Protection of the employee claims in case of employer’s insolvency: the analysis of world experience and its possible use in Russia
( Pp. 171-175)
More about authors
Ignatenko Anna Sergeevna
aspirant. Mesto ucheby: Moskovskiy gosudarstvennyy yuridicheskiy universitet imeni O.E. Kutafina (MGYuA). Podrazdelenie: kafedra trudovogo prava i prava socialnogo obespecheniya. Dolzhnost: rukovoditel yuridicheskogo otdela
Moscow state law university named after O.E.Kutafin (MSLA); Park development, LLC
Moscow state law university named after O.E.Kutafin (MSLA); Park development, LLC
Abstract:
Background: In this article on the example of experience of different countries are reviewed and analyzed methods that protect the rights of employees in case of insolvency (bankruptcy) of the employer. In conditions of economic instability that began in Russia in 2014, there is a high social importance of this issue, which makes it of relevance. The aim of the research is to analyze and identify, based on overseas experience, the most effective ways of improving the protection of employee claims in insolvency of the employer in Russia. Along with local experts, research to develop the most effective measures of legal protection of employee claims in case of bankruptcy of the employer, shall be held by such foreign scientists as Janis Sarra, Wang, H.Y. Materials and methods: Methodological and theoretical basis for the study was the works of domestic and foreign experts in this field. Of great importance in theoretical and practical aspect was generalizing scientific principles and mechanisms for the protection of the employee rights connection with insolvency in foreign countries. During conducting the research and presenting the material were applied scientific approaches (system approach) and methods of scientific cognition (analysis, deduction, scientific abstraction). Conclusions: On the basis of the conducted research, accordance with current economic situation the author of the article gives conclusions, justifies it, The author gives their rationale, and suggests measures to improve the protection of employee claims in insolvency of the employer in Russian Federation. Thus, in particular, the author proves the inefficiency of the system of privileges and the need to implement the guarantee (insurance) institutions; analyzes and points out the advantages and disadvantages of measures that provide additional protection for employee on the example of foreign experience; the conclusions on the effectiveness of the application in Russia the project of the Federal law "On compulsory social insurance against loss of earnings due to insolvency (bankruptcy) of the employer". Target audience: The publication can be useful for scientists and practitioners involved with solving problems in the protection of employee claims in insolvency of the employer, and graduate students involved in the study of the considered problem
How to Cite:
Ignatenko A.S., (2015), PROTECTION OF THE EMPLOYEE CLAIMS IN CASE OF EMPLOYER’S INSOLVENCY: THE ANALYSIS OF WORLD EXPERIENCE AND ITS POSSIBLE USE IN RUSSIA. Business in Law, 3 => 171-175.
Reference list:
Sm., naprimer: Anisimova L.V. Narushenie prav rabotnikov na voznagrazhdenie za trud pri nesostoyatel nosti (bankrotstve) rabotodatelya // Ombudsmen. 2012. N 2. S. 26 - 30;
Vedeev A., Predvaritel naya otsenka VVP po itogam 2014 goda - rost mezhdu 0,5-0,6 // Informatsiya s ofitsial nogo sayta Minekonomrazvitiya Rossii: lt;http://economy.gov.ru/minec/press/news/2015011411 gt;
Gerasimov I., Naberzhnov G., CHistyy ottok kapitala iz Rossii v 2014 godu sostavil 151,5 mlrd // RBK (16 yanvarya 2015 goda), dostupno v Internete: lt;http://top.rbc.ru/finances/16/01/2015/54b96c5e9a7947490508d8d2 gt;; Peremitin G., Ottok kapitala iz Rossii v oktyabre uskorilsya do maksimuma s nachala goda // RBK (20 noyabrya 2014 goda), dostupno v Internete: top.rbc.ru/finances/20/11/2014/546e4dcfcbb20f9821a97755
