Rule of law principle: evolution of doctrines of legal understanding in national and international law
( Pp. 92-100)
More about authors
Umnova-Koniukhova Irina A.
Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Director of Constitutional Law Studies at the Сenter of Justice Research in the Russian State University of Justice
Сenter of Justice Research in the Russian State University of Justice
Moscow, Russian Federation Nikolaev Vladimir Alexandrovich aspirant kafedry konstitucionnogo prava imeni N.V.Vitruka Rossiyskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta pravosudiya (g. Moskva). Konsultant otdela apparata Upolnomochennogo po pravam cheloveka v Rossiyskoy Federacii.
Russian state university of justice
Moscow, Russia
Сenter of Justice Research in the Russian State University of Justice
Moscow, Russian Federation Nikolaev Vladimir Alexandrovich aspirant kafedry konstitucionnogo prava imeni N.V.Vitruka Rossiyskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta pravosudiya (g. Moskva). Konsultant otdela apparata Upolnomochennogo po pravam cheloveka v Rossiyskoy Federacii.
Russian state university of justice
Moscow, Russia
Abstract:
The principle of the rule of law is currently rather uncertain in the scientific and law enforcement spheres, which leads to an unjustified expansion of the rule of law criteria. The purpose of the study is to consider the evolution of the doctrines of legal understanding of the rule of law in the national constitutional and international law on the basis of comparative legal analysis of domestic constitutional and international legal practice. Objectives of the study: to analyze the narrow and broad understanding of the rule of law, to give a critical assessment of the unjustified expansion of the rule of law criteria, as well as to analyze the judicial practice of national and international justice on the example of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation and the ECHR. Conclusions: The authors proposes an approach to the definition of the rule of law through the doctrine of a narrow and broad understanding of this principle. Contradictory positions of the bodies of national constitutional and international justice on the example of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation and the ECHR are revealed. Originality/value: the article can be useful for scientists, jurists, judges, specialists and any specialist, which are interested in the problems of constitutional law.
How to Cite:
Umnova-Koniukhova I.A., Nikolaev V.A., (2015), RULE OF LAW PRINCIPLE: EVOLUTION OF DOCTRINES OF LEGAL UNDERSTANDING IN NATIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL LAW. Gaps in Russian Legislation, 6 => 92-100.
Reference list:
Daysi A.V. Osnovy gosudarstvennogo prava Anglii pod redaktsiey prof. P.G. Vinogradova. M. - 1905. - 681 s.
Ellinek G. Obshchee uchenie o gosudarstve: Uchebnoe posobie. - SPb.: YUridicheskiy tsentr-Press, 2004. - 752 s.
Marchenko M.N., Deryabina E.M. Teoriya gosudarstva i prava: uchebno-metodicheskoe posobie. - 2-e izd., Moskva: Prospekt, 2015. - 720 s.
Fuller L.L. Moral prava, per. s angl. T.Danilovoy. - Moskva, CHelyabinsk: IRISEN, Sotsium, 2016. - 308 s. (Seriya Pravo ).
SHarandin YU.A., Kravchenko D.V. Verkhovenstvo prava, pravovoe gosudarstvo i drugie mezhdunarodnye pravovye doktriny: lingvisticheskie aspekty konvergentsii i razgranicheniya /Doktriny pravovogo gosudarstva i verkhovenstva prava v sovremennom mire: Sb. statey. Otvetstvennye redaktory: V.D. Zor kin, P.D. Barenboym - M.: LUM, YUstitsinform, 2013. - 560 s.
Alec Stone, The Birth of Judicial Politics in France: The Constitutional Council in Comparative Perspective (1992). F.L. Morton, Judicial Review in France: A Comparative Analysis, 36 Am.J. Comp.L.89 (1988).
Brian Z. Tamanaha, On the Rule of Law - History, Politics, Theory (2004) Chapter 9.
Hadley Arkes The Natural Law Challenge // The Harvard Journal of Law Public Policy. Volume 36, Number 3 - Summer 2013, P.961-975.
Hurd J. The international rule of law and the domestic analog // Global constitutionalisn.- Cambridge,2015/- Vol.4,N 3.P.365-395.
Ian Brownlie The Politics of Human Rights in Relation to the Rule of Law // Indian Journal of International Law. Vol.49. 2009.
