Trends of a Global Legal Polysystem Based on the Negation of Bad Faith
( Pp. 150-156)

More about authors
Zhanna I. Sedova Cand. Sci. (Law), Department of International Law
Russian State University of Justice
Moscow, Russian Federation
Abstract:
Objective: The reason for writing the article is the discovery of the reception of some doctrines and legal mechanisms of common law by the Russian legal system. The purpose of the article is to highlight the grounds on which the convergence of legal systems is possible, in order to form a common good faith view of the subjects of law about their legitimate expectations from justice, the protection of their legitimate rights and interests in different legal orders, as well as to answer the question whether in any areas of legal relations it is possible to consider humanity as a single subject of law, relying among other things on the opinions of several Russian scholars and foreign lawyers (R. Kolb and M. V. Hesselink). Model: The methodological basis of the article is the analysis of Russian and foreign doctrine on the issues of convergence, unification, harmonization, reception, interpenetration, universalization, integration and essential transformation of legal systems; synthesis and generalization in the form of highlighting the basis for convergence of national legal systems; analysis of the possibilities of forming a global legal polysystem. Conclusions: International law and natural need of mankind in protection of good faith and its requirements on the basis of negation of bad faith conduct as a method of legal regulation are the bases for rapprochement of national legal systems. Scope of research / possibility of further use of scientific work results: Research results are a part of new complex approach to the study of «bad faith conduct» as an independent legal concept, as well as to substantiation of new method of legal regulation—negation of bad faith conduct, which influences the reception of the best norms aimed at the most effective protection against bad faith by legal systems of countries. Practical importance: The author considers it necessary to study legal issues arising in connection with globalization. The processes of globalization in the modern world are characterized by the fact that due to the rapid development of scientific and technological progress the movement of information flows beyond national borders through the «Internet» becomes uncontrollable, disputes about jurisdiction and sovereignty of states in cyberspace arise, and due to the ever closer integration of national commodity markets, services and capital the economic interdependence of different countries increases, which countries have begun restrain to by unilateral restrictive measures, there are increasing flows of human migration. Legal systems are inevitably influenced by these processes, bringing changes to legal regulation. Originality/value: The article is addressed to the legal scientific community, legal practitioners, may be useful to law students at universities.
How to Cite:
Sedova Zh. I. Trends of a Global Legal Polysystem Based on the Negation of Bad Faith // ECONOMIC PROBLEMS AND LEGAL PRACTICE. 2023. Vol. 19. № 2. P. 150-156. (in Russ.)
Reference list:
Burkovskaya V.A. Unfair procedural behavior: directions of improvement of the legislation // Judge. 2020. № 2. P. 56–59.
Vaipan V.A. The principle of justice in civil law and judicial discretion // Civil law. 2018. № 1. P. 22 —28.
Vaipan V.A. Judicial discretion in the practice of arbitration courts // Bulletin of arbitration practice. 2020. № 6. P. 3–13.
Globalization and development of the legislation: essays / Ed. by Yu.A. Tikhomirov, A.S. Pigolkin. М., 2004.
Dmitrieva, G.K. Rapprochement of the private law of different states in conditions of globalism: international-legal mechanisms. —Moscow: Moscow State Juridical University Press, 2012, № 6. P. 1303–1314.
Integration law in the modern world: a comparative legal study: monograph / V. A. Zhbankov, P. A. Kalinichenko, S. Yu. Kashkin and others; ed. by S. Yu. Kashkin. Moscow: Prospect, 2015. —416 p.
Kapitsa S.P. An Essay on the Theory of Human Growth: Demographic Revolution and Information Society. Ed. by Stereotype. M.: LENAND, 2019. —128 p.
Commentary to Article 253 of the APC RF. Article-by-article commentary to the Arbitration Procedural Code of the Russian Federation edited by P.V. Krasheninnikov. Statut. 2013.
Korshunov N.M. Convergence of private and public law: problems of theory and practice // M.: NORMA, INFRA-M, 2001, —240 p.
Kulikov V. Truth in the last instance. Judges will be instructed to follow the precedents of the Supreme Court of the country. // Rossiskaya gazeta—Federal issue No. 124(8178).
Kuchin M.V. Legal nature of a legal norm: an integrative approach // Journal of Russian Law. 2017. № 12. P. 31–42.
Marochkin S.Y. International law: 60 years after the UN creation // Journal of Russian Law. 2006. № 3.
Neshataeva T.N. International organizations and law. New tendencies in international legal regulation. —Moscow: Delo, 1998. —272 p.
Nikitina N.K. Russian legislation in the conditions of globalization (issues of theory and practice): Author's abstract of diss. … Candidate of jurisprudence. Moscow, 2008, —27 p.
Presnyakov M.V. Constitutional concept of the principle of justice / ed. by G.N. Komkova. Moscow: DMK Press, 2009. —384 p.
Problems of Unification of Private International Law: Monograph / Vlasova N.V., Doronina N.G., Lazareva T.P. et al; ed. by Makovsky A.L., Khlestova I.O. Moscow: IISP Jurisprudence, 2012. —488 p.
Sedova J.I. The principle of estoppel in the practice of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation // Journal «Russian Justice», special issue (to the IX All-Russian Congress of Judges), 2016. P. 139–148.
Sedova J.I. International legal entity as a subject of private international law. Diss. ... Candidate of jurisprudence. Moscow, 2001, —170 p.
Sklovsky K.I. Problems of application of the norm of article 451 of the Civil Code of the RF: the currency clause and the balance of interests of the parties to the contract // Bulletin of Economic Justice of the Russian Federation. 2016. № 7.
Talapina E.V. Modernization of public administration in the information society: information and legal research: Author's abstract of diss. … Candidate of jurisprudence. М., 2015.
Tretyakova O.D. Legal convergence. Author's abstract of diss... D. in Law. Vladimir, 2012. —42 p.
Unification and harmonization in international private law. Issues of theory and practice: monograph / Y.O. Alimova, N.N. Viktorova, G.K. Dmitrieva; otv. red. G.K. Dmitrieva, M.V. Mazhorina. M.: NORM, INFRA-M, 2016. —208 p.
Hesselink M.V. Principle of good faith // Bulletin of economic justice of the Russian Federation. 2020. № 8. P. 157–187.
Kolb R. Good Faith in International Law // Oxford and Portland, Oregon. Hart Publishing. 2017. —265 p.
Keywords:
global legal polysystem, law reception, convergence of legal systems, principle of good faith, denial of bad faith conduct..


Related Articles

МЕЖДУНАРОДНО-ПРАВОВЫЕ НАУКИ (СПЕЦИАЛЬНОСТЬ 5.1.5.) Pages: 193-199 Issue №24320
Excess of Authority or Good Faith Conduct: Liability Issues in the Energy Sector Under Foreign Unilateral Restrictive Measures
unilateral restrictive measures sanctions of unfriendly states board of directors excess of authority extreme necessity
Show more
МЕЖДУНАРОДНО-ПРАВОВЫЕ НАУКИ (СПЕЦИАЛЬНОСТЬ 5.1.5.) Pages: 297-304 Issue №24364
The Inadmissibility of Digital Misuse as a Type of Negation of Unfair Conduct in the Law
principle of good faith denial of bad faith conduct digital rights digital bad faith conduct legal remedies.
Show more