To the Question of the Current State of the Methods of Implementation (Transformation) of International Legal Norms into the System of Russian Law
( Pp. 145-152)

More about authors
Ilovaisky Igor Borisovich Cand.Sci.(Law), Associate Professor, Associate professor of the department of civil law disciplines
Volgograd Institute of Management (branch) of Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration
Volgograd, Russian Federation Turov George Sergeevich Assistant of legal adviser
«Regional law company», LLC
Volgograd, Russian Federation
Abstract:
The purpose of the study. The proposed research examines both the general theoretical aspects of the use of the terms implementation and transformation in domestic law, and the correlation of the content of these terms with each other. The article analyzes the provisions of the Vienna Convention on the Law of International Treaties (concluded in Vienna on 23.05.1969) and the norms of Federal Law No. 101-FZ dated 15.07.1995 "On International Treaties of the Russian Federation", which determine the procedure for introducing the norms of international law into the system of national legislation. The specific ways of transformation (implementation) of international legal norms characterizing the stage of giving final consent to the implementation of the norms of international law are investigated: ratification, approval, acceptance or accession to an international treaty. The theoretical and normative aspects of the ratification procedure are analyzed in detail, the legal essence and role of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation in its implementation are revealed, and the specifics of this kind of process in the Republic of Kazakhstan and in Russia are compared. Special attention is devoted to the analysis of acceptance and approval procedures as elements of transformation. Their legal features, subject composition, some aspects of the registration and entry into force of the norms of international law on the territory of the Russian Federation in their implementation are revealed. The problems of the correlation of the legal force of the norms of international law implemented on the basis of different methods of transformation are presented, as a result of which certain critical remarks are made about their consolidation and classification in domestic legislation. We believe that these arguments will contribute to the improvement of both the content of normative acts and law enforcement practice in the analyzed area of public relations. Conclusions. As a result of the conducted research, the authors draw an unambiguous conclusion - it is necessary to more accurately and in detail determine the content and procedure for implementing the implementation procedures established in Federal Law No. 101-FZ of 15.07.1995 "On International Treaties of the Russian Federation". Such a measure will allow, firstly, to summarize the long-term scientific discussion on these issues; and, secondly, it will clarify and eliminate possible abuses in the practical implementation of the norms under consideration. At the same time, it is proposed to use the positive experience of the Republic of Kazakhstan in terms of conducting scientific examinations of draft federal laws on the ratification of international treaties for their compliance with the norms of not only national, but also international law.
How to Cite:
Ilovaisky I.B., Turov G.S., (2022), TO THE QUESTION OF THE CURRENT STATE OF THE METHODS OF IMPLEMENTATION (TRANSFORMATION) OF INTERNATIONAL LEGAL NORMS INTO THE SYSTEM OF RUSSIAN LAW. Gaps in Russian Legislation, 1 => 145-152.
Reference list:
Abdildina, D. B. On some features of the scientific examination of draft international treaties / D. B. Abdildina // Bulletin of the Institute of Legislation and Legal Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan. - № 5 (54). - 2018. - Pp. 161-166.
Balkhaeva, S. B. Types of entry into force of international treaties of the Russian Federation / S. B. Balkhaeva // Journal of Russian Law. - № 8 (176). - 2011. - Pp. 56-64.
Balkhaeva, S. B. Entry into force of international treaties as a result of accession / S. B. Balkhaeva // Journal of Russian Law. - № 7 (223). - 2015. - Pp. 131-141.
Balkhaeva, S. B. Multilateral international treaties of the Russian Federation: features of entry into force / S. B. Balkhaeva // Journal of Russian Law. - № 10 (190). - 2012. - Pp. 82-89.
Balkhaeva, S. B. Development of legislation on the entry into force of international treaties in the Soviet period / S. B. Balkhaeva // Bulletin of the Russian State Humanitarian University. Series «Economics. Control. Right». - № 3 (83). - 2012. - Pp. 193-201.
Vdovin, V. A. Implementation of international legal norms in the criminal law of the Russian Federation (issues of the General part): dis. ... cand. legal Sciences: 12.00.08: defended 05.10.2006 / V. A. Vdovin. - Ulyanovsk, 2006. - 234 p.
Vylegzhanin, A. N. International law. In 2 parts. Part 1: textbook for universities / A. N. Vylegzhanin [and others]; resp. ed. A. N. Vylegzhanin. - 4th edition, revised and enlarged. - Moscow: Yurayt Publishing House, 2022. - 329 p.
Zheldybina, T. A. Implementation as a legal institution / T. A. Zheldybina // Bulletin of the Institute of Legislation and Legal Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan. - № 2 (34). - 2014. - Pp. 120-124.
Kichenina, V. S., Fesenko, E. A. Implementation of the pacta sunt servanda principle in modern international legal relations / V. S. Kichenina, E. A. Fesenko // Legal Science. - № 1. - 2020. - Pp. 71-75.
Kurashvili, A. Yu. The Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation in the process of concluding international treaties / A. Yu. Kurashvili // Law and Modern States. - № 3. - 2017. - Pp. 21-29.
Lifshits, I. M. International financial law and the law of the European Union: interaction and mutual influence: monograph / I. M. Lifshits. - Moscow: Yustitsinform, 2020. - 548 p.
Smaznov, D. A. Implementation of the norms of international law into the system of national law / D. A. Smaznov // Bulletin of a young scientist of the Kuzbass Institute: a collection of scientific articles. - Novokuznetsk: Kuzbass Institute of the Federal Penitentiary Service, 2019. - Pp. 48-51.
Sosnov, N. A. Implementation of the norms of international law into the Russian legal system based on various methods of implementation / N. A. Sosnov // Issues of Russian justice. - 2021. - № 13. - Pp. 13-19.
Sheverdyaev, S. N. Reflection of modern anti-corruption culture in Russian constitutional law: monograph / S. N. Sheverdyaev. - Moscow: Yustitsinform, 2020. - 320 p.
Shutkin, M. V. Ratification as a way of expressing consent to the binding nature of international treaties in the Russian Federation / M. V. Shutkin // Innovations and investments. - № 7. - 2013. - Pp. 135-140.
Keywords:
implementation, transformation, ratification, acceptance, approval, accession to international treaties.


