On the Problem of the Correlation of the Categories of Freedom of Labor and Right to Labor in the Constitutional Doctrine and Decisions of the Russian Federation Constitutional Court
( Pp. 40-44)
More about authors
Kanakova Anna Evgenievna
kand. yurid. nauk, docent kafedry konstitucionnogo i mezhdunarodnogo prava
Altai State University
Barnaul, Russia
Altai State University
Barnaul, Russia
Abstract:
Task: The fundamental law of the state acts as the base of some explanation of legal categories, constructions. The inaccuracy in conveying the constitutional categories embodied in the constitutional norms generates either some misunderstanding or ambiguity of such understanding. An example of such an inaccuracy can be the provision of Article 37 of the RF Constitution on the rights and freedoms in labor sphere. To explain the sense of the appropriate constitutional provisions one should analyze the essence and contents of the categories of “freedom of labor” and “right to labor”. Nowadays the problem of understanding the given categories is interesting for legal community not only in Russia but abroad (V.V. Zhernakov, the Ukraine, K.K. Urzhinsky, Belorussia, etc.) Materials and methods: The research base of the work is compiled from scientific views of jurists, normative legal sources and materials of court practice analyzed through general and special methods of scientific cognition. Conclusions: In the article the author gives the over-all appreciation of the constitutional categories “freedom of labor” and “right to labor”, analyses their essence, determines the content of the given categories and reveals the peculiarities of the way of establishing the given provisions in the RF Constitution. Possibility of subsequent use of the results of the scientific work: The author made a special contribution to the research of the subject-matter by introducing a number of concrete proposals directed at removing some inaccuracies in the formulation of separate legal norms of the Russian legislation. Social consequences: The introduction of these changes allows the members of the society to understand their labor constitutional rights and freedoms more precise and it can be one of the conditions for defending them more effective. Originality and importance: The results of the given work can be useful for jurists I regulating the provisions on freedom of labor and right to labor in various spheres of man’ life, law scientists in research, law students to understand the essence of the constitutional provisions on freedom of labor and right to labor.
How to Cite:
Kanakova A.E., (2015), ON THE PROBLEM OF THE CORRELATION OF THE CATEGORIES OF FREEDOM OF LABOR AND RIGHT TO LABOR IN THE CONSTITUTIONAL DOCTRINE AND DECISIONS OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION CONSTITUTIONAL COURT. Gaps in Russian Legislation, 5 => 40-44.
Reference list:
Arzamasov YU.G., Afanas ev V.S., Babaev V.K., Bozh ev V.P., Vitruk N.V. Nauchno-prakticheskiy kommentariy k Konstitutsii Rossiyskoy Federatsii. M., YURAYT, 2009. 871 s.
Artamonov V.V. Sudebnaya zashchita konstitutsionnoy svobody truda v Rossiyskoy Federatsii: Diss. kand.yurid.nauk. : 12.00.02. : Voronezh, 2006. 258 s.
Volkova O.N., YAroshenko D.N. Pravo na trud v sovetskoy i rossiyskoy pravovoy nauke: istoricheskie aspekty // Trud i sotsial nye otnosheniya. 2014. №4. 104-107 s.
Voronov I.YU. Svoboda truda v trudovykh pravootnosheniyakh // Vestnik MGPU. Seriya YUridicheskie nauki . 2009. №1 (3). 89-93 s.
Zobnina I.V. Znachenie Konstitutsii RF v rossiyskom trudovom prave: diss. kand.yurid.nauk.: Perm . 1999. 188 s.
Krasnoyarova E.V. Svoboda truda i ee ogranicheniya v sfere primeneniya naemnogo truda // Prolog law. 2014. №2. 20-24 s.
Leshchenko A.KH. Perspektivy pravotvorchestva sub ektov RF po realizatsii prav i svobod grazhdan v sfere truda // Teoriya i praktika obshchestvennogo razvitiya. 2014. №15. 130-132 s.
