Russian Historical Science ahead of the 75th Anniversary of Victory in the Great Patriotic War
( Pp. 38-47)

More about authors
Kamynin Vladimir D.
Ural Federal University named after the first President of Russia B.N. Yeltsin
Yekaterinburg, Russian Federation
Read text
Abstract:
The article analyzes the changing attitude to the Victory of the Soviet Union in the Great Patriotic war of 1941-1945 in post-Soviet historiography. The significance of anniversaries in reviving the interest of the authorities, society and historians in the history of the Great Patriotic war is shown. It is concluded that the first attempt to refute the traditional concept of war was made by liberal authors in the years of “perestroika”. It is proved that in the first half of the 1990s, with the direct connivance of the official authorities of the Russian Federation, liberal historians revised the Soviet version of the history of the Great Patriotic war and formulated their own concept of the great Victory. The reason for the revision was the first anniversary of the great Victory in post-Soviet Russia in 1995. The appearance of the dichotomy “Great Patriotic war” and “‘Other war’ 1939-1945” The article analyzes the causes of discourse in Russian historiography on the main problems of the history of the Great Patriotic war in the early twentieth century. The article describes the efforts of the state authorities of modern Russia to counteract the falsification of the history of the Great Patriotic war and the influence of the information war that is being waged between the West and Russia after the beginning of the Ukrainian crisis. An assessment of the resolution of the European Parliament, which entrusted the USSR with the war, is given. The article deals with the tasks facing the historical science of Russia along with Nazi Germany of responsibility for unleashing the Second world war on the eve of the 75th anniversary of Victory in the Great Patriotic war.
How to Cite:
Kamynin V.D., (2020), RUSSIAN HISTORICAL SCIENCE AHEAD OF THE 75TH ANNIVERSARY OF VICTORY IN THE GREAT PATRIOTIC WAR. History and Modern Perspectives, 1 => 38-47.
Reference list:
Aleksandrov K.M. Protiv Stalina: Sbornik statey i materialov. M.: YUventa, 2003. 352 s.
Aleksandrov K.M. Russkie soldaty Vermakhta. Geroi ili predateli. M.: YAuza, Eksmo, 2005. 752 s.
Aleksandrov K.M. Armiya generala Vlasova 1944-1945. M.: YAuza, Eksmo, 2006. 592 s.
Aleksandrov K.M. Ofitserskiy korpus armii general-leytenanta A. A. Vlasova 1944-1945. M.: Posev, 2001. 1120 s.; Izd. 2-e, ispr. i dop. M.: Posev, 2009. 1100 s.
Afanas ev YU.N. Drugaya voyna: Istoriya i pamyat // Drugaya voyna 1939-1945. M., 1996. S. 15-31
Bezymenskiy L.A. Gitler i Stalin pered skhvatkoy. M.: Veche, 2000. 512 s.
Bordyugov G. Ukradennaya Pobeda // Komsomol skaya pravda. 1990. 5 maya.
Bortnevskiy V.G. Sud bu vybirayut. General Vlasov, vlasovtsy i drugie // Uchitel skaya gazeta. 1989. 18 maya.
Bortnevskiy G. V. Protiv svoego Otechestva // Smena (Leningrad). 1989. 27 avg.
Bunich I.L. Operatsiya Groza ili oshibka v tret em znake . Kn. 1. SPb.: VITA-OBLIK, 1994. 448 s.; Kn. 2. SPb.: YUNA-OBLIK. 1994. 667 s.
Bykova S.I., Baranova L.YA. Voyna i pamyat kak eticheskie i istoricheskie kategorii (na osnove issledovaniya znaniy studentov) // Izvestiya Ural. un-ta. 2011. Ser. 1 Problemy obrazovaniya, nauki i kul tury. № 1 (86). S. 26-30.
Velikaya Otechestvennaya voyna. 1941-1945. Voenno-istoricheskie ocherki. V 4 kn. M.: Nauka, 1998. Kn. 1. 544 s.; Kn. 2. 502 s.; 1999. Kn. 3.510 s.; Kn. 4. 368 s.
Velikaya Otechestvennaya voyna 1941-1945 godov v 12 t. M.: Voenizdat; Kuchkovo pole, 2011-2015.
Vishlev O.V. General Vlasov v planakh gitlerovskikh spetssluzhb // Novaya i noveyshaya istoriya. 1996. № 4. S. 131-140
Vishlev O.V. Nakanune 22 iyunya 1941 goda. Dokumental nye ocherki. M.: Nauka, 2001. 320 s.
Voyna i obshchestvo 1941-1945. V 2 kn. M.: Nauka, 2004. Kn. 1. 480 s.; Kn. 2. 411 s.
