Epstein V.A. Actual problems of recovery of funds for forensic expertise in civil proceedings // Gaps in Russian legislation. 2023. Т. 16. №8. P. 167- 171.
Epshteyn V.A. Aktual nye problemy vzyskaniya sredstv za provedennye sudebnye ekspertizy v grazhdanskom protsesse // Probely v rossiyskom zakonodatel stve. 2023. T. 16. №8. S. 167- 171.
Keywords:
legal system, forensic, commissioning of expert study, payment for the expert report, civil proceedings, arbitration proceedings..
Related Articles
MULTI-VECTOR SCHOOL OF CIVILISTIC AND COMPARATIVE LEGAL RESEARCH Pages: 14-17 Issue №7907
BRIEF ACCOUNT OF JUDICIAL SYSTEM OF KINGDOM OF SPAIN
the judicial system
foreign legislation
The Kingdom Of Spain
constitutional basis
civil proceedings
Show more
7. CIVIL LAW; ENTREPRENEURIAL LAW; FAMILY LAW; INTERNATIONAL PRIVATE LAW Pages: 93-96 Issue №10025
CONCEPT LEGAL FACTS IN CIVIL PROCEEDINGS
civil procedural law
civil proceedings
legal fact
the structure of the law
elements of the legal fact
Show more
14. CIVIL PROCEDURE ARBITRATION; PROCEDURE 12.00.15 Pages: 288-293 Issue №18348
The actual issues of the judicial representation reformation in civil and arbitral proceedings
the right to judicial protection
legal representation
arbitration proceedings
civil proceedings
legal representation
Show more
13. Civil procedure arbitration procedure Pages: 244-248 Issue №15895
Court costs and its compensation in civil proceedings: concept and legal nature
court costs
liability theory
risk theory
parties to a civil case
civil proceedings
Show more
11. ADMINISTRATIVE LAW, ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESS (12.00.14) Pages: 262-265 Issue №18617
On some issues of legal and administrative norms of the Code of Noah (based on the analysis of the Book of Genesis of the Mosaic Pentateuch)
administrative law
government
public administration
legal system
sources of law
Show more
4. CIVIL LAW, INTERNATIONAL PRIVATE LAW, HOUSING LAW, FAMILY LAW, CIVIL PROCEDURE, ARBITRATION PROCESS Pages: 189-194 Issue №10864
Competition of types of legal proceedings: civil and administrative
civil proceedings
administrative proceedings
regulatory legal act
direct judicial control
indirect judicial control
Show more
1. EFFECTIVE COUNTERING TO CRIME IN THE CONDITIONS OF GLOBALIZATION: PROBLEMS AND PERSPECTIVES International scientific and practical conference, May 26-27, 2017, Nalchik Pages: 115-116 Issue №10195
CHECK THE MAJOR VERSIONS IN THE COLLECTION OF PRIMARY MATERIAL AS A WAY OF SOLVING CRIMES IN HOT PURSUIT
confrontation
crime
investigation
the inspection of the scene
the activities of the investigator
Show more
9. ADMINISTRATIVE LAW, ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESS (12.00.14) Pages: 202-206 Issue №17728
Sources of administrative enforcement rules in the Old Testament legislation (based on the analysis of the Book of Leviticus of the Moses Pentateuch)
administrative law
government
public administration
legal system
sources of law
Show more
8. CIVIL LAW BUSINESS LAW FAMILY LAW; PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW 12.00.03 Pages: 218-221 Issue №17564
Qualification of an inheritance relationship with a foreign element: choice of applicable law
legal system
foreign element
qualification
hereditary relation
conflict regulation
Show more
3. PRIVATE LAW (CIVIL) DISCIPLINES Pages: 190-198 Issue №19964
Summary Proceedings of Resolving Claims in Civil Proceedings
summary proceedings
civil proceedings
stages of legal proceedings
gaps in legislation
reform
Show more