Related Articles

1. CURRENT ISSUES OF SOCIO-ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT OF RUSSIA Pages: 7-10 Issue №9731
ACTUAL PROBLEMS OF STRUGGLE AGAINST COUNTERFEITED PHARMACEUTICAL PRODUCTION: CIVIL- AND CRIMINALLAW ASPECTS
counterfeit pharmaceuticals medications manufacturer implementation sales
Show more
10. International law; European Law Pages: 182-184 Issue №5975
NATIONAL MECHANISM OF IMPLEMENTATION OF INTERNATIONAL HUMANITARIAN LAW
implementation national mechanism of implementation international humanitarian law the regulatory means of implementation of international law organizational-legal means of implementing international law
Show more
5. Criminal; Criminal enforcement law Pages: 162-165 Issue №4982
ADJUSTMENT OF CRIMINAL CODE RUSSIAN FEDERATION FACTOR OF DEVELOPMENT OF MODERN CRIMINAL POLITICS
criminal policy criminal law transformation reform the concept
Show more
7. PRIVATE LAW (CIVIL) (5.1.3.) Pages: 213-217 Issue №20974
Innovation Assessment Activities (Essence, Content). Evaluation of Innovative Projects in Russia
innovation innovative development evaluation innovative activity innovative project
Show more
8. FINANCIAL LAW; TAX LAW; BUDGETARY LAW 12.00.04 Pages: 249-254 Issue №18758
Features of the international financial standards implementation process
implementation financial standard regulator sovereignty international financial law
Show more
5.2.3. REGIONAL AND SECTORAL ECONOMICS Pages: 239-242 Issue №20181
Analysis of Digitalization of Industry in Russia
industry industrial complex transformation digitalization digital tools
Show more
11. CRIMINAL LAW AND CRIMINOLOGY; CRIMINAL ENFORCEMENT LAW 12.00.08 Pages: 234-237 Issue №17214
Development of measures to prevent the financing of terrorism
terrorism financing prevention prevention crime
Show more
9. International law; European Law Pages: 167-170 Issue №6252
Analysis of the legal problems of correlation of international and national legal rules in the system of integration community of the states
international standards national standards international and regional organizations enterprises the Constitution
Show more
8. Judicial, prosecutorial, human rights and law enforcement activities Pages: 169-172 Issue №16219
SUFFICIENT POWERS TO CONTROLLING BODIES FOR EFFECTIVENESS OF PROSECUTOR'S SUPERVISION OVER THE LAWS IMPLEMENTATION
prosecutor's office supervision enforcement laws legality
Show more
18. International law; European Law Pages: 164-167 Issue №11394
PROBLEMS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF INTERNATIONAL LAW NORMS IN SPAIN
implementation international Treaty Spain Congress of deputies The Senate Of Spain
Show more