Mikaelyan A.S. Konstitutsionnye garantii prava na trud grazhdan Rossiyskoy Federatsii // Vestnik magistratury. 2015. № 3(42). 143-145 s.
Presnyakov, M.V. Konstitutsionnyy printsip svobody: formy i vidy realizatsii // Grazhdanin i pravo. 2012. №8. 37-38 s.
Radchenko, D.A. Konstitutsionnoe prava cheloveka na trud i mekhanizm ego realizatsii v Rossiyskoy Federatsii: dis. kand.yurid.nauk.: 12.00.02.: M. 2004. 216 s.
Sofronova T.V. Realizatsiya prava na trud litsami s invalidnost yu. Istoriya i sovremennost . // Vestnik Nizhegorodskogo universiteta im. N.I. Lobachevskogo, 2014, №3 (2). 222-224 s.
Stavtseva A.I. Razreshenie trudovykh sporov (Sudebnaya zashchita ot neobosnovannykh perevodov i uvol neniy). M.: ZAO quot;Biznes shkola Intel-Sintez quot;, 1998. 288 s.
Tuganov YU.N., Bystrov P.G. Problemy realizatsii sud yami, prebyvayushchimi v otstavke, konstitutsionnogo prava na trud. // Vestnik ZabGU. 2014. №08 (111). 154-166 s.
Ebzeev, B.S. Konstitutsiya, vlast i svoboda v Rossii: Opyt sinteticheskogo issledovaniya. M.: Prospekt. 2014. 336 s.
YAroshenko D.N. Pravo na trud v sovremennoy Rossii: avtoref. dis. kand.yurid.nauk.: 12.00.05. M., 2014. 28 s.
Artamonov V.V. Sudebnaya zashchita konstitutsionnoy svobody truda v Rossiyskoy Federatsii: Diss. kand.yurid.nauk. : 12.00.02. : Voronezh, 2006. 258 s.
Volkova O.N., YAroshenko D.N. Pravo na trud v sovetskoy i rossiyskoy pravovoy nauke: istoricheskie aspekty // Trud i sotsial nye otnosheniya. 2014. №4. 104-107 s.
Voronov I.YU. Svoboda truda v trudovykh pravootnosheniyakh // Vestnik MGPU. Seriya YUridicheskie nauki . 2009. №1 (3). 89-93 s.
Zobnina I.V. Znachenie Konstitutsii RF v rossiyskom trudovom prave: diss. kand.yurid.nauk.: Perm . 1999. 188 s.
Krasnoyarova E.V. Svoboda truda i ee ogranicheniya v sfere primeneniya naemnogo truda // Prolog law. 2014. №2. 20-24 s.
Leshchenko A.KH. Perspektivy pravotvorchestva sub ektov RF po realizatsii prav i svobod grazhdan v sfere truda // Teoriya i praktika obshchestvennogo razvitiya. 2014. №15. 130-132 s.
Mikaelyan A.S. Konstitutsionnye garantii prava na trud grazhdan Rossiyskoy Federatsii // Vestnik magistratury. 2015. № 3(42). 143-145 s.
Presnyakov, M.V. Konstitutsionnyy printsip svobody: formy i vidy realizatsii // Grazhdanin i pravo. 2012. №8. 37-38 s.
Radchenko, D.A. Konstitutsionnoe prava cheloveka na trud i mekhanizm ego realizatsii v Rossiyskoy Federatsii: dis. kand.yurid.nauk.: 12.00.02.: M. 2004. 216 s.
Sofronova T.V. Realizatsiya prava na trud litsami s invalidnost yu. Istoriya i sovremennost . // Vestnik Nizhegorodskogo universiteta im. N.I. Lobachevskogo, 2014, №3 (2). 222-224 s.
