Assessment of Components of the Internal Control System for the Purpose of Risk Management of Organizations
( Pp. 251-257)
More about authors
Aksana A. Turgaeva
Cand. Sci. (Econ.), Associate Professor, Associate Professor of the economic security and risk management Department
Financial University under the Government of the Russian Federation
Moscow, Russian Federation
Financial University under the Government of the Russian Federation
Moscow, Russian Federation
Abstract:
Task. An effective internal control system is closely related to the risk management of the organization, namely, it reduces the risks of failure to achieve the set goals and, according to the COSO concept, provides reasonable assurance of their achievement. The subject of the study is the assessment of the components of the internal control system for the purpose of risk management of organizations. The object of the study is the internal control system of the organization. The article raises the problem of developing a methodology for assessing the formation of all components of the ICS in accordance with the COSO model. The problem lies in the insufficient number of studies on the systematization of control procedures for each component of the ICS in the context of assessing the system, describing standard and non-standard situations that must be responded to promptly and how to assess such situations in the context of internal control and risk management through qualitative indicators that are not measurable. Model. To substantiate the methodology for assessing the formation of all components of the ICS in accordance with the COSO model, the criterion for assessing and measuring non-financial indicators of financial stability of organizations is presented. The study uses the grouping method, which allows studying the interrelations of phenomena, as well as their interdependencies, to identify the influence of certain factors and trends. The article uses the comparative method as the most common method of analysis, as well as the methods of induction and synthesis. Conclusions. The methodology for assessing the formation of ICS components in accordance with the COSO model in organizations is of theoretical significance in terms of developing scientific and theoretical provisions concerning the construction of internal control and improving the effectiveness of ICS, as well as practical significance in the context of applying the developed package of documents. Practical significance. As a result, the methodology for assessing the formation of all ICS components in accordance with the COSO model was substantiated, a number of documents were developed that systematized the indicators for assessing the ICS components, including non-financial indicators. It is proposed to form a map of typical situations: standard and non-standard, as well as situations with increased complexity, allowing you to create new algorithms for action to reduce risk. Originality. The author's contribution is to develop a methodology for assessing the formation of all ICS components in accordance with the COSO model.
How to Cite:
Turgaeva A. A. Assessment of Components of the Internal Control System for the Purpose of Risk Management of Organizations // ECONOMIC PROBLEMS AND LEGAL PRACTICE. 2024. Vol. 20. № 4. P. 251-257. (in Russ.) DOI: 10.33693/2541-8025-2024-20-4-251-257. EDN: JGHIBE
Reference list:
Slabinskaya, I. A. Modern methods of assessing the internal control system in the management of an industrial enterprise / I. A. Slabinskaya, Yu. A. Tkachenko // Bulletin of the Belgorod University of Cooperation, Economics and Law. —2023. —No. 5 (102). —P. 54–62. —DOI 10.21295 / 2223-5639-2023-5-54-62. —EDN MRDHCP.
Endovitsky, D. A. Features of the formation of the internal control system in budgetary institutions of the social sphere / D. A. Endovitsky, S. V. Golovin, N. E. Spiridonova // Accounting in budgetary and non-profit organizations. —2023. —No. 11 (563). —P. 12–27. —EDN TFTKSQ.
Turishcheva, T. B. Identification, formulation and scientific substantiation of a set of performance indicators for the functioning of the internal control system of an autonomous institution / T. B. Turishcheva, A. I. Bolvachev // Azimuth of scientific research: economics and management. —2023. —Vol. 12, No. 1 (42). —P. 137–140. —DOI 10.57145/27128482_2023_12_01_25. —EDN DFZTNP.
Danchikov, E. A. Mechanisms for the formation of an internal procurement control system / E. A. Danchikov, S. N. Kovalenko // Economics and management: problems, solutions. —2023. —Vol. 2, No. 5 (137). —P. 131–138. —DOI 10.36871/ek.up.p.r.2023.05.02.019. —EDN WOYWFS.
Erykalin, M. I. Basic models for building an internal control system / M. I. Erykalin, N. A. Prodanova // Accounting in healthcare. —2023. —No. 5. —P. 35–43. —DOI 10.33920/med-17-2305-04. —EDN MNYXRB.
Bychkova, G. M. Features of assessing the level of organization of the internal control system: applied aspect / G. M. Bychkova, N. M. Dyakova // Collection of scientific papers of the Angarsk State Technical University. —2023. —No. 20. —P. 339–344. —EDN RVIHJA.
Ponomareva, S. V. The role of internal audit in monitoring the internal control system / S. V. Ponomareva, T. M. Rogulenko, M. Conde // Control and analytical, accounting technologies and economic security in business: Monograph. —Moscow: Limited Liability Company «Rusains», 2024. —Pp. 53–60. —EDN EVHCCC.