James Wilson. The Works of James Wilson (Chicago, Callaghan Co., James DeWitt Andrews ed.,1896).- P.298-300.
Kanetake M., Nollkaemper A. International rule oflaw in the cycle of contestations and deference// Amsterdam center for international law: Research paper.- Amsterdam, 2015.- P. 3-14. - Mode of access:http://works.be-press.com/machiko kanetake/12/
Kommers D.P. The Constitutional Jurisprudence of the Federal Republic of Germany. Dunham, London: Duke University Press, 1997.
Loughlin M. The Rule of Law in European Jurisprudence. European Commission for Democracy Through Law (Venice Commission) Study 512/2009, CDL-JD(209) 004 (Strasbourg, 29 May 2009).
Pech, L. Rule of Law in France/L.Pech//Asian Discourses of Rule of Law. Theories and implementation of Rule of Law in Twelve Asian Countries. France and the US.//R.P.Peerenboom (ed.). - L.: Routledge, 2004. - P71
Stern K. Staatsrecht der Bundes republik Deutschland. 2nd ed.Munich, 1984.
Raymond Carr de Malberg. Contribution la Th orieg n rale de l Etat 1920 (Paris: Dalloz, 2004). Vol. 1, 228-243 (tsit. V Loughlin). P. 638
Ellinek G. Obshchee uchenie o gosudarstve: Uchebnoe posobie. - SPb.: YUridicheskiy tsentr-Press, 2004. - 752 s.
Marchenko M.N., Deryabina E.M. Teoriya gosudarstva i prava: uchebno-metodicheskoe posobie. - 2-e izd., Moskva: Prospekt, 2015. - 720 s.
Fuller L.L. Moral prava, per. s angl. T.Danilovoy. - Moskva, CHelyabinsk: IRISEN, Sotsium, 2016. - 308 s. (Seriya Pravo ).
SHarandin YU.A., Kravchenko D.V. Verkhovenstvo prava, pravovoe gosudarstvo i drugie mezhdunarodnye pravovye doktriny: lingvisticheskie aspekty konvergentsii i razgranicheniya /Doktriny pravovogo gosudarstva i verkhovenstva prava v sovremennom mire: Sb. statey. Otvetstvennye redaktory: V.D. Zor kin, P.D. Barenboym - M.: LUM, YUstitsinform, 2013. - 560 s.
Alec Stone, The Birth of Judicial Politics in France: The Constitutional Council in Comparative Perspective (1992). F.L. Morton, Judicial Review in France: A Comparative Analysis, 36 Am.J. Comp.L.89 (1988).
Brian Z. Tamanaha, On the Rule of Law - History, Politics, Theory (2004) Chapter 9.
Hadley Arkes The Natural Law Challenge // The Harvard Journal of Law Public Policy. Volume 36, Number 3 - Summer 2013, P.961-975.
Hurd J. The international rule of law and the domestic analog // Global constitutionalisn.- Cambridge,2015/- Vol.4,N 3.P.365-395.
Ian Brownlie The Politics of Human Rights in Relation to the Rule of Law // Indian Journal of International Law. Vol.49. 2009.
James Wilson. The Works of James Wilson (Chicago, Callaghan Co., James DeWitt Andrews ed.,1896).- P.298-300.
Kanetake M., Nollkaemper A. International rule oflaw in the cycle of contestations and deference// Amsterdam center for international law: Research paper.- Amsterdam, 2015.- P. 3-14. - Mode of access:http://works.be-press.com/machiko kanetake/12/
Kommers D.P. The Constitutional Jurisprudence of the Federal Republic of Germany. Dunham, London: Duke University Press, 1997.
Loughlin M. The Rule of Law in European Jurisprudence. European Commission for Democracy Through Law (Venice Commission) Study 512/2009, CDL-JD(209) 004 (Strasbourg, 29 May 2009).
Pech, L. Rule of Law in France/L.Pech//Asian Discourses of Rule of Law. Theories and implementation of Rule of Law in Twelve Asian Countries. France and the US.//R.P.Peerenboom (ed.). - L.: Routledge, 2004. - P71
Stern K. Staatsrecht der Bundes republik Deutschland. 2nd ed.Munich, 1984.
Raymond Carr de Malberg. Contribution la Th orieg n rale de l Etat 1920 (Paris: Dalloz, 2004). Vol. 1, 228-243 (tsit. V Loughlin). P. 638