Grebennikov P.V. O popytkakh peresmotra khoda i itogov Vtoroy mirovoy voyny // Izvestiya Ural. un-ta. 2011. Ser. 1 Problemy obrazovaniya, nauki i kul tury. № 1 (86). S. 7-12.
God krizisa, 1938-1939. Dokumenty i materialy: v 2 t. M.: Politizdat, 1990. T. 1. 554 s.; T. 2. 430 s.
Dashichev V. Rokovoe reshenie Stalina // Oglasheniyu podlezhit: SSSR-Germaniya. 1939-1941: Dokumenty i materialy / Sost. YU. Fel shtinskiy. M.: Mosk. rabochiy, 1991. 367 s. S. 12-24.
Dokumenty vneshney politiki. T. KHKHII. V 2 kn. M.: Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, 1992. Kn. 2. 1 sentyabrya-31 dekabrya 1939 g. 687 s.
Dokumenty vneshney politiki. T. KHKHIII. V 2 kn. M.: Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, 1995. Kn. 1. 1 yanvarya - 31 oktyabrya 1940 g. 750 s.
Drobyazko S. I. Russkaya Osvoboditel naya Armiya. M.: AST,1999. 44 s.
Drobyazko S. I. Vtoraya mirovaya voyna 1939-1945: Russkaya osvoboditel naya armiya. M.: ACT, 2000. 44 s.
Drugaya voyna 1939-1945. M.: RGGU, 1996. 490 s.
Evroparlament ob yavil pakt Molotova - Ribbentropa prichinoy Vtoroy mirovoy voyny // URL: https://www.yaplakal.com /forum1/topic2008482.html
I. Stalin o Velikoy Otechestvennoy voyne Sovetskogo Soyuza. M.: OGIZ, 1946. 186 s.
Istoriya Velikoy Otechestvennoy Voyny Sovetskogo Soyuza. 1941-1945. V 6 t. M.: Voenizdat, 1960-1965
Istoriya Vtoroy Mirovoy voyny 1939-1945. V 12 t. M.: Voenizdat, 1973-1982.
Kamynin V.D. Rossiyskaya istoricheskaya nauka v pervoy polovine 1990-kh gg. // Vestnik Ural. in-ta ekonomiki, upravleniya i prava. 2008. № 4(5). S. 93-105.
Karel skiy front v Velikoy Otechestvennoy voyne 1941-1945 gg.: Voenno-istoricheskiy ocherk. M.: Nauka, 1984. 359 s.
Kvitsinskiy YU.A. General Vlasov - put predatel stva. M.: Sovremennik, 1999. 320 s.
Kolesnik A.N. ROA - vlasovskaya armiya: Sudebnoe delo generala A.A. Vlasova. KHar kov: Prostor, 1990. 78 s.
Kolesnik A.N. Grekhopadenie. General Vlasov i ego okruzhenie. KHar kov, 1991. 237 s.
Kolesnik A.N. General Vlasov-predatel ili geroy M.: Izd-vo Tekhinvest , 1991. 175 s.
Komintern i vtoraya mirovaya voyna. V 2 ch. M.: Pamyatniki istoricheskoy mysli, 1994. CH. 1 Do 22 iyunya 1941 g. 554 s.; CH. 2 Posle 22 iyunya 1941 g. 594 s.
K 70-letiyu nachala Vtoroy mirovoy voyny: issledovaniya, dokumenty, kommentarii. M.: In-t rossiyskoy istorii RAN, 2009. 486 s.
Mirovye voyny KHKH veka: V 4 kn. Kn. 3. Vtoraya mirovaya voyna: Istoricheskiy ocherk. M.: Nauka, 2002. 597 s.; Kn. 4: Vtoraya mirovaya voyna: Dokumenty i materialy. M.: Nauka, 2002. 677 s.
Na rokovom poroge (iz arkhivnykh materialov 1939 g.) // Voprosy istorii. 1989. №11. S. 87-112.
Narochnitskaya N.A. Partitura Vtoroy mirovoy. Kto i kogda nachal voynu M., Veche. 2009. 237 s.
Nevezhin V. A. Sindrom nastupatel noy voyny. Sovetskaya propaganda v preddverii svyashchennykh boev 1939-1941. M.: AIRO-XX, 1997. 288 s.
Nevezhin V. A. Esli zavtra v pokhod M.: YAuza, Eksmo, 2007. 320 s.
Oglasheniyu podlezhit: SSSR-Germaniya. 1939-1941: Dokumenty i materialy / Sost. YU. Fel shtinskiy. M.: Mosk. rabochiy, 1991. 367 s.
Organy Gosudarstvennoy bezopasnosti v Velikoy Otechestvennoy voyne. Sb. dok. V 8 t. M.: Rus ; Kuchkovo pole, 1995-2008.
Orlov A.S. Stalin v preddverii voyny. M.: Izd-vo Eksmo, 2003. 416 s.