German, M. V. Functioning of the risk management and internal control system at a manufacturing enterprise / M. V. German, D. A. Pashkovsky, V. E. Zaykovsky // Bulletin of Tomsk State University. Economics. —2024. —No. 66. —Pp. 240–250. —DOI 10.17223/19988648/66/15. —EDN DTJAIV.
Turgaeva, A. A. Block-modular model of audit of the effectiveness of the internal control system / A. A. Turgaeva // Bulletin of the Kazan State Agrarian University. —2021. —Vol. 16, No. 1 (61). —P. 130–135. —DOI 10.12737 / 2073-0462-2021-130-135.
Turgaeva, A. A. Audit of the effectiveness of the internal control system in an insurance organization / A. A. Turgaeva // International accounting. —2020. —Vol. 23, No. 2 (464). —P. 168–189. —DOI 10.24891 / ia.23.2.168.
Turgaeva, A. A. Practical application of methods for assessing the effectiveness of the internal control system in insurance companies / A. A. Turgaeva // International accounting. —2020. —Vol. 23, No. 4 (466). —P. 428-443. —DOI 10.24891 / ia.23.4.428.
Turgaeva A.A. Assessment of the financial security of insurance companies in the organization of internal control / A.A. Turgaeva, L. V. Kashirskaya, Y. A. Zurnadzhyants [et al.] // Entrepreneurship and Sustainability Issues. —2020. —Vol. 7, No. 3. —P. 2243–2254. —DOI 10.9770 / jesi.2020.7.3 (52).
Marmilova E. Methods for conducting an audit of the effectiveness of internal control / E. Marmilova, L. Kashirskaya, M. Kubenka A. Turgaeva [et al.] // Journal of Security and Sustainability Issues. —2020. —Vol. 9, No. May. —P. 433-450. —DOI 10.9770/JSSI.2020.9.M(33).
Turgaeva, A. A. Audit of the effectiveness of the internal control system in an insurance organization / A. A. Turgaeva // International accounting. —2020. —Vol. 23, No. 2 (464). —P. 168–189. —DOI 10.24891/ia.23.2.168.
Endovitsky, D. A. Features of the formation of the internal control system in budgetary institutions of the social sphere / D. A. Endovitsky, S. V. Golovin, N. E. Spiridonova // Accounting in budgetary and non-profit organizations. —2023. —No. 11 (563). —P. 12–27. —EDN TFTKSQ.
Turishcheva, T. B. Identification, formulation and scientific substantiation of a set of performance indicators for the functioning of the internal control system of an autonomous institution / T. B. Turishcheva, A. I. Bolvachev // Azimuth of scientific research: economics and management. —2023. —Vol. 12, No. 1 (42). —P. 137–140. —DOI 10.57145/27128482_2023_12_01_25. —EDN DFZTNP.
Danchikov, E. A. Mechanisms for the formation of an internal procurement control system / E. A. Danchikov, S. N. Kovalenko // Economics and management: problems, solutions. —2023. —Vol. 2, No. 5 (137). —P. 131–138. —DOI 10.36871/ek.up.p.r.2023.05.02.019. —EDN WOYWFS.
Erykalin, M. I. Basic models for building an internal control system / M. I. Erykalin, N. A. Prodanova // Accounting in healthcare. —2023. —No. 5. —P. 35–43. —DOI 10.33920/med-17-2305-04. —EDN MNYXRB.
Bychkova, G. M. Features of assessing the level of organization of the internal control system: applied aspect / G. M. Bychkova, N. M. Dyakova // Collection of scientific papers of the Angarsk State Technical University. —2023. —No. 20. —P. 339–344. —EDN RVIHJA.
Ponomareva, S. V. The role of internal audit in monitoring the internal control system / S. V. Ponomareva, T. M. Rogulenko, M. Conde // Control and analytical, accounting technologies and economic security in business: Monograph. —Moscow: Limited Liability Company «Rusains», 2024. —Pp. 53–60. —EDN EVHCCC.
German, M. V. Functioning of the risk management and internal control system at a manufacturing enterprise / M. V. German, D. A. Pashkovsky, V. E. Zaykovsky // Bulletin of Tomsk State University. Economics. —2024. —No. 66. —Pp. 240–250. —DOI 10.17223/19988648/66/15. —EDN DTJAIV.
Turgaeva, A. A. Block-modular model of audit of the effectiveness of the internal control system / A. A. Turgaeva // Bulletin of the Kazan State Agrarian University. —2021. —Vol. 16, No. 1 (61). —P. 130–135. —DOI 10.12737 / 2073-0462-2021-130-135.