Stavtseva A.I. Razreshenie trudovykh sporov (Sudebnaya zashchita ot neobosnovannykh perevodov i uvol neniy). M.: ZAO quot;Biznes shkola Intel-Sintez quot;, 1998. 288 s.
Tuganov YU.N., Bystrov P.G. Problemy realizatsii sud yami, prebyvayushchimi v otstavke, konstitutsionnogo prava na trud. // Vestnik ZabGU. 2014. №08 (111). 154-166 s.
Ebzeev, B.S. Konstitutsiya, vlast i svoboda v Rossii: Opyt sinteticheskogo issledovaniya. M.: Prospekt. 2014. 336 s.
YAroshenko D.N. Pravo na trud v sovremennoy Rossii: avtoref. dis. kand.yurid.nauk.: 12.00.05. M., 2014. 28 s.
Keywords:
freedom of labor, the right to work, the contents, the constitutional court.
Related Articles
1. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 11-14 Issue №5215
The Constitutional Court and the key problems of the Criminal Procedure legislation
The Constitutional Court
constitutional proceedings
the criminal process
judicial review
Show more
11. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 124-129 Issue №11007
PERSONAL RIGHTS AND FREEDOMS IN MODERN SERBIAN CONSTITUTION
the Constitution of Serbia 2006
The rights and freedoms of man
Personal rights and freedoms
The right to life
The dignity of the person
Show more
9. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 102-106 Issue №9731
THE MODERN BASIS OF THE LEGAL STATUS OF THE AUTONOMOUS PROVINCE OF VOJVODINA
The Constitution of Serbia 2006
Administrative autonomy
The system of bodies of Autonomous education
The Autonomous province of Vojvodina
The Statute of the Autonomous province of Vojvodina
Show more
8. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 96-100 Issue №9479
THEORY AND PRACTICE OF FORMATION OF CONSTITUTIONAL CONTROL BODY: EXPERIENCE OF SERBIA
The Serbian Constitution of 2006
The constitutionality and legality
The constitutional court
The law on the constitutional court
The election of judges of the constitutional court
Show more
GAPS IN THE LAW, INTERNATIONAL PUBLIC LAW, INTERNATIONAL PRIVATE LAW Pages: 96-99 Issue №2286
Gaps in the criminal procedure legislation, caused by the recognition of norms unconstitutional
The Constitutional Court
criminal procedure law
a gap in the law
the analogy of law
analogy of the law
Show more
10. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 113-118 Issue №11076
ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL RIGHTS IN THE CONSTITUTION OF SERBIA 2006
The Constitution of Serbia 2006
The rights and freedoms of man
Socio-economic rights
The right of ownership
The right of inheritance
Show more
11. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 118-123 Issue №11007
FREEDOM OF LABOR AND RIGHT TO LABOR IN THE OFFICIAL AND ALTERNATIVE DRAFTS OF THE CONSTITUTION OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION
drafts of the Constitution
the right to work
freedom of labor
Show more
10. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 126-131 Issue №11076
TOPICAL ISSUES OF CONSTITUTIONAL PROCEEDINGS IN SERBIA
The Constitution of Serbia 2006
The law on the constitutional court
The constitutional court
The constitutionality and legality
The constitutional appeal
Show more
9. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 114-119 Issue №9525
TO THE QUESTION ABOUT THE STATUS OF JUDES OF BOSNIAN CONSTITUTIONAL COURT
The Constitution of Bosnia and Herzegovina, 1995
The constitutional court
The rules of the constitutional court of Bosnia and Herzegovina
The election of judges of the constitutional court
Status of judges the constitutional court
Show more
9. Constitutional law; Constitutional judicial process; Municipal law Pages: 97-101 Issue №9731
THE CONSTITUTIONAL COURT AS A DEFENDER OF STATE INTEGRITY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SERBIA
The Constitution of Serbia 2006
Administrative autonomy
The system of bodies of Autonomous education
The Autonomous province of Vojvodina
The Statute of the Autonomous province of Vojvodina
Show more