The phenomenon of obviousness and uncertainty of an objective approach to understanding the corpus delicti through the prism of the views of scientists of the late 19th - early 21st centuries
( Pp. 151-155)

More about authors
Komyagin Roman Alexandrovic lecturer of criminal and penitentiary law department
Saratov State Law Academy
Saratov, Russian Federation
Abstract:
Today, it seems possible to state the presence of dualism within the general doctrine of the corpus delicti. In contrast to the «normative», the representatives of the objectivist approach consider the corpus delicti, along with the crime, as a real phenomenon. Namely, only a system of elements and signs embodied in objective reality can form the composition of a specific crime committed. The presented understanding makes it possible to determine the corpus delicti as the only basis for criminal liability, as well as to build the correlation between the crime and the corpus delicti as one-order categories. However, a detailed study and critical analysis of the works of scientists, representatives of this approach, allow us to point out a number of problems that indicate its theoretical incompleteness, and as a consequence, requiring study and improvement. As a result, the author of the article presents the key points in the evolution of scientific thought about the formation and development of an objectivist approach to understanding the corpus delicti from the end of the 19th to the beginning of the 21st century, allowing you to get a holistic view of its phenomenon, including both obvious and contradictory aspects. Subject of research: norms of the current criminal legislation, which are based on the category of corpus delicti, published scientific works (article, monographs) and educational materials devoted to the general doctrine of the corpus delicti. Purpose: the formation in the science of criminal law of a system understanding of the phenomenon of an objective approach to understanding the corpus delicti, its main provisions and controversial aspects, aimed at overcoming the existing and achieving a unified understanding of the corpus delicti. Conclusion: Since, within the framework of the objectivist approach, the corpus delicti, the elements and features that form its structure, are considered as real phenomena, it becomes possible to structure a specific crime, as well as to establish the basis of criminal liability. However, a number of provisions do not allow to recognize this vision of the corpus delicti as devoid of contradictions.
How to Cite:
Komyagin R.A., (2020), THE PHENOMENON OF OBVIOUSNESS AND UNCERTAINTY OF AN OBJECTIVE APPROACH TO UNDERSTANDING THE CORPUS DELICTI THROUGH THE PRISM OF THE VIEWS OF SCIENTISTS OF THE LATE 19TH - EARLY 21ST CENTURIES. Gaps in Russian Legislation, 6 => 151-155.
Reference list:
Babiy N.A. Uchenie o strukture i sostave prestupleniya: monografiya. V 2 kn. Kn. 1. Ponyatie struktury i sostava prestupleniya. - M.: YUrlitinform, 2019.
Belogrits-Kotlyarevskiy L.S. Uchebnik Russkogo Ugolovnogo prava. CHast 1. M.: YUzhno-russkoe knigoizdatel stvo F.A. YUgansona, 1903. CHast 1.
Borbat A.V., Zavidov B.D., Endol tseva A.V., Milevskiy A.I. Sostav prestupleniya kak osnovanie ugolovnoy otvetstvennosti (problemnye voprosy ugolovnogo prava Rossii) /// SPS Konsul tantPlyus , 2005.
Gerasimov A.M. Obshchestvennaya opasnost prestupleniya: ponyatie, struktura, sushchnostnye kharakteristiki. Mir yuridicheskoy nauki. № 8. 2018.
Karpushin M.P., Kurlyandskiy V.I. Ugolovnaya otvetstvennost i sostav prestupleniya. M., YUridicheskaya literatura , 1974.
Krylova N.E. Diskussionnye voprosy ucheniya o sostave prestupleniya. Vestn. Mosk. un-ta. Ser. 11. Pravo. 2012. № 4.
Kuznetsova N.F. Problemy kvalifikatsii prestupleniy: Lektsii po spetskursu Osnovy kvalifikatsii prestupleniy / Nauch. red. i predisl. akademika V.N. Kudryavtseva. - M.: Izdatel skiy Dom Gorodets , 2007.
Morozov V.I., Losev S.G. Ponyatie sostava prestupleniya v otechestvennoy teorii ugolovnogo prava. YUridicheskaya nauka i pravookhranitel naya praktika, № 2 (40). 2017.
N.F. Kuznetsova, V.N. Kudryavtsev. Izbrannye trudy (sbornik). Izd-vo YUridicheskiy tsent Press , 2003.
Orazdurdyev A.M. Vidy sostavov prestupleniy v ugolovnom prave: monografiya. - M.: YUrlitinform, 2019.
Plotnikov A.I. Ob ektivnoe i sub ektivnoe v prestuplenii. Diss. dokt. yurid. nauk. M. 2012.
Sakharov A.B. K voprosu o ponyatii sostava prestupleniya. Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i pravo. 1952. № 7.
Sovetskoe ugolovnoe pravo. CHast Obshchaya / pod red. V.D. Men shagina, N.D. Durmanova, P.S. Romashkina. M., 1962.
Solodov I.A. Obshchestvennaya opasnost prestupleniya i ee ugolovno-pravovoe izmerenie. Diss. kand. yurid. nauk. Saratov, 2013.
Tagantsev N.S. Russkoe ugolovnoe pravo. T. 1. Tula, 2001.
Ter-Akopov A.A. Prestuplenie i problemy nefizicheskoy prichinnosti v ugolovnom prave. M.: YUrkniga. 2003.
Traynin A.N. Obshchee uchenie o sostave prestupleniya. M., Gosyurizdat. 1957.
Traynin A.N. Sostav prestupleniya po sovetskomu ugolovnomu pravu. Gosyurizdat. M., 1951.
Filimonov V.D. Norma ugolovnogo prava. SPb.: Izdatel stvo R. Aslanova YUridicheskiy tsentr Press , 2004.
CHankhay Lun. Uchenie o sostave prestupleniya po ugolovnomu pravu KNR i Rossii: sravnitel no-pravovoe issledovanie: avtoref. dis. kand. yurid. nauk. Vladivostok, 2009.
Keywords:
corpus delicti, objectivist approach, crime, correlation of crime and corpus delicti, grounds for criminal liability.