Petrovskiy L. P. Delo Nekricha // Vestnik RAN. 1995. T. 65. Vyp. 6. S. 528-539.
Polpredy soobshchayut : Sbornik dokumentov ob otnosheniyakh SSSR s Latviey, Litvoy i Estoniey: Avgust 1939 g.-avgust 1940 g. M.: Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, 1990. 544 s.
Reshin L.E., Kudryashov S.V. Osvoboditeli. Vlasov i vlasovtsy // Rodina. 1992. №8-9. S. 84-95.
Reshin L.E., Stepanov B.C. Sud by general skie. Byl li general Vlasov ubezhdennym protivnikom Sovetskoy vlasti // Voenno-istoricheskiy zhurnal. 1993. №6. S. 21-28.
Rozanov G.L. Stalin-Gitler. Dokumental nyy ocherk sovetsko-germanskikh diplomaticheskikh otnosheniy 1939-1941 gg. M.: Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, 1991. 224 s.
Rossiya v KHKH v. Voyna 1941-1945 gg.: sovremennye podkhody. M.: Nauka, 2005. 567 s.
Russkiy arkhiv: Velikaya Otechestvennaya. Nakanune voyny: materialy soveshchaniya vysshego komandnogo sostava RKKA, 23-31 dekabrya 1940 g. M.: TERRA, 1993. T. 12. 408 s.
Russkiy arkhiv: Velikaya Otechestvennaya. Prikazy narodnogo komissara oborony SSSR, 1937-21 iyunya 1941 g. M.: TERRA, 1994-1998. T. 13. Kn. 1-3.
Sakharov A.N. O novykh podkhodakh v rossiyskoy istoricheskoy nauke. 1990-e gody // Istoriya i istoriki, 2002: Istoriogr. vestn. M.: Nauka, 2002. S. 3-28.
Sakharov A.N., D yakov YU.L., Kolodnikova L.L. Predislovie // Voyna 1941-1945 godov: sovremennye podkhody. M.: Nauka, 2005. S. 5-14.
Sekrety Gitlera na stole u Stalina: razvedka i kontrrazvedka o podgotovke germanskoy agressii protiv SSSR, mart-iyun 1941 gg. M.: Mosgorarkhiv, 1995. 256 s.
Semiryaga M.I. Tayny stalinskoy diplomatii. 1939-1941. M.: Vysshaya shkola, 1992. 303 s.
Semiryaga M.I. Voennye, kollaboratsionisty i general Vlasov // Rossiya XX vek. Drugaya voyna, 1939-1945. M.: RGGU, 1996. S. 313-339.
Semiryaga M.I. Kollaboratsionizm. Priroda, tipologiya i proyavleniya v gody Vtoroy mirovoy voyny. M.: ROSSPEN, 2000. 863 s.
Skrytaya pravda voyny: 1941 god. Neizvestnye dokumenty. M.: Russkaya kniga, 1992. 380 s.
Sovetskiy Soyuz v gody Velikoy Otechestvennoy voyny 1941-1945. M.: Nauka, 1985. 711 s.
Solonin M. 22 iyunya, ili Kogda nachalas Velikaya Otechestvennaya voyna M.: Eksmo, YAuza, 2005. 512 s.
Stenograficheskiy otchet o zasedanii Komissii po protivodeystviyu popytkam fal sifikatsii istorii v ushcherb interesam Rossii // URL: http://www.kremlin.ru/events /administration/5336
1939 god: uroki istorii. M.: Mysl , 1990. 508 s.
1941: dokumenty i materialy: k 70-letiyu nachala Velikoy Otechestvennoy voyny: v 2 t. SPb : FGBU Prezidentskaya biblioteka imeni B. N. El tsina , 2011. T. 1. 415 s.; T. 2. 575 s.
Fal sifikatory istorii (Istoricheskaya spravka). M.: OGIZ, Gospolitizdat, 1948. 79 s.
CHubar yan A.O. Rossiyskiy evropeizm. M.: OLMA-PRESS, 2006. 414 s.
SHubin A.V. Mir na krayu bezdny. Ot global nogo krizisa k mirovoy voyne. 1929-1941 gody. M.: Veche, 2004. 576 s.
Boffa D. Istoriya Sovetskogo Soyuza. V 2 t. M.: Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya , 1994. T. 1. 628 s.; T. 2. 632 s.
Vert N. Istoriya sovetskogo gosudarstva. 1900-1991 / Per. s fr. M.: Progress: Progress-Akademiya, 1992. 480 s.
Gorodetskiy G. Mif Ledokola : Nakanune voyny / Per. s angl. M.: Progress-Akademiya, 1995. 352 s.
Gorodetskiy G. Rokovoy samoobman: Stalin i napadenie Germanii na Sovetskiy Soyuz / Per. s angl. M.: ROSSPEN, 2008. 384 s.
