Administrative Arrest as a Judicial Administrative Punishment
( Pp. 31-36)
More about authors
Aleksander I. Stakhov
Dr.Sci.(Law), Professor, Head of the Department of Administrative Law and Procedure, n Federation
Russian State University of Justice
Moscow, Russia Maksim Yu. Stazhila postgraduate student of the Department of Administrative Law and Procedure, n Federation
Russian State University of Justice
Moscow, Russia
Russian State University of Justice
Moscow, Russia Maksim Yu. Stazhila postgraduate student of the Department of Administrative Law and Procedure, n Federation
Russian State University of Justice
Moscow, Russia
Abstract:
Abstract: The purpose of the research. The article analyzes the concept of understanding administrative arrest as a type of judicial administrative punishment through the prism of the historical experience of the national model of public force. The purpose of the research is to analyze the development of legislation on administrative liability in relation to administrative arrest in retrospect in order to establish criteria for classifying administrative arrest as judicial administrative punishments and prospects for the application of this type of punishment.
Results. As a result of the research, the authors come to the conclusion that the axiomatic nature of the modern perception of administrative arrest as a judicial administrative punishment is based on a long and logical path of development of legislation on administrative liability and the experience of the legislator's search for the optimal model of public force. The authors note that the basis for classifying administrative arrest as judicial administrative punishments is the criterion of limiting the personal constitutional rights of a person subjected to administrative punishment. Despite the discussion in the scientific community regarding the expediency of maintaining administrative arrest, the authors note the objective need of the legal system for this type of administrative punishment for the effective implementation of the administrative and protective function of the state, provided that the exceptional nature of its appointment is preserved.
Results. As a result of the research, the authors come to the conclusion that the axiomatic nature of the modern perception of administrative arrest as a judicial administrative punishment is based on a long and logical path of development of legislation on administrative liability and the experience of the legislator's search for the optimal model of public force. The authors note that the basis for classifying administrative arrest as judicial administrative punishments is the criterion of limiting the personal constitutional rights of a person subjected to administrative punishment. Despite the discussion in the scientific community regarding the expediency of maintaining administrative arrest, the authors note the objective need of the legal system for this type of administrative punishment for the effective implementation of the administrative and protective function of the state, provided that the exceptional nature of its appointment is preserved.
How to Cite:
Stakhov A.I., Stazhila M.Yu. Administrative Arrest as a Judicial Administrative Punishment // Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2024. Vol. 17. №5. Pp. 031-036. (in Russ.). DOI: 10.33693/2072-3164-2024-17-5-031-036. EDN: MFPRDU
Reference list:
Kardanova, M.A. Police arrest in monarchical Russia : Historical and legal research : abstract of the dissertation of the candidate of Legal Sciences: 12.00.01 / Kuban State Agrarian University. un-T. - Krasnodar, 2005. - 29 p.
Kirin A.V. Contradictions of the conceptual and legal status of arrest as an administrative punishment // Administrative law and process. 2011. No. 9. Pp. 32-34.
Pankova O.V. Optimization of justice in cases of administrative offenses // Bulletin of the O.E. Kutafin University (MSAL). 2021. № 6 (82). Pp. 145-154.
Stazhila M.Yu. The origins of the modern understanding of administrative liability // Formation, development and integration of extrajudicial and judicial administrative proceedings in the Russian Federation: Collection of scientific articles. Moscow: RGUP. 2023. Pp. 314-320.
Tarkhov, A.V. Administrative Punishments restricting personal freedom : abstract of the dissertation of the candidate of Legal Sciences : 12.00.14 / Moscow. The Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation. - Moscow, 2004. - 24 p.
Kirin A.V. Contradictions of the conceptual and legal status of arrest as an administrative punishment // Administrative law and process. 2011. No. 9. Pp. 32-34.
Pankova O.V. Optimization of justice in cases of administrative offenses // Bulletin of the O.E. Kutafin University (MSAL). 2021. № 6 (82). Pp. 145-154.
Stazhila M.Yu. The origins of the modern understanding of administrative liability // Formation, development and integration of extrajudicial and judicial administrative proceedings in the Russian Federation: Collection of scientific articles. Moscow: RGUP. 2023. Pp. 314-320.
Tarkhov, A.V. Administrative Punishments restricting personal freedom : abstract of the dissertation of the candidate of Legal Sciences : 12.00.14 / Moscow. The Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation. - Moscow, 2004. - 24 p.
Keywords:
public force, judicial administrative punishments, administrative arrest, administrative liability, system of administrative punishments, administrative offense..
Related Articles
CRIMINAL LAW, CRIMINOLOGICAL, ADMINISTRATIVE AND OTHER MEASURES TO COMBAT CRIME IN MODERN CONDITIONS Pages: 47-51 Issue №117858
Current Issues of Bringing Responsibility for Illegal Actions of Collectors
return of overdue debt
illegal actions
protection of the rights and legitimate interests of individuals
administrative liability
criminal liability.
Show more
5. CURRENT PROBLEMS OF THE CIVIL SOCIETY DEVELOPMENT AND THE PARTICIPATION OF ITS INSTITUTIONS IN PROVIDING PUBLIC SECURITY Pages: 162-166 Issue №18933
Public Control as a New Subject of Control in Places of Forced Detention
public control
supervision
rights
legitimate interests
public monitoring commission
Show more
10. Administrative law; Administrative process Pages: 202-207 Issue №7594
Development of administrative arrest as an exceptional form of punishment in the countries of the Eurasian Economic Union
administrative arrest
the exclusivity of punishment
The Eurasian economic Union
humanization of the Institute of administrative arrest
Show more
10. Administrative law; Administrative process Pages: 187-206 Issue №6543
The draft law of the Russian Federation Code of Administrative Offences: new for magistrates
the magistrate
the case of an administrative offense
the justices of peace
electronic document management
exemption from administrative liability
Show more