Sm. podrobnee: Ignatenko A.S. Zashchita prav rabotnikov na oplatu truda pri nesostoyatel nosti rabotodatelya // Aktual nye problemy rossiyskogo prava. № 7 iyul 2014 g.;
Schetnaya palata otsenila poteri rossiyskogo byudzheta v 2015 godu // Interfaks (09 dekabrya 2014 goda), dostupno v Internete: lt;http://www.interfax.ru/business/411964 gt;
Kovan S.E., Ugrozy bankrotstv Rossiyskikh organizatsiy v usloviyakh mirovogo finansovogo krizisa // Effektivnoe antikrizisnoe upravlenie: http://info.e-c-m.ru/magazine/60/eau 60 11.htm
Lyutov N.L. Zashchita prava rabotnikov na zarabotnuyu platu v sluchae bankrotstva rabotodatelya: nesootvetstvie rossiyskogo zakonodatel stva mezhdunarodnym standartam // Trudovoe pravo. 2010. № 1. S. 77 - 82;
Lyutov N.L. Politika flexicurity v Evropeyskom soyuze i gibkoe regulirovanie truda v Rossii // Rossiyskoe pravo: Obrazovanie. Praktika. Nauka. 2011. № 4-5. S. 52-59.; Postanovlenie Pravitel stva RF ot 17.12.2014 N 1382 quot;O razmerakh minimal noy i maksimal noy velichin posobiya po bezrabotitse na 2015 god quot; // quot;Sobranie zakonodatel stva RF quot;, 22.12.2014, N 51, st. 7463;
Lyutov N.L. Proizvodstvennye sovety v Rossii: balans ekonomicheskikh i sotsial nykh prav // ZHurnal rossiyskogo prava. 2014. N 5. S. 95 - 104;
Mironova T.K. K voprosu ob opredelenii ponyatiya sotsial naya zashchita (pravovoy aspekt) // quot;Trudovoe pravo quot;, 2008, №3;
Del na 5 kopeek. Pri bankrotstve kompanii sotrudniki bez zarplaty ne ostanutsya // stat ya opublikovana na ofitsial nom sayte RSPP po adresu: http://www.rspp.ru/news/view/3364 gt;;
General noe soglashenie mezhdu obshcherossiyskimi ob edineniyami profsoyuzov, obshcherossiyskimi ob edineniyami rabotodateley i Pravitel stvom Rossiyskoy Federatsii na 2008 - 2010 gody // Rossiyskaya gazeta № 293, 28.12.2007;
Ponyatie kreditory, imeyushchie plavayushchee obespechenie dolga (floating security creditors) ne imeet pryamogo analoga v rossiyskom zakonodatel stve, dopolnitel no po dannomu voprosu sm.: Teplov N.V. Zalog tovarov v oborote: analiz instituta na primere floating charge // Vestnik VAS RF. 2013. N 10. S. 4 - 15; N 11. S. 75 - 101;
Proekt federal nogo zakona Ob obyazatel nom sotsial nom strakhovanii na sluchay utraty zarabotka vsledstvie bankrotstva rabotodatelya // razmeshchen v seti Internet po adresu: lt;http://regulation.gov.ru/project/11314.html point view project stage 3 stage id 9585 gt;;
Zaklyuchenie ob otsenke reguliruyushchego vozdeystviya na proekt federal nogo zakona Ob obyazatel nom sotsial nom strakhovanii na sluchay utraty zarabotka vsledstvie bankrotstva rabotodatelya // razmeshcheno v seti Internet po adresu: lt;http://regulation.gov.ru/project/11314.html point view project stage 3 stage id 9585 gt;.
Janis Sarra, Employee and Pension Claims During Company Insolvency. A Comparative Study of 62 Jurisdictions, (Toronto: Thomson Canada, 2008);
Wang, H.Y., An International Comparison of Insolvency Law (28 April 2006, OECD Report) at 4, available at: lt;www.oecd.org gt;;
Widening the Insolvency Lens: The Treatment of Employee Claims, in: Paul Omar (ed.), International Insolvency Law. Themes and Perspectives. Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing Limited, 2008, p. 320-321; China s new enterprise bankruptcy law : context, interpretation and application / edited by Rebecca Parry, Yongqian Xu, Haizheng Zhang, Ashgate Pub., 2010, p. 223;
Sukhanova M.G. Ob obnovlenii rossiyskogo zakonodatel stva o nesostoyatel nosti rabotodatelya // Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. 2012. N 2. S. 191 - 201;
Petrov A.YA. Problemy obespecheniya rabotnika zarabotnoy platoy v sluchae prekrashcheniya deyatel nosti rabotodatelya i ego neplatezhesposobnosti // quot;Zakonodatel stvo i ekonomika quot;, 2010, N 7;