Related Articles

1. Theory and history of law and state; History of law and State teachings Pages: 14-16 Issue №5143
Terminology of criminality in the area of drug trafficking
drug addiction narcotic substance psychotropic substance drug trafficking crime
Show more
11. YOUNG SCIENTISTS IN ACTUAL CRIMIAL LAW PROBLEMS SOLVING Pages: 234-237 Issue №17728
Criminal law analysis of the disposition of the norm on a crime that infringes on the authors ' personal non-property rights
Copyright related rights violation crime legislation
Show more
2. SCIENTIFIC SCHOOL OF DOCTOR OF SCIENCE, PROFESSOR ShHAGAPSOEV Z.L. Pages: 162-164 Issue №7907
THE CONCEPT OF THE STATE OF MIGRATION POLICY TO 2025: FIRST RESULTS AND FOLLOW THE WAY OF REALIZATION
migration policy migrants security voluntary resettlement of compatriots crime
Show more
4. Employment Law; Right to social security; Land law; Natural resource law; Environmental law; Pages: 172-174 Issue №4539
Legal problems of the transplantation of human organs and tissues in Russia and foreign countries
health workers transplantation donation biomaterials the removal of organs
Show more
11. Criminal law and criminology; Criminal enforcement law Pages: 171-174 Issue №3758
The factors assisting to involve minors in committing antisocial activities
crime minors right family society
Show more
11. YOUNG SCIENTISTS IN ACTUAL CRIMIAL LAW PROBLEMS SOLVING Pages: 223-226 Issue №17728
Measures to prevent violence against government officials
crime prevention prevention elimination minimization
Show more
11. Theory and history of law and state; History of law and State teachings Pages: 185-188 Issue №9089
RURAL CRIME IN THE USSR FROM 1958-1970
the people's courts crime the image of the criminal the countryside the code of criminal procedure
Show more
8. Forensics; Forensic expertise; Operational and search activities Pages: 165-169 Issue №5746
Issues in the Substantive Legal Defense of Defendants Having been Subject to Entrapment in the Course of Investigation
operatively-search activity provocative-inflammatory action the distinction between legitimate experiment and provocation crime the circumstance excluding criminality of act
Show more
3. CRIMINAL, CRIMINOLOGICAL, ADMINISTRATIVE AND OTHER MEASURES FOR COUNTERING CRIME IN CONTEMPORARY CONDITIONS Pages: 209-212 Issue №21729
Problems of Qualification of Crimes Committed in the State of Alcoholic Drunk
alcohol intoxication crime drunkenness affect physiological intoxication
Show more
2. Theory and history of law and state; History of law and State teachings Pages: 125-127 Issue №11986
Some issues of domestic criminal law in the second half of the XVIII - early XIX century
crime criminal law punishment types of criminal penalties
Show more