Nekrich A.M. 1941. 22 iyunya. M.: Pamyatniki istoricheskoy mysli, 1990. 335 s.
Suvorov V. Ledokol. Kto nachal Vtoruyu mirovuyu voynu : Nefantasticheskaya povest -dokument. M.: AO Izdatel skiy dom Novoe vremya , 1992. 352 s.
Suvorov V. Den -M. Kogda nachalas Vtoraya mirovaya voyna : Nefantasticheskaya povest -dokument. Kn. 2-ya. M.: AO Vse dlya Vas , 1994. 256 s.
Suvorov V. Poslednyaya respublika. Pochemu Sovetskiy Soyuz proigral Vtoruyu mirovuyu voynu. M.: TKO AST, 1995. 480 s.
Suvorov V. Ten pobedy. M.: AST, 2002. 410 s.
Suvorov V. Rasskazy osvoboditelya. M.: OOO Izd-vo Dobraya kniga , 2015. 410 s.
Flyayshkhauer I. Pakt. Gitler, Stalin i initsiativa germanskoy diplomatii. 1938-1939. M.: Progress, 1990. 480 s.
KHosking Dzh. Istoriya Sovetskogo Soyuza. 1917-1991 gg. M.: Vagrius, 1994. 510 s.
Das nationalsozialistische Deutschland und die Sowjetunion, 1939-1941. Akten aus dem Archiv des Deutscher Auswartigen Aruts, Department of State. 1948; Nazi-Soviet Relations, 1939-1941. Dokuments from the Archives of The German Foreign Office, Department of State, 1948. 300 r.
81. Die Welt. 1989. 23 m rz.
Keywords:
The great Patriotic war, historiography, discourse, victory anniversaries, falsification of history.


Related Articles

History and Theory of Politics Pages: 15-20 DOI: 10.33693/2223-0092-2023-13-1-15-20 Issue №22854
Discourse Theory as a Methodology for Conflictological Analysis of Regional Ethnopolitical Processes
discourse social cognition reproduction of information levels of social space actors of social and political discourse
Show more
HISTORY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY Pages: 96-102 DOI: 10.33693/2658-4654-2021-3-3-96-102 Issue №19560
Modern Historiography of Problems of Metallurgy Development in Russia in the Second Half of the XIX Century and Industrial Policy
XIX century metallurgy state industrial policy historiography
Show more
13. Philosophy of history and modern historical researches Pages: 152-159 Issue №10327
Different points of view in the history of Russia: world outlook
the state the historical process historiography methodology logic
Show more
2. Theory and history of law and state; History of law and State teachings Pages: 97-100 Issue №12435
ACTIVITIES OF BODIES OF INTERNAL AFFAIRS OF KABARDINO-BALKARIA DURING THE GREAT PATRIOTIC WAR
police the bodies of internal Affairs The great Patriotic war Kabardino-Balkaria the organization
Show more
Social and Political Philosophy Pages: 123-130 DOI: 10.33693/2223-0092-2023-13-2-123-130 Issue №22898
Discourses and Epistems as Contexts of the Dispersion of “Newspeak” (Based on the Philosophy of M. Foucault)
newspeak discourse episteme authority knowledge
Show more
History of Russia Pages: 127-138 DOI: 10.33693/2658-4654-2021-3-1-127-138 Issue №18317
Aviation metallurgy in the Urals during Great Patriotic War (1941-1945)
The Great Patriotic War aviation metallurgy industrial production in the Urals formation and development of raw materials base and metalworking manufacturing
Show more
Historiography, Source Studies and Methods of Historical Research Pages: 85-99 Issue №15872
“OPTIMISTS” AND “PESSIMISTS” ABOUT THE REASONS OF THE RUSSIAN REVOLUTION
Russian revolution historiography political and economic problems discussion welfare
Show more
HISTORIOGRAPHY Pages: 106-112 DOI: 10.33693/2658-4654-2023-5-1-106-112 Issue №24033
The Study of The Armenian Diaspora in the Tyumen Region in Modern Literature
Tyumen region Armenian Diaspora historiography migrations
Show more
Historiography, Source Studies and Methods of Historical Research Pages: 77-84 Issue №15872
MODERN RUSSIAN HISTORIOGRAPHY THE PARTY-STATE NOMENCLATURE OF THE URALS 1920-s-1930-s
Ural historiography party-state nomenclature power social portrait
Show more
HISTORY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY Pages: 114-118 DOI: 10.33693/2658-4654-2021-3-3-114-118 Issue №19560
Military Development and Military Formations in the Territory of Perm Province During the First World War: to the Historiography of the Problem
historiography Russian Imperial Army World War I Perm province Kazan military district
Show more