Turgaeva, A. A. Audit of the effectiveness of the internal control system in an insurance organization / A. A. Turgaeva // International accounting. —2020. —Vol. 23, No. 2 (464). —P. 168–189. —DOI 10.24891 / ia.23.2.168.
Turgaeva, A. A. Practical application of methods for assessing the effectiveness of the internal control system in insurance companies / A. A. Turgaeva // International accounting. —2020. —Vol. 23, No. 4 (466). —P. 428-443. —DOI 10.24891 / ia.23.4.428.
Turgaeva A.A. Assessment of the financial security of insurance companies in the organization of internal control / A.A. Turgaeva, L. V. Kashirskaya, Y. A. Zurnadzhyants [et al.] // Entrepreneurship and Sustainability Issues. —2020. —Vol. 7, No. 3. —P. 2243–2254. —DOI 10.9770 / jesi.2020.7.3 (52).
Marmilova E. Methods for conducting an audit of the effectiveness of internal control / E. Marmilova, L. Kashirskaya, M. Kubenka A. Turgaeva [et al.] // Journal of Security and Sustainability Issues. —2020. —Vol. 9, No. May. —P. 433-450. —DOI 10.9770/JSSI.2020.9.M(33).
Turgaeva, A. A. Audit of the effectiveness of the internal control system in an insurance organization / A. A. Turgaeva // International accounting. —2020. —Vol. 23, No. 2 (464). —P. 168–189. —DOI 10.24891/ia.23.2.168.
Keywords:
internal control, ICS components, control environment, monitoring, information system, risks, situations, goals, non-financial indicators..
Related Articles
Scientific Symposium “Risks of Social Change: Political Projection” Pages: 16-26 DOI: 10.33693/2223-0092-2024-14-4-16-26 Issue №131736
Interdependence of Social and Political Changes: Riscogenic Potential
social system
subsystem
integration
groups
interests
Show more
MANAGEMENT Pages: 233-237 DOI: 10.33693/2541-8025-2024-20-3-233-237 Issue №115847
Managing Risk Factors for an Adverse Event
internal control
risks
risk management
uncertainty
control tools.
Show more
18. ECONOMIC SECURITY AND RISKS MANAGEMENT Pages: 173-182 Issue №10025
THEORETICAL AND LEGAL UNDERPINNINGS OF ECONOMIC SECURITY OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION AS A COMPONENT OF THE STATE NATIONAL SECURITY
economic security
national security
Russia (Russian Federation)
USA
China
Show more
5.2.3. REGIONAL AND SECTORAL ECONOMICS Pages: 260-266 Issue №22298
Financial Analysis of an Insurance Organization within the Framework of Internal Control
internal control
insurance companies
correlation
control procedures
risks
Show more
10. Administrative law; Administrative process, Information Law Pages: 151-153 Issue №2490
Administrative and legal regulation of state control (supervision) in the field of protection, reproduction and use of fauna
control
the state faunistic control
animal world
the objects of the animal world
monitoring
Show more
8. CIVIL LAW BUSINESS LAW FAMILY LAW; PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW 12.00.03 Pages: 222-226 Issue №17564
On the issue of the nominal (special) account of operators of investment, financial platforms and information systems
operator
financial platform
investment platform
information system
credit organization
Show more
3. GENERAL THEORETICAL, CRIMINAL-LEGAL AND OTHER PROBLEMS OF COUNTERING EXTREMISM AND TERRORISM. PROBLEMS OF PREVENTING EXTREMISM AND TERRORISM Pages: 198-202 Issue №21338
Current Problems in Countering the Use of Social Networks to Spread Extremist and Terrorist Ideology
extremism
terrorism
social media
recruitment
combating
Show more
MANAGEMENT Pages: 252-255 DOI: 10.33693/2541-8025-2024-20-1-252-255 Issue №72283
Risk Management in the System of Ensuring Economic Security of Organizations
risk management
economic security
risks
control procedures.
Show more
MANAGEMENT Pages: 258-266 Issue №24067
Risks of the Formation of Public Spaces as Elements of Infrastructure and the Comfort of the Life of the Metropolis
public spaces
urban environment
risks
infrastructure
life comfort
Show more
5. CIVIL LAW; ENTREPRENEURIAL LAW; FAMILY LAW; INTERNATIONAL PRIVATE LAW; Civil procedure arbitration procedure Pages: 133-136 Issue №6840
The legal framework for ensuring the financial sustainability of the enterprises (organizations) in the Russian Federation
financial stability
reserve funds
bankruptcy
mandatory regulations
criteria
Show more