Lyutov N.L. Zashchita prava rabotnikov na zarabotnuyu platu v sluchae bankrotstva rabotodatelya: nesootvetstvie rossiyskogo zakonodatel stva mezhdunarodnym standartam // Trudovoe pravo. 2010. № 1. S. 77 - 82;
Kulagina E., CHucha S. Uyazvimaya kategoriya kreditorov. Evropeyskaya sotsial naya khartiya i zashchita rabotnikov pri bankrotstve organizatsiy v Rossii // Kadrovik. Trudovoe pravo dlya kadrovika. 2009. N 11. S. 4 - 10
Vedeev A., Predvaritel naya otsenka VVP po itogam 2014 goda - rost mezhdu 0,5-0,6 // Informatsiya s ofitsial nogo sayta Minekonomrazvitiya Rossii: lt;http://economy.gov.ru/minec/press/news/2015011411 gt;
Gerasimov I., Naberzhnov G., CHistyy ottok kapitala iz Rossii v 2014 godu sostavil 151,5 mlrd // RBK (16 yanvarya 2015 goda), dostupno v Internete: lt;http://top.rbc.ru/finances/16/01/2015/54b96c5e9a7947490508d8d2 gt;; Peremitin G., Ottok kapitala iz Rossii v oktyabre uskorilsya do maksimuma s nachala goda // RBK (20 noyabrya 2014 goda), dostupno v Internete: top.rbc.ru/finances/20/11/2014/546e4dcfcbb20f9821a97755
Sm. podrobnee: Ignatenko A.S. Zashchita prav rabotnikov na oplatu truda pri nesostoyatel nosti rabotodatelya // Aktual nye problemy rossiyskogo prava. № 7 iyul 2014 g.;
Schetnaya palata otsenila poteri rossiyskogo byudzheta v 2015 godu // Interfaks (09 dekabrya 2014 goda), dostupno v Internete: lt;http://www.interfax.ru/business/411964 gt;
Kovan S.E., Ugrozy bankrotstv Rossiyskikh organizatsiy v usloviyakh mirovogo finansovogo krizisa // Effektivnoe antikrizisnoe upravlenie: http://info.e-c-m.ru/magazine/60/eau 60 11.htm
Lyutov N.L. Zashchita prava rabotnikov na zarabotnuyu platu v sluchae bankrotstva rabotodatelya: nesootvetstvie rossiyskogo zakonodatel stva mezhdunarodnym standartam // Trudovoe pravo. 2010. № 1. S. 77 - 82;
Lyutov N.L. Politika flexicurity v Evropeyskom soyuze i gibkoe regulirovanie truda v Rossii // Rossiyskoe pravo: Obrazovanie. Praktika. Nauka. 2011. № 4-5. S. 52-59.; Postanovlenie Pravitel stva RF ot 17.12.2014 N 1382 quot;O razmerakh minimal noy i maksimal noy velichin posobiya po bezrabotitse na 2015 god quot; // quot;Sobranie zakonodatel stva RF quot;, 22.12.2014, N 51, st. 7463;
Lyutov N.L. Proizvodstvennye sovety v Rossii: balans ekonomicheskikh i sotsial nykh prav // ZHurnal rossiyskogo prava. 2014. N 5. S. 95 - 104;
Mironova T.K. K voprosu ob opredelenii ponyatiya sotsial naya zashchita (pravovoy aspekt) // quot;Trudovoe pravo quot;, 2008, №3;
Del na 5 kopeek. Pri bankrotstve kompanii sotrudniki bez zarplaty ne ostanutsya // stat ya opublikovana na ofitsial nom sayte RSPP po adresu: http://www.rspp.ru/news/view/3364 gt;;
General noe soglashenie mezhdu obshcherossiyskimi ob edineniyami profsoyuzov, obshcherossiyskimi ob edineniyami rabotodateley i Pravitel stvom Rossiyskoy Federatsii na 2008 - 2010 gody // Rossiyskaya gazeta № 293, 28.12.2007;
Ponyatie kreditory, imeyushchie plavayushchee obespechenie dolga (floating security creditors) ne imeet pryamogo analoga v rossiyskom zakonodatel stve, dopolnitel no po dannomu voprosu sm.: Teplov N.V. Zalog tovarov v oborote: analiz instituta na primere floating charge // Vestnik VAS RF. 2013. N 10. S. 4 - 15; N 11. S. 75 - 101;
Proekt federal nogo zakona Ob obyazatel nom sotsial nom strakhovanii na sluchay utraty zarabotka vsledstvie bankrotstva rabotodatelya // razmeshchen v seti Internet po adresu: lt;http://regulation.gov.ru/project/11314.html point view project stage 3 stage id 9585 gt;;
Zaklyuchenie ob otsenke reguliruyushchego vozdeystviya na proekt federal nogo zakona Ob obyazatel nom sotsial nom strakhovanii na sluchay utraty zarabotka vsledstvie bankrotstva rabotodatelya // razmeshcheno v seti Internet po adresu: lt;http://regulation.gov.ru/project/11314.html point view project stage 3 stage id 9585 gt;.
Janis Sarra, Employee and Pension Claims During Company Insolvency. A Comparative Study of 62 Jurisdictions, (Toronto: Thomson Canada, 2008);
Wang, H.Y., An International Comparison of Insolvency Law (28 April 2006, OECD Report) at 4, available at: lt;www.oecd.org gt;;
Widening the Insolvency Lens: The Treatment of Employee Claims, in: Paul Omar (ed.), International Insolvency Law. Themes and Perspectives. Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing Limited, 2008, p. 320-321; China s new enterprise bankruptcy law : context, interpretation and application / edited by Rebecca Parry, Yongqian Xu, Haizheng Zhang, Ashgate Pub., 2010, p. 223;
Sukhanova M.G. Ob obnovlenii rossiyskogo zakonodatel stva o nesostoyatel nosti rabotodatelya // Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. 2012. N 2. S. 191 - 201;
Petrov A.YA. Problemy obespecheniya rabotnika zarabotnoy platoy v sluchae prekrashcheniya deyatel nosti rabotodatelya i ego neplatezhesposobnosti // quot;Zakonodatel stvo i ekonomika quot;, 2010, N 7;
Lyutov N.L. Zashchita prava rabotnikov na zarabotnuyu platu v sluchae bankrotstva rabotodatelya: nesootvetstvie rossiyskogo zakonodatel stva mezhdunarodnym standartam // Trudovoe pravo. 2010. № 1. S. 77 - 82;
Kulagina E., CHucha S. Uyazvimaya kategoriya kreditorov. Evropeyskaya sotsial naya khartiya i zashchita rabotnikov pri bankrotstve organizatsiy v Rossii // Kadrovik. Trudovoe pravo dlya kadrovika. 2009. N 11. S. 4 - 10
Keywords:
Protection, bankruptcy, failure, privilege, guarantee funds.
Related Articles
INTERNATIONAL SCIENTIFIC AND PRACTICAL CONFERENCE «COUNTERACTION CRIME: CURRENT PROBLEMS OF THEORY AND PRACTICE» MAY 20-21, 2022, NALCHIK, NORTH CAUCASUS INSTITUTE FOR PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT (BRANCH) KRASNODAR UNIVERSITY OF THE MINISTRY OF INTERNAL AFFAIRS OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1. CRIMINALISTIC, PROCEDURAL AND OPERATIVE-SEARCH MEASURES TO COUNTER CRIME IN THE GLOBALIZATION CONDITIONS Pages: 24-27 Issue №21338
On the Issue of Ensuring the Safety, Protection of the Rights and Freedoms of Victims in the Framework of Criminal Proceedings
security
criminal proceedings
victim
protection
rights and freedoms
Show more
1. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 18-21 Issue №8598
The constitutional and international protection of human rights in the social state
The Constitution Of The Russian Federation
protection
human rights
Declaration of human rights
Show more
1. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 23-26 Issue №5413
THE PARTICIPATION OF THE AUTHORITIES OF PRESIDENTIAL POWER IN THE PROTECTION OF THE RIGHTS AND FREEDOMS OF HUMAN AND CITIZEN
The President of the Russian Federation
Garant
the rights and freedoms of man
protection
lawmaking
Show more
1. Theory and history of law and state; History of law and State teachings Pages: 16-18 Issue №4210
Some aspects of the unification of the concept of "potentially dangerous and critical facilities"
potentially dangerous and critical objects
infrastructure
protection
security
categories of objects
Show more
Pages: 21-23 Issue №2286
Realization of property of the debtor within bankruptcy procedure by means of the public offer: auction or public offer?
Bankruptcy
failure
private relationship
auction
public offer
Show more
Private Law (Civil) Sciences Pages: 35-41 DOI: 10.33693/2782-7372-2025-4-1-35-41 Issue №185581
The Right to Maintenance and the Right to Raise a Child: Problems of Provision in Practice
state
alimony
children
maintenance
protection
Show more
1. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 32-38 Issue №4539
Protection of the rights and freedoms of man and citizen in the Russian Federation and in European countries: a comparative legal analysis
Protection
rights and freedoms
people
citizen
The Constitution of the Russian Federation
Show more
private law (civil) Pages: 53-57 Issue №23832
Formation and Implementation of Legal Interests of Owners
protection
law
interest
constitution
civil code
Show more
1. SCIENTIFIC SCHOOL OF DOCTOR OF SCIENCE, PROFESSOR SHCHERBA SERGEJ PETROVICH Pages: 28-30 Issue №9149
PROTECTION OF PUBLIC AND PRIVATE INTERESTS THROUGH THE FILING AND MAINTENANCE OF A CIVIL ACTION BY THE PROSECUTOR IN THE CRIMINAL PROCESS
civil action
protection
public interest
the private interest
Show more
PRIVATE LAW (CIVIL) SCIENCES Pages: 51-55 Issue №150029
Specifics of the Formation of the Institution of Bankruptcy of Individuals in the Russian Federation
individual
citizen
insolvency
bankruptcy
law
Show more